Marvin Gaye Utterly Hated Diana Ross, Now We Know the Reason Why | HO!!!!

Motown’s Golden Mirage: The Fractured Truth Behind a Legendary Collaboration

In the shimmering haze of 1970s Motown, few pairings looked more perfect on paper than Marvin Gaye and Diana Ross. To the public, their joint album “Diana & Marvin” shimmered with promise—a marriage of two of the era’s brightest stars, both groomed under the watchful eye of Motown founder Berry Gordy. But beneath the glossy album cover, the reality was far grimmer.

As new sources and studio insiders now reveal, Marvin Gaye didn’t just dislike Diana Ross—he resented her, and the project, with a quiet fury that never faded.

This is the untold story of how Motown’s most dazzling duo became its most fractured, and why Marvin Gaye would later admit, “That album shouldn’t have happened.”

A Collision, Not a Collaboration

On the surface, Marvin Gaye and Diana Ross were Motown royalty—each with a string of hits, each a symbol of Black excellence at a time when the music industry was finally beginning to recognize it. But their worlds could not have been more different.

Gaye was the melancholic poet, a man whose music—especially the landmark “What’s Going On”—channeled the pain and hope of Black America. He was introspective, moody, and fiercely protective of his artistic integrity. Diana Ross, meanwhile, was Motown’s golden girl: dazzling, disciplined, always perfectly coiffed and camera-ready. Her rise from the Supremes to solo stardom was a testament to Gordy’s vision and her own relentless drive.

The problem? Neither wanted to work together.

The Command from Above

According to multiple Motown insiders, the idea for a Gaye-Ross duet album was not born of artistic yearning, but of business calculation. Berry Gordy, ever the mogul, saw dollar signs in the pairing. He issued the order: “You and Diana will create an album together.” For Gaye, it was a command, not a request—a bitter pill to swallow for an artist who had just fought for creative control over his own music.

“Marvin was already a legend by then,” recalls a former Motown engineer. “He didn’t want to be anyone’s backdrop. But nobody said no to Berry.”

Ross, for her part, was pregnant and exhausted from film and studio commitments. She didn’t relish the prospect of sharing the spotlight—especially not with a partner as unpredictable as Gaye.

Studio: A Cold War

The sessions that followed were a master class in avoidance. Gaye, who preferred recording late at night, would linger in the studio for hours, lost in smoke and his own thoughts. Ross arrived promptly, always with an entourage, always expecting the space to be cleared and the air to be smoke-free.

“They never recorded together,” says a technician who shuttled between the two. “Diana would ask, ‘Is he still here?’ If the answer was yes, she’d leave. They sang love songs together, but never looked each other in the eye—not once.”

The result was a patchwork: Gaye would lay down his vocals, then leave. Ross would listen to his track three times, record her part in a single take, and depart. There were no duets, only two voices spliced together by engineers.

A Battle of Wills

What made the sessions unbearable wasn’t personal animosity, but mutual resentment at being forced into roles neither wanted. Gaye felt suffocated by an environment that favored Ross at every turn. The arrangements skewed to her range; the songs were sweet, commercial love ballads, a far cry from the raw, socially conscious music he wanted to make.

“He felt like a prop,” says a close friend of Gaye’s. “He told me, ‘Music isn’t for anyone to command. This isn’t my story.’”

Ross, meanwhile, saw Gaye’s behavior—his smoking, his lateness, his brooding—as disrespectful. She was used to professionalism, punctuality, and control. The chaos of Gaye’s process unnerved her, especially as her pregnancy advanced.

The tension reached its peak during a now-legendary incident: after a long, silent standoff in the studio, Ross hurled a bunch of grapes at the wall. The room froze. Gaye said nothing. Gordy, for once, simply left.

The Aftermath: Two Worlds, Never Meeting

When “Diana & Marvin” was released in 1973, the album was a commercial success. Songs like “You’re a Special Part of Me” and “My Mistake (Was to Love You)” climbed the charts. But the chemistry was a mirage. There were no joint interviews, no shared performances, no promotional tours. Every photo showed Ross front and center, Gaye a step behind, his smile never reaching his eyes.

“People loved the music,” says a Motown publicist. “But if you listened closely, you could hear it—they weren’t singing to each other. They were singing past each other.”

Gaye never performed the songs live, never included them in his later compilations. In interviews, he would nod politely when asked about Ross, then quickly change the subject. He kept no personal recordings from the sessions—not a single demo or scrap of tape.

The System, Not the Singer

It would be easy to paint Gaye’s resentment as personal, but those closest to him insist otherwise. His anger was directed not at Ross, but at the system that forced two incompatible artists together for the sake of sales. He saw himself as a pawn, his artistry reduced to a backdrop for Motown’s queen.

“Barry didn’t just control Diana,” Gaye later reflected. “He controlled me, too. And neither of us realized it until it was too late.”

Ross, for her part, never spoke publicly about the sessions. She maintained her silence—no criticism, no defense, only a quiet withdrawal. When Gaye was murdered in 1984, Ross released the tribute song “Missing You.” It was subdued, respectful, and full of unspoken space—a fitting coda for a relationship defined by distance.

The Truth Behind the Music

Today, “Diana & Marvin” stands as a testament to Motown’s power—and its pitfalls. The album’s lush harmonies and romantic lyrics mask a collaboration that was anything but harmonious. For Gaye, it was a wound that never quite healed; for Ross, a chapter best left unspoken.

Industry insiders now agree: the album was an “organized deception,” a product of commercial calculation rather than creative chemistry. The public may have heard a love story, but the reality was a cold war—two stars forced to share a stage, each longing for their own spotlight.

Legacy: Respect in Silence

In the end, there was no explosion, no public feud—just a lingering chill. Gaye and Ross never disparaged each other, never aired their grievances in the press. Their silence was its own form of respect, a tacit acknowledgment that not all artists are meant to create together.

As one former Motown staffer put it, “Sometimes the greatest tribute is knowing when to stay silent. They knew it wasn’t real, but they never let it turn ugly.”

For Marvin Gaye, the pain was not about Diana Ross, but about being forced into a role that was never truly his. For Diana, it was the pressure of perfection, the weight of always being the center, even when she wanted to disappear. Both paid a price for Motown’s ambitions—a price that still echoes in every note of that polished, hollow album.

If you’ve ever felt trapped in a role that wasn’t yours, you’ll understand why Marvin Gaye resented Diana Ross—not as a person, but as a symbol of everything he fought against. Theirs was not a story of hatred, but of two souls forced apart by the very system that brought them together.

For more untold stories from the heart of music, subscribe to The Ledger. Because behind every hit, there’s a truth waiting to be heard.