Breakthrough in Lily and Jack Sullivan Case — Did Malehya Plan It? | HO!!

Nova Scotia, Canada —More than a year after the mysterious disappearance of siblings Lily and Jack Sullivan, new information has surfaced that could finally offer crucial insight into what happened on that fateful day in Upper Stuyak.

As the community continues to search for answers, a recent wave of statements from family insiders and witnesses is raising difficult questions about the actions of the children’s mother, Malehya Brooks Murray, and what may have truly unfolded on May 2, 2024.

This is the story of a missing persons case that has gripped Nova Scotia — and the disturbing possibility that what happened may not have been an accident at all.

The Disappearance

Lily and Jack Sullivan, young siblings living with their mother Malehya, her partner Daniel Martell, their baby sister Meadow, and Malehya’s mother Janie McKenzie, were last seen on their rural property in Upper Stuyak. The family reported the children missing on May 2, 2024, sparking an immediate search effort centered on the dense woods and muddy trails surrounding their home.

Search teams found two small bootprints: one near the pipeline trail, the other on the driveway, where search dogs reportedly lost the children’s scent. For weeks, authorities, volunteers, and family combed the area, but no trace of the children was found. The investigation soon stalled, and the case faded from national headlines — until now.

A Family Insider Comes Forward

In July 2025, a new voice emerged: Darren Gettis, a close relative of Malehya, appeared on the YouTube true crime show “A Crimeing Shame.” Speaking on behalf of Janie McKenzie, the children’s grandmother, Darren described a version of events that had never before been made public. He claimed to have shared these details with the RCMP, Westful Police, and other local authorities, but said his statements had not been acted upon.

According to Darren, the accepted narrative — that Lily and Jack simply wandered off into the woods while Malehya was distracted — is incomplete at best, and possibly a deliberate cover story.

The Morning of May 2

Darren alleges that on the morning of the disappearance, Janie McKenzie was unexpectedly present on the property, asleep in her trailer with her dog. Malehya and Daniel, he says, believed Janie was away overnight, possibly visiting a boyfriend. This, Darren claims, is why Malehya chose that particular morning to leave the house with the children, assuming no one else would be around to witness her actions.

But Janie was there. She was awoken by the sound of Lily’s distinctive “little screaming thing” — described by Darren as a playful shriek — and by Jack’s voice. Her dog began barking, and she realized the children were outside. Janie heard Malehya taking Lily and Jack out of the camper, leading them through the back of the property, outside the fenced area, and onto the gravel driveway.

Darren highlights a key detail: the night before, Janie had filled a pothole and ditch on the driveway with fresh gravel. It had rained, and the ground was muddy. The next morning, Janie noticed a single small bootprint sunk into the wet gravel — matching the spot where search dogs later lost the children’s scent. This, Darren says, is direct evidence that Lily and Jack left the property that morning, not simply wandered off later.

A Confrontation — and a Mystery

Janie came out of her trailer and saw Malehya standing with baby Meadow in her arms, looking at her phone. Janie confronted her: “Where’s the kids?” she demanded, knowing she had just heard them moments earlier. According to Darren, Malehya looked stunned, then answered, “They’re in the woods.” When pressed for how long they’d been gone, she replied, “20 minutes.” At that moment, Daniel came running out of the house, and the confusion escalated.

If true, this sequence raises troubling questions. How could Malehya lose track of two young children so quickly, especially with a barking dog and a fully fenced yard? Why did she appear surprised when asked about their whereabouts? And why did she not immediately sound the alarm?

The Friend with a Chilling Statement

In the hours after the disappearance, another strange episode unfolded. Darren recounts that a young woman, described as a friend of Malehya’s, arrived at the property. In front of police and other witnesses, this woman made a shocking claim: that the missing children were being “tucked into warm beds in New Brunswick.” When Janie confronted her, demanding to know how she could possibly know such a thing, the woman allegedly replied, “I’ll be visiting them in a few days.” Janie, furious, ordered her off the property.

Darren insists this was not idle gossip — several people, including police, heard the exchange. The woman, known to some as “the psychic,” has never been publicly identified.

A Theory of Abduction

Darren’s account suggests a theory that diverges sharply from the initial investigation. He believes Lily and Jack may have been taken from the property and transported to an Indigenous reserve — specifically, the Saint Regis Mohawk Reserve, which straddles the Canada-US border between Ontario and New York. This area, known for complex cross-border jurisdiction, could provide cover for moving children without immediate detection.

Supporting this theory, Darren cites a report from a hairdresser in Plattsburgh, New York, who claimed to have seen both Lily and Jack in her salon on May 26, 2024 — more than three weeks after their disappearance. Law enforcement has not confirmed this sighting.

Why No Amber Alert?

Despite these suspicious circumstances, no Amber Alert was ever issued for Lily and Jack. Darren explains that, under Canadian law, an Amber Alert requires confirmed abduction or imminent danger. While Janie reported seeing Malehya on the side of the road that day, she did not witness the children being transferred to another vehicle — a crucial detail for triggering an alert. Without that evidence, authorities may have felt their hands were tied.

Malehya’s Silence — and Deflection

When Darren’s claims were posted publicly, Malehya did not deny the specific allegations. Instead, she changed the subject, accusing Daniel of stealing from her TEU account and claiming he wasn’t committed to finding the children. When asked directly who she was protecting her youngest daughter Meadow from, Malehya replied with a single word: “CPS” — Child Protective Services.

This response has fueled speculation that Malehya may be attempting to shield all of her children from child welfare authorities, possibly out of fear of losing custody or facing legal consequences.

A Pattern of Evasion?

Darren insists that he has reported everything he knows to the RCMP, Westful Police, Stellarin Police, and other local agencies. He has also revealed that, due to being banned from his original Facebook account, he used the alias “Darwood O’Grady” to communicate with authorities and the public. Despite this, he says, his account has never changed.

Yet, a key question lingers: Why did Janie McKenzie not come forward with these details sooner? If her account is accurate, it could have dramatically altered the course of the investigation. Was it fear, confusion, or something more that kept her silent?

The Investigation Today

As of this writing, Lily and Jack Sullivan remain missing. The RCMP has not confirmed whether Darren’s testimony is part of their active investigation, nor have they commented on the theory that the children may have been transported across provincial or international borders. No arrests have been made, and the case remains open.

For many in the community, the new revelations have reopened old wounds — and raised new hopes that the truth might finally come out. Was this a tragic accident, a case of parental negligence, or a carefully planned disappearance? Did Malehya orchestrate the events of that morning, believing no one would notice? Or is she, too, a victim of circumstances beyond her control?

What Happens Next?

The fate of Lily and Jack Sullivan hangs in the balance, caught between rumor, suspicion, and the slow grind of official investigation. For their family, the agony of not knowing continues. For the public, the case is a chilling reminder of how easily children can vanish — and how hard it can be to uncover the truth.

Anyone with information about the whereabouts of Lily and Jack Sullivan is urged to contact local authorities immediately. As new details emerge, the hope remains that someone, somewhere, knows what really happened on that rainy morning in Upper Stuyak — and that the full story will finally be told.