I Tried Not To Stare At Her On Our First Date — She Smiled And Said “So You Like The Dress?”
I Tried Not To Stare At Her On Our First Date — She Smiled And Said “So You Like The Dress?”

I set my menu down on the white linen, straightened the cuff of my dark suit jacket, told Crystal she looked beautiful, and immediately gave my water glass more attention than any glass had ever earned. Across the candle and the small vase of white roses, she rested her forearms on the table, champagne silk catching the warm room light, and smiled when I looked back up.
“So, you like the dress?”
I had two clever answers ready, but what came out was, “I liked you before I knew you owned that dress.”
Her fingers stopped tapping the stem of her glass. The teasing edge in her smile softened. “Did you?”
Now, before I could decide whether honesty had just saved me or ruined me, the waiter arrived with our plates of seared trout and asked if we wanted fresh pepper. I was grateful for the interruption. Crystal was not.
She adjusted her fork and kept her eyes on me. “Before tonight,” she said, “you’ve only seen me running onto the slip with a clipboard and mud on my trousers.”
True. “And twice with coffee on your sleeve.”
“One of those cups was yours, Gordon.”
“It was.”
“I handed it to you right when the deck hands dropped the gate. Bad timing on my part.”
She laughed, warm and low. “You’re avoiding the question. What did you notice?”
Crystal White wasn’t fishing for reassurance. She looked comfortable in the dress — comfortable with me noticing it, and even more interested in whether I had noticed anything else.
“I watched you with that older couple from Raleigh three weeks ago,” I said. “The husband kept asking about winter on the lake. You could have sold him the view. Instead, you told him which cottages get drafty, where the wind hits hardest in January, and where to buy weather stripping. Then you left them alone at the rail until they stopped looking nervous.”
Crystal glanced down at her plate. “They needed to know what living here actually feels like, not what the brochure says.”
“Most agents want a signature before the ferry leaves.”
“I’m not most agents.”
“No,” I said. “That was the part I noticed.”
For a moment, she didn’t answer. Then she took a bite of trout, and the quiet between us became easier instead of awkward.
“Were you planning to tell me that tonight?” she asked.
“Eventually. I had a smoother version in mind.”
“What happened to it?”
“You asked a direct question.”
Crystal’s smile turned gentler. “I can live with direct.”
I was beginning to suspect the better move was to stop performing a second earlier than usual.
We ate without rushing. The Rowan Room was busy around us — silverware, low conversation, the glow of wall sconces against the dark windows over the cove. I learned that Crystal loved old houses with uneven floors and refused to call a shaded deck sunny just because it caught an hour of late light. She learned that I could identify three engine noises from forty feet away but had no useful opinion about decorative tile.
When the waiter came to clear our plates and ask about dessert, I was ready to ask for the check so she wouldn’t feel trapped into a long first date. Crystal picked up the dessert card.
“The lemon tart,” she said. “Two forks.”
That simple decision did more to settle me than any compliment could have. She wasn’t staying because I was buying dinner. She wanted another twenty minutes.
Outside, the mountain air had cooled. I walked her to her car with my hands in my jacket pockets.
“I have the early run Monday,” I said. “Six-thirty out of the south slip.”
“I know the schedule.” She leaned back against the driver’s door, her coat loose over the champagne dress. “I have a Northshore showing at ten. Are you free Tuesday evening?”
“I am.”
“Coffee by the marina?”
“Absolutely.”
She opened the door, then looked at me over the top of it. “And Tom — yeah. I’m glad you noticed the winter winds before the dress.”
I watched her drive away with the uncomfortable, pleasant realization that I wanted Tuesday to arrive faster.
On Monday morning, a thin layer of steam lifted from Lake Rowan toward the Blue Ridge Pines. My ferry, the Rowan Star, carried passengers only — sixty seats, an open deck, and a timetable that mattered more than people guessed until they were late for work.
At 6:25, a regular named Mr. Henderson hurried down the gangway, waving a rolled newspaper. “Hold on, Captain. My brother’s getting his thermos from the truck.”
I checked the clock beside the wheelhouse door. “Gate closes at 6:30. If he’s not across when the horn sounds, he gets the 7:15.”
“Come on, Tom. It’s forty seconds.”
“Forty seconds puts us behind the freight barge in the narrows.”
I stepped aside to let the last two commuters through. “Tell him to use those long legs.”
His brother made it with fifteen seconds left, breathing hard and laughing at himself. I latched the gate and gave the deckhand the castoff signal.
I liked people. I also liked delivering forty of them where I had promised to deliver them. Charm was useful at a boarding gate. It wasn’t a substitute for doing the job.
Crystal took the 9:45 crossing. I saw her from the wheelhouse as she came aboard in flat shoes, dark slacks, and a wool sweater, with a leather portfolio tucked under one arm. Friday night had been champagne silk and candlelight. Monday was practical shoes and a work bag. I liked both versions more than was convenient.
She caught me looking through the wheelhouse glass and lifted her travel mug in a small salute. She didn’t try to come up to the helm. She took a seat near the bow and let me work.
On the noon return, the boat was nearly empty. After we docked and the passengers cleared, I found her by the gangway studying two pages in a plastic sleeve.
“Rough showing?” I asked.
“Showing was fine. The listing sheet is another matter.” She tapped the page. “April took my description of the Miller cottage and turned it into bullet points. ‘Granite counters, lake views, prime investment opportunity.’ Sounds like every house in the county.”
“Exactly.”
Her frustration sharpened. “She cut the walk from the ferry. She thinks buyers will be scared by ten minutes uphill through rhododendrons.”
“Would they?”
“Some might.”
“Then they should know before they fall in love with the photographs.”
She folded the pages against her portfolio. “The walk smells like pine after rain, and you need real shoes on the shale. That matters if you’re going to live there.”
Her phone buzzed. She glanced at the screen, saw April’s name, and put the phone back into her pocket without answering.
“Still on for coffee tomorrow?” she asked.
“Four o’clock, right after my relief captain takes over.”
A small smile came back. “Don’t be late, Captain. I hear you’re strict about forty seconds.”
She headed toward the parking lot, pausing to let an older passenger through the gate.
I noticed noticing Crystal had become effortless. Not turning every useful thing I knew into another excuse to stand near her would take more discipline.
After she left the dock, Andrew McCann came out of the galley carrying a wrench. Andrew and I had been hiking together since college.
“You still good for Saturday?” he asked.
“Full Shining Rock loop. We’ve been protecting that day since May.”
“I’m good.”
“Full weekend off?”
“Full weekend off.”
“Good. If you cancel for another tourist charter, I’m eating all the trail jerky myself.”
“Threat noted.”
I said it easily, but the date mattered. The ferry took most of my weeks in forty-minute pieces. One whole day on a ridge with an old friend felt rare enough to guard.
Tuesday afternoon, Crystal and I took a corner table in the Marina Cafe. She had two versions of the Miller cottage description spread between our coffees.
“This was mine,” she said, tapping the longer page. “Morning light in the kitchen, the stone hearth, the walk from the ferry landing. And this is what April wants online.”
The second version was half as long. “‘Convenient lake access,'” I read. “That’s generous.”
“It’s vague. It’s also risky. The shoreline below the cottage is shale. Anyone assuming they can dock right under the house is going to be disappointed.”
“That’s the problem.” She sat back. “I don’t want my name under something that sounds polished but leaves out how the place actually works. The one part I haven’t verified is where the public trail meets the property boundary. The old survey is muddy there.”
“I know that split. I walk the public side every spring with the ranger, because our signs have to stay off private land.”
Her eyes brightened, then narrowed with caution. “Tom, I’m not asking you to do my job.”
“I know. I’m offering one piece I actually know. I can walk the upper section Thursday after my early run, mark the public turn, and give it back to you.”
“Just the trail.”
“Just the trail. I’m a boat captain. If I start writing real estate copy, we’ll both regret it.”
That got a smile out of her. “All right. Just the trail would help.” She put one fingertip on the page. “And I mean just the trail. I want to do the description myself.”
“I heard you. I like being invited back for coffee, so I have an incentive not to become unbearable.”
Her mouth twitched. “Good incentive.”
I slid the papers back to her side instead of hovering over them. The boundary didn’t make me feel less involved. If anything, it made the offer cleaner. She had given me one lane. I could do it well and stop.
“Now that we’ve settled that,” she said, “what are you doing for dinner tonight?”
“Tonight?”
“Tomorrow. A day when no clipboard is required.” She folded the pages and tucked them away. Her expression changed — not coy, not uncertain, deliberate. “Come by my place tomorrow around five. I have tea a client brought me from Charleston. We can talk about something that has nothing to do with houses.”
“It’s a date.”
She held my eyes. “Yes, Tom. It is.”
Crystal lived on the second floor of a converted brick dry-goods building two blocks from the waterfront. When I knocked at 5:00 on Wednesday, she opened the door in dark jeans and a cream knit sweater, her blonde hair pinned up with a wooden clasp.
“Come in. Boots by the door.”
Her work bag was closed on the dining table and pushed toward the wall. That detail pleased me more than it should have.
At the kitchen island, she held up two identical silver tins. “One is smoky black tea, one is peppermint. I moved them out of the paper bags last month and forgot to label them.”
I opened one, took a confident sniff, and handed it back. “Black tea. Definitely.”
She smelled the other. “Then this one must be peppermint.”
Five minutes later, I took a careful sip and nearly coughed peppermint through my nose. Crystal tried hers, stared into the mug, and started laughing.
“Mine tastes like a campfire.”
I looked at my mug. “So much for confident.”
She was still smiling when she tucked one leg beneath herself on the sofa and set her mug on the side table. “Tell me about the hike with Andrew.”
Most people heard “twenty miles” and asked what was wrong with us. Crystal asked where we were going.
“Shining Rock Wilderness. River start, long climb, then the balds. No engines, no schedule, no one asking when the four o’clock boat leaves.”
“You love the ferry.”
“I do. But on the water, I’m always listening for something. The engine note, wind against the canopy, somebody moving where they shouldn’t. On the ridge, I only have to pay attention to my own feet and whether Andrew remembered the filter.”
She nodded slowly. “A day when you don’t have to be the capable person in the room.”
The accuracy of it made me quiet. “Pretty much.”
She didn’t invite herself. She didn’t turn the hike into a joke. She let the answer sit.
I mentioned that my old hiking bottle leaked if it tipped sideways. Crystal stood, crossed to a pantry cabinet, and pulled down a forest-green insulated thermos with a screw-on cup.
“Take this.”
“I can buy one.”
“You can. Or you can use the perfectly good one collecting dust in my cabinet.” She handed it to me. “Bring it back clean after the hike. I use it for long showing days.”
I took the thermos. “Deal.”
She settled back onto the sofa. “Your turn.”
“My turn for what?”
“I asked about the hike. Ask me something that has nothing to do with a listing.”
I thought about it. “What do you do on a Sunday when nobody can reach you?”
Crystal smiled. “I walk through the old neighborhoods and look at porches.”
“That sounds suspiciously like work.”
“No clients, no measurements. I like seeing what people do with a place after the brochure is gone. Crooked flower pots, bikes under stairs, somebody’s dog in the one patch of sun.”
There it was again — the thing I had noticed before the dress. She liked houses most after they stopped being products.
“And I bake bread badly,” she added.
“I’m willing to take the risk.”
Her eyes held mine for a second longer than the joke required.
By the time the bad tea was gone, the room had darkened enough that the windows reflected us from the glass. I stood to leave. Crystal walked me to the landing.
“Thank you for coming over,” she said. “And for not asking about square footage once you got here.”
“I thought about it.”
“No, you didn’t.”
“No,” I admitted, “I didn’t.”
Her smile softened. “I like you better when you’re not trying to be useful every second.”
The line surprised me. I stepped close enough to make the air between us feel intentional without touching her. “I like you outside the office, too.”
“Good,” she said. “That’s the woman who asked you over.”
I carried the green thermos home and spent the walk to my truck thinking about how easily she had separated being helped from being owed.
On Thursday, I took the early afternoon ferry north as a passenger with a small daypack and Crystal’s survey notes. The public trail climbed through mountain laurel and old hemlock, then curved along the hillside toward the Miller property. A shower had passed through before dawn, leaving the shale dark and slick in the shaded sections. Near the creek, my right boot slid half a step on a flat stone, and I caught myself against a hemlock trunk. Nothing dramatic — but enough to make the phrase “easy walk” feel dishonest.
Ten yards farther on, runoff had cut a muddy groove across the path that would be simple in hiking shoes and annoying with grocery bags. I walked the section she hadn’t verified, checked the survey stakes, and marked the things that mattered: the slick shale near the creek, the footbridge, the muddy groove after rain, and the turn where the public path met the stone wall along the cottage boundary. The route stayed clear of the neighboring drive.
Crystal was on the back terrace when I arrived, measuring a sliding door. Her gaze dropped to the streak of dark mud up the side of my right boot before she looked at the pad in my hand.
“The trail’s clean,” I said, handing it to her. “Public the whole way to the wall. One slick patch by the creek and a muddy rut after rain. I marked both.”
She read my notes, relief showing before she tried to hide it. “This is exactly what I needed.”
“That’s all you needed from me.”
She looked up. “Meaning?”
“Meaning you get to decide what any of it sounds like on the page.”
That pleased her. She leaned against the railing and read one of her own revised paragraphs from the printout. It described the walk honestly — the climb, the footbridge, the fact that groceries would feel heavier on the way up — and somehow made the place sound more inviting, not less.
“That sounds like you,” I said.
“Better than ‘convenient lake access’ by a dangerous margin.”
She folded the page once and tucked it under her arm. The satisfaction on her face was small but unmistakable. I liked seeing it. More than that, I liked that my part was already over and I could stand beside her without searching for the next problem to solve.
For a second, I wanted to reach for her. I didn’t. We were on a client’s terrace in the middle of her workday, and wanting something wasn’t the same as needing to act on it.
Then her phone chimed. She read the message and exhaled through her nose. “April just added a Charlotte couple for Saturday at ten. The husband’s an architect. He wants to understand how the cottage sits on the slope.”
“You wanted buyers who care how it really lives.”
“I did. I also have cove clients at nine.”
“You’ll sort it.”
“I will.” But she said it while already opening her calendar.
We rode back across together. Crystal asked if I wanted a glass of water before my late ferry shift, so I followed her upstairs. I set my daypack by the door and dropped my cap and light jacket over the back of a chair.
Twenty minutes later, she was rinsing our glasses when she glanced toward my pack. “Did you confirm Saturday with Andrew?”
“Not yet.”
She turned off the water. “Why not?”
I shrugged into one sleeve. “I wanted to see how your client schedule landed first.”
Her expression changed. “Tom, it’s not a problem.”
“That wasn’t my question.”
“Do you want to do the hike?”
I almost gave her an easy answer. The trail wasn’t going anywhere. Andrew would understand. We could always go next month. All true. And none of it answered her.
“Yes,” I said. “I want the whole day. We’ve been trying to make it happen for months.”
“Then tell him yes. You’ve got two showings. They’re mine.”
I looked at her. The awkward truth was that she had never asked me to hold the day. I had done that myself. I had left a door open because being available felt pleasantly close to being wanted, and I hadn’t noticed the difference until she said it out loud.
She dried her hands on a towel. “I like that you helped me with the trail. I liked it a lot. But I don’t want you holding your plans open in case my office creates another problem.”
The words landed harder because she wasn’t pushing me away. She was making room for something that had nothing to do with her.
My shift alarm vibrated in my pocket. Crystal picked up my cap from the chair, set it beside my bag at the door, and draped my jacket over the strap so I wouldn’t forget it.
“Go run your ferry,” she said, “and text Andrew.”
I put on the cap. “Bossy, efficient.”
One smile, one word each. Then she opened the door and I left on time. On the way to the terminal, I texted Andrew that Saturday was locked.
Friday afternoon, Crystal met me at the Marina Cafe with a face that told me the calendar had not become kinder overnight.
“The Charlotte couple can only do ten tomorrow,” she said after we sat down. “And my nine o’clock clients won’t move.”
I waited.
“April suggested something.”
Crystal folded her hands around her coffee, then unfolded them. “She asked if you could meet the Charlotte couple at the north dock, walk them up the trail, and keep them at the cottage until I can get there.”
There it was. The exact kind of little favor that could turn into half a day while everybody called it forty minutes.
“You mean tomorrow morning?”
“Yes.”
“That’s when I’m on the ridge with Andrew.”
“I know.” Her voice was careful. “I thought maybe because it’s only the walk from the dock.”
“No, Crystal.”
She went still. I kept my voice even. “I can leave you the trail notes. I can answer one question tonight if you need it. But I’m not taking clients tomorrow. That’s my day with Andrew.”
Her fingers tightened around the coffee cup. She looked past me toward the window — not angry, just caught between disappointment and the practical problem that had suddenly become hers again.
For several seconds, neither of us spoke. The grinder hissed behind the counter. Someone at the next table dropped a spoon. I had the sharp, stupid fear that I had just turned one honest boundary into the end of something that had barely begun.
Crystal set the cup down carefully. “That’s not what I wanted to hear,” she said.
“I know.”
“I was counting on you.”
“I know that, too.”
She drew a slow breath. For a moment, I thought she might argue that it was only forty minutes. Instead, she looked down at her hands. “And that’s the problem,” she said at last. “I counted your time as if it was available because you helped once already.”
“I made it easy to do that. I keep offering.”
“That doesn’t make it mine.” She rubbed her thumb once over the cardboard sleeve around the cup. “I don’t like the answer, Tom, but I don’t want you to change it.”
The relief I felt was immediate and not entirely comfortable. Part of me had wanted the moment to become easy again. It didn’t. It stayed awkward, which was probably why it meant something.
The short walk we had planned after coffee disappeared. Crystal needed to call April and the clients before the day ended.
“I should handle this,” she said.
“I know.”
I stood, and every friendly instinct in me wanted to soften the moment by adding one more offer. Drive someone. Call someone. Meet them for twenty minutes. Something.
I didn’t.
“I’ll see you,” I said.
Her eyes lifted to mine. There was warmth there, but no quick smile to erase what had just happened. “You will,” she said.
I left the cafe alone.
At 5:30, my phone buzzed with a message from Crystal. *If you’re free at 6, come by the office. Ten minutes, not for work.*
I almost smiled at the last sentence.
Her office sat above a pharmacy on Main Street. When I came in, April was standing beside Crystal’s desk with a calendar open between them.
“Tom,” April said, relieved. “Perfect timing. If the Charlotte couple calls back and insists on ten, could you possibly—”
“No,” Crystal said — calm enough that April stopped mid-sentence. Crystal turned the calendar so they could both see it. “They agreed to three. I’m keeping the cove showing at nine, and I’ll take the ferry over after lunch. Tom isn’t our backup plan.”
April’s mouth tightened. “Three is not what they asked for. If they decide they don’t want to rearrange their day, we could lose a serious buyer.”
“I know. And we had a way to keep the ten o’clock slot.” Crystal’s shoulders stayed relaxed. “By asking someone who doesn’t work here to give up his day off.”
April glanced at me, then back at Crystal. “I’m not trying to exploit anybody. I’m trying to keep two clients from walking.”
“I know. But if the schedule doesn’t work, that’s an office problem. It doesn’t become Tom’s job because he knows the trail.”
April exhaled and tapped one finger against the open calendar. “If they cancel at three, I want us to be honest about why.”
“We will be,” Crystal said. “And if they come, I’ll show them the property myself.”
April clearly didn’t love the answer. “Fine. Three o’clock. Send me confirmation before you leave.”
“I already did.”
April gave a short nod and carried the calendar away. Crystal let out a breath.
“That went well,” I said.
She gave me a look. “It went adequately.”
I had seen the cost now. She had chosen the harder scheduling conversation instead of making my availability part of her solution. She gathered two folders, put them into her bag, and came around the desk.
Outside, the evening air had cooled.
“You didn’t have to come up,” she said.
“You told me it wasn’t for work. I was curious.”
“It isn’t.” She tucked a strand of hair behind her ear. “Come over tomorrow night after your hike. Six-thirty, if your legs still work.”
“What’s the occasion?”
“I want to hear about the ridge.” She met my eyes. “And I want to see you.”
Nothing in that invitation needed me to solve anything.
“I’ll be there.”
She hesitated before turning toward the stairs. “I almost didn’t ask you to come tonight. I thought maybe after yesterday I should stop asking you for anything.”
“Don’t do that.” I waited until she looked back at me. “Ask. I want you to ask. Just don’t assume the answer has to be yes.”
A little tension left her shoulders. “Fair.”
“And if I say no, don’t make me wonder whether I just lost the next date.”
“You didn’t.”
That was all I needed. This time, the easy answer and the true answer were the same.
Saturday morning was crisp and clear. I met Andrew at the trailhead off the Blue Ridge Parkway at 6:45. He was leaning against his tailgate, tightening a pack strap, when I pulled in.
“I was half expecting a cancellation,” he said.
“Not today.”
Crystal’s green thermos sat in the side pocket of my pack, full of ice water. Andrew noticed it while we were getting our boots settled.
“Fancy. Borrowed from Crystal?”
“Yeah.”
He gave me a look but wisely didn’t turn it into an interview.
We started at seven. The first hours were all climbing — rhododendron tunnels, wet roots, long sections where conversation came in half sentences because breathing mattered more. By late morning, we broke onto the open balds. The mountains rolled away in blue layers, and Lake Rowan was a thin flash of silver far to the south.
At lunch we sat on a granite outcrop. I poured water from the thermos into its metal cup and handed it to Andrew. He drank and raised his eyebrows.
“That is offensively cold.”
“She said it would be.”
“So she’s useful.”
I looked at him. Andrew grinned. “Relax. I’m kidding.”
I took the cup back. “She made sure I came today.”
That changed his expression. “Good.”
“I almost left the day open in case her work blew up. And she told me not to.”
Andrew tore open a packet of trail mix. “Then keep listening to her.”
That was all he said about it.
We finished the loop a little after three, tired in the satisfying way that made the truck seat feel luxurious. I had kept a plan that belonged to my life before Crystal, and it no longer felt like time taken away from us.
On the drive down, Andrew mentioned a shorter loop next month. “Send me the date,” I said. “If I’m off, I’m in.”
I dropped Andrew at his truck and drove home with the windows cracked, already looking forward to 6:30. I showered, changed into clean jeans and a dark button-down, washed Crystal’s thermos, dried the cap and cup, and drove to her apartment.
When she opened the door, she was wearing a dark plum wrap dress and small silver earrings. Her hair was loose. She looked a little tired around the eyes and entirely glad to see me.
“Hey.”
“Hey.”
I held up the thermos. “Returned clean, dry, and with all original parts.”
She took it and checked the cup with mock seriousness. “Acceptable.”
“I was hoping for a certificate.”
“You’re pushing it.”
She put the thermos back in the cabinet and led me to the dining table. Two plates were set out beside a bowl of pasta with roasted tomatoes and basil, a loaf of bread, and a simple green salad. No listing folders. No open laptop.
“How was the ridge?” she asked.
I told her about the climb, Andrew’s opinion of the thermos, and the view from the balds. She listened without steering the story back toward her day. Only after I finished did I ask, “How did three o’clock go?”
Crystal leaned back in her chair. “Better than ten would have.” She smiled faintly. “The architect asked about drainage, winter footing, and whether the public path gets muddy after storms. His wife stood on the footbridge for five minutes because she liked the creek. And they want to think about it.”
There was no disappointment in her voice.
“That’s good.”
“It is.” She folded her napkin once under her fingers. “They saw the actual place, not a photograph with the inconvenient parts cropped out. If they buy it, they’ll know what they’re choosing. If they don’t, I did my job.”
That mattered to her enough that I could hear it.
“And the listing?”
“Mine went out shorter than my first draft, longer than April’s. It sounds like me.”
I smiled. “Then you had a good day.”
“I did.” She grew quiet. “I also kept thinking about yesterday.”
I set down my fork. Crystal looked at me directly.
“When you said no, I didn’t like it.”
“I noticed.”
“For a few minutes, I was angry at the situation and embarrassed that I had put you in it.” She looked down, then back up. “I’m glad I didn’t make either feeling your problem.”
“You didn’t.”
“Then today, April pushed back and I understood why it mattered that you had already said no. If you had agreed, everybody would have learned that asking you was easier than fixing the schedule.”
I sat with that.
“I like helping you,” I said.
“I know.”
“And I like being the man you call. I just don’t want being useful to be the reason you want me around.”
Her face softened. “It isn’t.”
That answer took the last of my practiced charm away. I reached across the table and rested my hand between us.
“I want to keep seeing you,” I said. “Seriously. I want us to make time for this because we want it, not because one of us has a problem the other can solve.”
Crystal placed her hand over mine. “I want that, too. And I want you to say no when you mean no.”
“I can do that.”
“I know.”
We sat quietly for a few seconds, the pasta cooling between us. Then Crystal stood and came around the table. I rose to meet her.
“Can I kiss you?” I asked.
“Yes.”
The kiss was soft at first, then certain. Her hands came to the back of my neck. Mine settled at her waist. There was no rush in it, and no sense that either of us had won anything. When we parted, she rested her forehead against mine for a second.
“Now sit down,” she said. “I made dinner because I wanted to feed you. I would like you to actually eat it.”
“Yes, ma’am.”
We finished the pasta. Afterward, we moved to the sofa with tea — peppermint this time, because Crystal read the tin twice before pouring — and talked until the street below went quiet.
Before I left, she opened her calendar, looked at one evening the following week, and asked, “The Rowan Room. My invitation.”
I leaned over beside her. Tuesday showed one of my late runs. Wednesday had a Northshore showing in her handwriting. Friday was clear for both of us.
“Friday,” I said.
“Seven.”
She wrote *dinner* in the square. My old reflex arrived right on schedule.
“Do you need me to—” I stopped. Crystal looked up. I laughed once at myself. “No. Wrong question. How do you feel about the showing Wednesday?”
“Better.”
“Good. Tell me how it goes.”
Her smile was quiet and pleased — not because I had offered nothing, but because I had finally trusted her to tell me if she needed something. She closed the calendar. Friday belonged to us because we had put it there on purpose. It was enough to make me look forward to the whole week.
The following Friday, I parked outside the Rowan Room at seven. The host pointed me toward the corner table by the tall windows. Crystal was already there. She sat in the same chair she had taken on our first date, white linen between us, candlelight reflected in the glass. Her blonde hair fell in soft waves over her shoulders, and she was wearing the champagne silk dress.
I stopped for half a second. She saw it, and her mouth curved.
I walked to the table, pulled out the chair opposite her, and sat down without checking my water glass for help.
“You wore it,” I said.
“I like it.”
“I remember.”
“And,” she added, “I like the man looking at it.”
I let myself look at her then — not as if she were a problem to solve, not as if admiration had to be justified by some useful thing I could do afterward. She was beautiful. She knew I thought so. Neither of us needed to pretend otherwise.
“I’m looking,” I said.
Her smile widened.
We ordered dinner. Halfway through the first course, her phone buzzed inside her purse. Crystal took it out, read the screen, and made a small face.
“April.”
“April.”
“She wants me to look at a revised paragraph tonight.”
I waited. Crystal typed a short reply, set the phone face down beside her purse, and picked up her fork.
“Monday morning,” she said.
“That work for her?”
“It will.”
I smiled. “Mr. Henderson tried to board this afternoon with a fishing net taller than he is. He got it sideways in the gate and blamed the boat.”
Crystal laughed. “Naturally, the boat has declined to comment.”
After dinner, the waiter brought the dessert card. Crystal didn’t open it.
“Lemon tart?” she asked.
“Two forks?”
“Obviously.”
She leaned forward, her hand resting near mine on the table. “And after dessert, come back to my place for tea. Peppermint. On purpose this time.”
I took her hand.
There would be ferry schedules, house showings, Andrew’s next hike, and a hundred ordinary reasons one of us would sometimes have to say no. None of them made this yes smaller.
“I’d like that,” I said.
Crystal squeezed my fingers, and when the lemon tart arrived, I stayed for dessert.