Amy Robach DUMPS TJ Holmes For Cheating On Her At Their Engagement Party| TJ’s Ex-Wife CLOWNS Amy | HO’

The fairytale is officially dead. What was supposed to be Amy Robach and TJ Holmes’ picture-perfect second chance at love has gone up in flames — and this time, the plot twist is straight out of a soap opera.

Sources close to the couple confirm that Amy Robach has called off her engagement to former Good Morning America co-anchor TJ Holmes after catching him cheating on her — at their own engagement party.

Yes, you read that right. The same night TJ stood before friends and family delivering an emotional speech about “forever love,” he was allegedly sneaking around with another woman. And now, the internet is losing its collective mind.

The “Forever Love” That Lasted One Night

Just days ago, Robach and Holmes seemed to be basking in their happily-ever-after moment. The pair proudly announced their engagement on their joint podcast, telling fans they’d been keeping the news secret for a month.

“We are sharing with all of you that we are engaged and we’ve been engaged for just about a month now,” Amy gushed. TJ added, “We wanted to let you all know before anybody else was able to. We’ve learned that lesson in the past.”

It was supposed to be their redemption arc — two star-crossed lovers who weathered scandal and career fallout to find peace in each other’s arms. But according to multiple insiders, that peace didn’t last long.

“Amy was completely blindsided,” one insider told InTouch Weekly. “She truly thought they were in a great place. She had no clue he was still messing around.”

History Repeats Itself — With a Twist

For anyone who followed their controversial romance, this outcome feels like déjà vu. Fans online have wasted no time pointing out the irony: the way you get them might be the way you lose them.

Because let’s not forget — both Amy and TJ were still married when their workplace affair was exposed in 2022. Their on-set chemistry at Good Morning America was the talk of the town, but when photos of the pair holding hands and getting cozy leaked to the press, their secret relationship became a public scandal.

They lost their high-profile GMA gigs, their reputations took a hit, and their families were torn apart. But the two stood by each other — insisting their love was real, not just an affair born out of chaos.

Now, karma seems to have come full circle.

“People don’t feel sorry for Amy,” one fan wrote on X. “She knew what she was doing. You lose them how you get them.”

Another user added: “If he could cheat on his wife for you, he can cheat on you too. Simple math.”

The Engagement Party Disaster

According to sources close to the couple, the now-infamous engagement party was supposed to mark a fresh chapter. Friends say Amy spared no expense, inviting close friends and family to celebrate their union.

But somewhere between the toasts and the champagne, things went downhill.

“Word on the street is that TJ got caught hooking up with another woman at the same party,” one source said. “It’s like something out of a movie — except way messier.”

The insider says Amy found out before the night was over. “She confronted him. He tried to deny it, but she had proof. It was humiliating.”

In the days that followed, Amy reportedly packed her things and left the apartment they shared in New York City.

A Pattern of Betrayal

Unfortunately for Amy, this isn’t the first time TJ Holmes’ name has been tied to infidelity rumors.

Long before their relationship made headlines, Holmes was allegedly involved with multiple women at ABC, including a 24-year-old script coordinator named Jasmine Pettaway.

According to Page Six, their affair began in 2015, when Jasmine reached out to Holmes for career mentorship. That mentorship allegedly turned physical — with their first encounter taking place in his office just hours before he went on air.

“It didn’t last long, but it was unprofessional and inappropriate,” said one insider familiar with the situation. “He took advantage of her trust.”

But that wasn’t all.

At the same time, Holmes was reportedly having another “off-the-books” fling with an overnight associate producer at Good Morning America. Witnesses claimed the pair were seen behind closed doors late one night — and what happened inside was “not work-related.”

“He turned that workplace into his own personal playground,” said another ABC staffer. “Everyone knew. People just didn’t talk about it.”

Amy’s Breaking Point

Sources say Amy was devastated when she learned about TJ’s history of affairs.

“She had no idea the extent of it,” one friend told People. “She knew about some rumors, but when she found out how many women there really were, she was sick.”

Amy reportedly realized that TJ’s interest in her might not have been as deep as she believed.

“She’s starting to think he only stayed with her because of the scandal,” the insider revealed. “He didn’t want to look like the bad guy who dumped the woman he got caught with. But he was never truly invested.”

The Cracks Were Already Showing

Even before the engagement party disaster, insiders say the couple’s relationship was showing serious strain.

According to InTouch Weekly, “The honeymoon phase is definitely over. They spend more time fighting than anything else.”

“They bicker constantly,” another source added. “The days of them being all over each other are gone. They’re realizing their whole relationship was built on lust, not love.”

Amy herself hinted at trouble during a recent podcast episode, revealing that TJ had a habit of “checking out” after arguments.

“Honestly, I’d rather have him yell at me than freeze me out for two days,” she said. “I spiral. I don’t know what to say or do.”

TJ admitted that communication was one of his weak points. “I’m really bad about this,” he said. “I don’t scream, I don’t yell — I just check out. I have to work on that.”

But fans were quick to point out that “checking out” might not have been the only thing he was doing.

Karma Has a Sense of Humor

As if things couldn’t get messier, TJ’s ex-wife, Marilee Fiebig, has been throwing subtle shade on social media ever since the breakup news dropped.

“She’s not saying much — but she doesn’t have to,” one source said. “Her posts about self-love and moving on say it all.”

And she’s not just winning the breakup emotionally. Fiebig, who was blindsided by TJ’s affair with Amy back in 2022, has since moved on — with Amy’s ex-husband, actor Andrew Shue.

Yes, the exes have swapped partners.

According to insiders, Marilee and Andrew bonded over their shared heartbreak. “They connected over their values and the pain they went through,” a mutual friend shared. “Now they’re thriving.”

The couple has reportedly launched a successful joint business venture and are living quietly — and happily — away from the spotlight.

“Marilee looks like the real winner here,” one fan wrote online. “Amy lost her job, her reputation, and now her man. Meanwhile, Marilee got her glow-up and Amy’s ex.”

Fallen From Grace

Since their scandal broke, both Amy and TJ have struggled to rebuild their careers. Their joint podcast has drawn modest attention, but no major network has been willing to take a risk on them.

“They’re basically blacklisted from morning television,” one insider told Radar Online. “Nobody wants to touch that drama again.”

Now, with the cheating allegations back in the headlines, insiders say any chance of a comeback is “officially dead.”

From Fairytale to Cautionary Tale

At this point, even Amy seems to realize that her “forever love” might have just been another headline waiting to happen.

“She’s heartbroken,” one close friend said. “But she’s also angry — mostly at herself. She risked everything for TJ, and now she’s realizing he’ll never change.”

Fans online have already turned her downfall into a lesson in internet karma. “A man who cheats with you will cheat on you,” one viral post read. “Always.”

Meanwhile, TJ’s ex is out here living her best life — unbothered, successful, and with Amy’s ex-husband by her side.

As one commenter put it, “Karma might take its time, but when it lands, it doesn’t miss.”

So while Amy Robach tries to pick up the pieces of her shattered engagement, Marilee and Andrew are proof that sometimes, the best revenge really is moving on — and looking good doing it.

Because if there’s one thing this Hollywood scandal has taught us, it’s that when you play with fire, you’re bound to get burned — and this time, Amy’s the one left holding the ashes.