63 Years After Her Death, Patsy Cline’s Daughter Finally Confirms What Fans Always Suspected |

63 Years After Her Death, Patsy Cline’s Daughter Finally Confirms What Fans Always Suspected |

5 Months Before Her Plane Went Down, Patsy Cline Told a Friend, ‘The Third One Will Either Be Lucky or Kill Me.’ Then She Washed Every Sock Her Children Owned.

Fall, 1962. A 30-year-old woman stands in the children’s bedroom of her house on Nella Drive in Nashville, rearranging the closet. She folds tiny dresses and smooths pairs of socks.

She and her husband have been married five years, and they have two small children.

Her close friend Dottie West stops by that afternoon and finds her at it. As West would tell the story for the rest of her life, the woman never looked up. She said one small sentence about knowing what was coming.

Five months later, Patsy Cline was dead in a plane crash in Tennessee. Her older daughter, Julie Fudge, is now 68. For nearly her entire life, wherever she goes, people ask her the same question about her mother.

Cline died on March 5, 1963, 63 years ago. For a generation of Americans she remains the queen of country music, with the smoky voice, the fringed cowboy dress and the shy smile.

Fans always wondered about two things. Was she abused by her husband, as the rumors said? And did she somehow know her own death was coming?

Julie was just 4 when her mother died, but she grew up in that house, with that father, those letters and those memories. She spent decades largely silent. Only in recent years has she spoken, and she has confirmed both suspicions.

But the woman on the records, Julie says, is the same woman who lived in the house. The part the voice hides is what her mother paid and who she was before anyone called her Patsy.

The girl named Ginny

She was not born Patsy, and she was not born Cline. She was born Virginia Patterson Hensley on September 8, 1932, in Winchester, Virginia. Her mother, Hilda Patterson, was 16. Her father, Samuel Lawrence Hensley, a blacksmith, was 43.

At home she was Ginny, and her childhood was a story of moving. By the time she turned 15, the family had relocated 19 times, chasing whatever work Sam could find for his hammer and forge.

When money ran out in Elkton, Ginny went to work plucking and gutting chickens at a poultry plant. She was not yet 12. The future Carnegie Hall headliner started her working life in a rural slaughterhouse.

There was something else in that house she would not forget. Decades later, as a star, she reportedly told her friend Loretta Lynn that her father had abused her for years, beginning when she was very small.

According to Lynn’s memoir, Patsy took her hand and said, “Take this story to the grave.” Her mother, Hilda, later confirmed details to the producers of a 1985 biographical film.

At 13, Ginny suffered a severe throat infection and rheumatic fever. By her own later account, her heart stopped in the hospital before doctors brought her back. When she recovered, her voice was deeper, thicker and fuller.

Before that, she sang like a little girl. After that, she sang like a woman who had lived a very long time.

From the radio station to Nashville

Her father left the family in 1947. Some said it was alcohol and some said affairs, while those closest to the family said Hilda wanted to settle down and Sam could not.

Ginny did not cry. She quit school around eighth or ninth grade and took any job she could to help raise her younger siblings, Samuel Jr. and Silvia Mae.

In the evenings she sang. At 15, she walked into Winchester radio station WINC and asked for an audition on the spot. She got it. Her daughter would later say Patsy never took a vocal lesson and never learned to read a note of music.

She spent the next few years working clubs, tent shows and lawn dances across Virginia, Maryland and Washington, D.C. In 1952 she joined bandleader Bill Peer’s group, The Melody Boys and Girls. Peer thought “Virginia” sounded too long and shortened her middle name, Patterson, to Patsy.

In March 1953 she married Gerald Cline, a member of a prosperous Virginia construction family. Friends never understood the match. He wanted a wife at home, and she wanted a stage. The marriage would end, but the name stayed.

In 1954 she signed with Four Star Records on a restrictive contract that limited her to songs whose copyrights Four Star owned. For five years she recorded material she neither chose nor loved.

In 1956 her father lay dying of lung cancer in a West Virginia hospital. She told him, “Daddy, you have never really heard me sing.” It was the last time she saw him, and she never spoke publicly about the visit.

Overnight star, and a new marriage

On January 21, 1957, she won Arthur Godfrey’s Talent Scouts in New York with “Walking After Midnight,” a song her label had almost refused to let her record.

It hit number two on the country chart and number 12 on the pop chart, a rare crossover. At 24, she was a national name overnight.

Her marriage to Gerald was over within weeks. They divorced in Maryland on March 28. Nobody won, she wanted a career and he wanted a wife.

She had already noticed someone else. At a Winchester dance in the summer of 1956, she’d spotted Charles Allen Dick, a tall, dark-eyed 24-year-old linotype operator at the Winchester Star. He liked to drink, and he was handsome in a careless way.

They married on September 15, 1957, only six months after her divorce. Friends worried from the start, since Charlie drank heavily, was jealous, and bristled that his wife out-earned him. Patsy told everyone he was the love of her life.

Both things, those who knew them said, would stay true for the five and a half years she had left.

Her first child, Julia Simadore, called Julie, was born August 25, 1958. For the first time, Patsy later told friends, she felt something stronger than ambition.

She kept singing anyway. At the end of 1958 the family moved to Nashville.

What the public didn’t see

According to people who knew the couple then, Charlie began hitting her in Nashville. It started with slaps when he was drunk, then shoves, then bruises she covered with makeup before going on stage.

Nobody called police, nobody wrote about it, and the fans saw only the smiling singer beside her handsome husband.

In January 1960, she became an official member of the Grand Ole Opry after nearly 12 years of work. That year she also signed with Decca Records, and the Four Star contract finally expired.

At Decca she met producer Owen Bradley, who ran a small studio on 16th Avenue that became the Quonset Hut, the seed of what the world would know as Music Row.

Bradley told her she wasn’t a cowboy singer but a ballad singer. He gave her strings, the Jordanaires, and a band of Nashville’s best studio players.

“I Fall to Pieces,” written by Hank Cochran and Harlan Howard, came out in January 1961 and reached number one on Billboard’s country chart that August. It was her first chart-topper, after 12 years of waiting. Her son, Allen Randolph, called Randy, was born February 28, 1961.

The crash that almost ended it

On June 14, 1961, Patsy was driving home with her brother Sam Jr., then 21, in Madison, north of Nashville. A car driven by Jacqueline Carpenter changed lanes to pass and hit them head-on. Carpenter died at the scene.

Patsy was thrown through the windshield. Her forehead was cut to the bone, her hip was broken and her ribs were fractured. A priest was called. She later said she had a near-death experience on the operating table, though she never said clearly what she saw.

The scar across her brow never faded. For the rest of her life she hid it under silk ribbons, wide clips or wigs.

Young singer Loretta Lynn heard about the crash on the radio. She had been singing “I Fall to Pieces” on a local show, and Charlie Dick found her at a record store and said Patsy wanted to meet.

It was the start of one of country music’s great friendships, between a woman in bandages and a girl from Butcher Hollow, Kentucky. It would last only 19 months.

Nine weeks after the crash, still on crutches, Patsy went back to the Quonset Hut. Bradley had a demo from a Texan named Willie Nelson, a song called “Crazy.” She hated it, since Nelson half-talked it with odd phrasing. She told Bradley she couldn’t sing it, and he told her to try.

She did it in a single take, with Floyd Cramer’s piano falling like rain behind her. The recording, released in October 1961, reached number two on the country chart and number nine on pop. It has long been billed as the most played jukebox song in American history.

In November 1961 she played Carnegie Hall, among the first country artists invited there. Critics who had written that country was music for farmers wrote that the woman from Winchester had made them cry.

Bleeding behind the curtain

By early 1962, no woman in country music had climbed higher. Behind the scenes, those close to her say, things were worse. Charlie began touring with her, supposedly to help.

Musicians later recalled him drinking in after-hours hotel bars, picking fights with male fans who asked for her autograph, and noises through hotel walls they never forgot.

One guitarist in the touring band would tell biographers he saw Charlie hit Patsy backstage in front of four or five grown men. No one stepped in.

Years later, a trove of Patsy’s handwritten letters surfaced and was sold through Heritage Auctions as lot 1022. In them she wrote that she’d had enough, that she didn’t care if she never saw him again, and that she was sick and tired of being hurt and used. She was reportedly preparing a divorce petition she never filed.

Around spring 1962, she became pregnant a third time, telling only close friends. Friends say she miscarried on a night Charlie came home drunk and yelling.

She never publicly said who was to blame, but Loretta Lynn, June Carter and Dottie West knew, they later said. Something in Patsy changed.

“The third one”

By fall 1962, she was telling friends something that would haunt them for 60 years. She said it to Dottie West in a car, to June Carter backstage at the Opry, and to Loretta Lynn in a hotel room.

The words varied, but the shape did not: she had been through two bad ones, and the third would either be lucky or kill her.

The two were the rheumatic fever at 13 and the 1961 windshield crash. She believed, with a certainty friends couldn’t shake, that a third was coming.

In November 1962, she walked Lynn through the new Nella Drive house, showing her every closet, drawer and box. She told Lynn where everything was in case anything happened.

She wrote a handwritten will and washed every dress, sock and shoe her children owned. She told Charlie, on one of their rare calm nights, how she wanted the children raised.

Charlie thought she was being strange. Her friends thought she was exhausted. Nobody believed her.

March 5, 1963

On March 3, she played the third of three nights at Kansas City’s Soldiers and Sailors Memorial Hall, a benefit for the family of DJ Cactus Jack Call, who’d died in a car crash.

Also on the bill were Cowboy Copas and Hawkshaw Hawkins. Patsy’s manager, Randy Hughes, who was also Copas’s son-in-law, was there too.

Hughes owned a small plane, a 1960 Piper Comanche, registration N7000P. After the Sunday finale, a major storm sat between Kansas City and Nashville. Hughes called the Weather Bureau, and they told him to wait.

Patsy could have taken a train, driven or flown commercially. She waited with Hughes instead.

On Tuesday, March 5, the storm seemed to be moving east, and Hughes thought he could fly behind it. The four boarded at Fairfax Municipal Airport at 2 p.m. and stopped in Dyersburg, Tennessee, around 5 to refuel.

The airport manager warned that weather to the east was worsening and offered his car for the drive to Nashville. Hughes refused. He did not hold an instrument rating, meaning he was cleared to fly only when he could see the ground.

At 6:07 p.m. he took off into the clouds. At 6:20, the small women’s watch on Patsy’s wrist stopped. The Comanche had plunged into a swampy forest five miles west of Camden, Tennessee. All four aboard died instantly. Patsy was 30.

Singer-songwriter Roger Miller, who drove through the night to join the search, found the site the next morning. He later said the engine sat at the bottom of a crater. Around him lay broken guitars, cowboy hats, rhinestones from stage dresses and a small watch frozen at 6:20.

Two days later, on the way to her funeral, country singer Jack Anglin died in a car accident. In country music, it became known as the month the music died for the first time.

In Nashville, a 4-year-old girl waited for her mother to come home.

The aftermath

On March 6, Charlie Dick had to tell his daughter that her mother wasn’t coming home. Julie would not remember that moment, and Randy, just 2, wouldn’t either.

Charlie raised the children in Nashville. He drank more, remarried singer Jamie Ryan and later divorced. In 1973 Patsy became the first solo female artist inducted into the Country Music Hall of Fame, and Charlie accepted on her behalf. In 1995 she received a posthumous Grammy Lifetime Achievement Award.

The 1985 film Sweet Dreams, with Jessica Lange as Patsy and Ed Harris as Charlie, portrayed him as an abusive husband. Charlie objected in interviews and disputed the film’s portrait, but admitted he had hit his wife at least once. To calm her down, he said.

Julie grew up to run Patsy Cline Enterprises, married, took the name Fudge and raised her own children. For decades she rarely discussed her parents publicly. Charlie died November 8, 2015, at 81, and only then did she begin to speak freely.

On April 5, 2017, the Patsy Cline Museum opened in Nashville, with Julie as a co-founder. That year she also appeared in the PBS American Masters documentary about her mother, and for the first time she addressed the two questions fans had asked for decades.

On the abuse, she said yes. Her father had hit her mother many times over the years, and her mother had decided to leave him shortly before her death. The handwritten letters, now public, support that account, though Charlie himself only ever acknowledged a single incident.

On the premonition, she also said yes. She repeated what Lynn, Carter and West had held onto for decades, that her mother cleaned out her children’s closets and washed every dress, sock and shoe in her final weeks.

It was not strange, Julie said. It was preparation. Skeptics might note that much of the account comes from friends’ recollections years later, and that some friends at the time simply thought Patsy was worn out.

Today, Julie spends afternoons in Nashville in the museum she built for her mother, and her routine echoes her mother’s in the fall of 1962.

She walks the shelves, smooths an old program and straightens a fringed cowboy dress. She sets a small watch, stopped at 6:20, in its proper place under the glass.

Everything is clean and everything is in its place. Sixty-three years on, the 4-year-old who waited for her mother has told the world what the fans always suspected.

Disclaimer: This story is fictional and created for entertainment purposes only. Any names, characters, places, or events are fictitious or used fictitiously. No real person or organization is intended to be portrayed.

Related Articles