Wyatt Earp’s Marriage to Mattie Blaylock Was Much Nastier Than You Thought |

Wyatt Earp’s Marriage to Mattie Blaylock Was Much Nastier Than You Thought |

She gave up her name, her family, and a decade of her life to be “Mrs. Wyatt Earp.” But there was no license, no ceremony.

In July 1888, in a dying silver town in the Arizona desert called Pinal City, a doctor wrote down how Mattie Earp had died. The record reads “Supposed to be suicide by opium poisoning.” It gives her age as 40. She was 38.

If you know her from the film Tombstone, you know a pale woman with a bottle of laudanum who drifts out of the story. Her paper trail is far uglier than that. The only document anyone has found in which Wyatt Earp calls her his wife is a debt he walked away from.

To see why that matters, you have to see what Mattie had already given up before she met him. She started out with a different name and a family that never saw her again.

She was born Celia Ann Blaylock in January 1850 in Monroe Township, Johnson County, Iowa. Her father, Henry, ran a small farm, and the household was strict and built around the Bible. She was the third child and the second daughter. Nothing about that farm hints at the life ahead.

In the middle of 1868, Celia ran away, and her younger sister Sarah went with her. Within a year, Sarah was back in Iowa. Celia never returned.

Somewhere on the road she dropped her real name and began calling herself Mattie. The usual reading is that the new name kept her family from finding her.

So the girl who would one day be listed as Wyatt Earp’s wife had already erased herself once, by choice, before she turned 20.

She first appears in the record at Fort Scott, Kansas, in 1871. Court documents there show her working as a prostitute from 1872. That is not a slur pinned on her later. It sits in the town’s own paperwork, in the fines and dockets cow towns used to tax a trade they never admitted to allowing.

From Fort Scott she moved on to the biggest cow town of all, Dodge City, and that is where the dates start fighting each other. One account has her meeting Wyatt there as early as 1873.

Another puts it after April 1876, when he arrived from Wichita to work as an assistant marshal. Nobody has a letter or a license that settles it.

Every version agrees on two things. By the end of the 1870s she was living with him as his wife, and she was still working when they met.

So who was the man she attached herself to? Here is the part the film leaves out. Wyatt had already been married once, legally, with a license.

On January 10, 1870, in Lamar, Missouri, he wed Urilla Sutherland. Within the year she was dead of typhoid fever, while expecting their first child.

What followed was not grief in a quiet room. In March 1871, Wyatt was sued over license fees he had collected and not handed over, and he was charged with stealing two horses.

He was arrested in April. Before he could be tried, according to the record, he escaped through the roof of the jail and headed for Peoria, Illinois.

In Peoria, the arrests kept coming, and they were not for gunfights. In February 1872, he and his brother Morgan were arrested for keeping and being found in a house of ill fame.

In May they were arrested again and fined. In September, Wyatt was picked up aboard a floating brothel on the river, the Beardstown gunboat, along with a prostitute named Sally Heckel.

The local paper printed a line that should stop anyone who thinks Mattie was the first. “Sally Heckel calls herself the wife of Wyatt Earp.”

That was eight years before a census would list Mattie the same way. Sally had no license and no ceremony anyone can find. She followed Wyatt to Wichita, where his brother James ran a brothel with his wife, Bessie. By the summer of 1875 she was gone from the record, and nobody knows what became of her.

When Mattie began calling herself Mattie Earp in Dodge City, she was stepping into a role Wyatt had already handed out once and taken back.

He had done it the legal way with Urilla, and it ended in a grave within a year. After that, as far as anyone has found, he never walked a woman into a courthouse again.

On September 9, 1879, Wyatt resigned from the Dodge City police. With Mattie, James and Bessie, he headed southwest, first to Las Vegas, New Mexico Territory, where they met up with Doc Holliday and Big Nose Kate, and then on to Prescott, Arizona.

One account says the party stopped in Pinal City for a couple of months along the way. If so, Mattie stood in the town where she would die nine years later, beside the man who would leave her.

On December 1, 1879, the Earp brothers and their women rolled into Tombstone. Within months, the federal government had written her down as his wife.

Historians call her his common-law wife, which is a polite phrase. It means she lived as his wife, used his name and was counted as his wife. It also means that if he ever left, she had no license to carry into any court.

In the 1880 census, taken in June, the Earp household lists her as Mattie Earp. Relationship to Wyatt: wife. Occupation: keeping house.

No marriage record has ever been found for them in Kansas, Arizona or anywhere else. But a census taker came to the door, somebody inside told him she was Mrs. Earp, and that is what went into the government’s book.

Tombstone gave Mattie the closest thing to a settled life she ever had. She and Wyatt lived in a small house on two lots on Fremont Street, a few doors from Virgil Earp and his wife, Allie. Allie later remembered it plainly: the house was “next door to Wyatt and Mattie’s, except for a vacant lot between.”

The brothers worked the town, and Wyatt took a job with Wells Fargo. The women kept house. According to writer Tom Clavin, Mattie and Allie shared more than a few afternoon drinks.

But Mattie had something worse than a drinking habit. She suffered severe headaches and, like plenty of people in those years, treated them with laudanum.

The film makes it look like a quaint tonic. It was a tincture of opium, roughly 10 percent powdered opium dissolved in alcohol, sold over the counter.

It was opium and liquor in one bottle, taken daily by a woman with no doctor watching her dose. By the time the Earps were famous, Mattie was dependent on it.

Then there was Josephine. Josephine Marcus had come to Tombstone attached to Johnny Behan, the man who would become sheriff of Cochise County.

By her own later account, he promised to marry her and never did. Early in 1881, she threw him out. At some point after that, she and Wyatt began the relationship that would last the rest of his life.

When it started is genuinely unknown. George Parsons, who kept a daily diary in Tombstone, and John Clum, who ran the Tombstone Epitaph, never recorded seeing the two together. Whatever passed between Wyatt and Josephine there, it stayed out of every record the town produced.

That matters because you have probably heard the dramatic version, with the two women screaming at each other in the street over Wyatt.

Most of that traces to Frank Waters, who took down Allie Earp’s memories in the 1930s and published his book in 1960. Researchers who later found his original manuscript say Allie never said many of the harshest things the book puts in her mouth.

The other famous source is I Married Wyatt Earp, billed as Josephine’s own memoir. It was assembled by Glenn Boyer in 1976.

Researchers later found that many of its facts could not be documented, and in 2000 the University of Arizona pulled it from its catalog. If a scene between those two women sounds too good to be true, it probably came from one of those books.

What is documented is enough. Mattie was living in Wyatt’s house, using his name and taking laudanum for her headaches, while the man she called her husband started something with the sheriff’s former partner. Then Tombstone blew up around all of them.

On October 26, 1881, Wyatt, Virgil, Morgan and Doc Holliday walked down Fremont Street toward the Clantons and the McLaurys. About 30 seconds later, Billy Clanton and both McLaury brothers were dead.

Ike Clanton filed murder charges, and the Earps and Doc endured a month of hearings before Justice Wells Spicer. They walked free, but lawyers are expensive.

In December, Virgil was shot from ambush on a dark street, and his left arm was crippled for life. The Earps and their women moved into the Cosmopolitan Hotel for protection. By one historian’s reconstruction, Mattie was the last of the family to move in, in February 1882.

That same month, the most revealing document in this story was signed. On February 13, 1882, “Wyatt S. Earp and Mattie Earp, his wife” mortgaged their house and lot on Fremont Street to a Tombstone attorney named James G. Howard.

The amount was $365 in gold coin. The note behind it was for $300 plus interest at 2 percent a month, due in three months. That works out to 24 percent a year, payable in gold.

Researchers at Wyatt Earp Explorers, who published a copy, link the loan to the legal costs of the Spicer hearing and to a family running out of money while being hunted.

Look at how she signed. The law of the day had a safeguard for a married woman signing over property. A notary had to examine her separately, apart from her husband.

So the notary, B. L. Peel, took Mattie aside and recorded that she signed freely and voluntarily, without fear or compulsion. She signed on the 13th. Wyatt did not sign his acknowledgment until the 18th.

Let that picture settle. The law needed to ask Mattie, alone, whether anyone was forcing her to put up her home. And this is the one paper anyone has found where Wyatt writes her down as his wife in his own transaction. It is not a license or a church book, just a mortgage.

Five weeks later, everything fell apart. On the night of March 18, 1882, at about 10:50, Morgan Earp was shot through a glass door while playing pool at Campbell and Hatch’s saloon. He died within the hour.

The next day, James put Morgan’s body on a train for the family home in Colton, California. Virgil and Allie followed, with Wyatt riding guard as far as Tucson, where Frank Stillwell turned up dead beside the tracks.

From then on, Wyatt was no longer a lawman protecting a family. He was a man on a vendetta, with warrants coming up behind him.

So what did he do with Mattie? On March 24, 1882, she left Tombstone for Colton, to Wyatt’s parents, Nicholas and Virginia, and the grieving family gathered around Morgan’s grave. Her biographers, including Ted Myers in Mattie, Wyatt Earp’s Secret Second Wife, tell it simply and brutally.

She was to wait for a telegram from Wyatt saying where to meet him once it was safe. Wyatt sent her away, and Wyatt was the one who would send for her.

Here is where he actually went. On April 15, 1882, he and his posse rode out of Arizona Territory into New Mexico, then on to Silver City and Albuquerque. By the end of April they were in Colorado, at Trinidad and then Gunnison.

On May 29, Colorado Governor Frederick Pitkin refused Arizona’s request to send them back for trial. From that day Wyatt was safe, a free man with a famous name. The telegram never came.

Put yourself in that house in Colton. Mattie had no legal paper tying her to Wyatt, no license to show anyone.

She was living with parents who had just buried a son, with no money of her own, and the house she had pledged in Tombstone carried a debt that grew every month it went unpaid.

Every week without word was an answer. She just did not have it in writing.

Then there are the dates. In the standard accounts, Josephine Marcus left Tombstone for San Francisco on March 24, 1882, the same day Mattie left for Colton.

Two women headed west out of the same town on the same day, one to his parents’ house to wait, the other to the city where he would eventually join her.

Nobody wrote down whether they shared a stage or a train, or even saw each other, so don’t let anyone sell you a scene. But the dates line up, and you can decide what they say about whom Wyatt planned to see again.

By late 1882, Wyatt was in San Francisco with Josephine. In spring 1883, when he returned to Kansas to back his friend Luke Short in the so-called Dodge City War, she traveled with him.

Dodge City, where Mattie had first lived as his wife, saw Wyatt again four years after he left, and a different woman was beside him.

There is no letter from Wyatt to Mattie explaining any of it, and no record that he sent her money. There was no divorce, because there was never a marriage to dissolve. That was the convenience of the arrangement all along.

When the census came, she was his wife. When the mortgage was signed, she was his wife. When he wanted to leave, no paper said she was anything at all.

Wyatt’s defenders have a case, and it deserves a hearing. He was a wanted man who had just lost a brother, and the Cowboys had shown they would shoot an Earp through a saloon door.

Sending the women to California may have kept them alive. They were not legally married, the argument goes, so he owed her nothing. She was addicted to laudanum and perhaps impossible to live with.

Some of that may be true. But the vendetta ended in the spring of 1882, and Mattie was still alive six years later. No record shows he ever sent for her.

And the legal argument runs straight into the documents, because on the house, Wyatt did treat her as a wife. He listed her that way on the mortgage, and the notary treated her that way when she signed.

Then there is the house itself. Wyatt left Arizona in April 1882 without repaying James G. Howard, and the three-month note came due and went unpaid.

In 1884, Howard sued. The court papers described the property as lots 3 and 4 of block M, the little house on Fremont Street where Mattie had lived as Mrs. Earp.

By 1886, according to tax rolls the same researchers turned up, the person assessed for the Earp lots was Nicholas Porter Earp, Wyatt’s father. That suggests the family settled the debt among themselves.

What it does not show is Mattie anywhere in the outcome. She signed the mortgage as the wife, and when the paperwork settled, the tax bill carried Wyatt’s father’s name. As far as any record shows, she came away with nothing.

By then she had already left Colton and returned to Arizona alone. Her biographers place her first in Globe, a copper town east of Phoenix, where she went back to the only trade that had ever paid her.

Later she moved on to Pinal City, founded in 1878 to process ore from the Silver King Mine and home to about 2,000 people at its peak. By the late 1880s the mine was drying out and the people were leaving.

A woman in her late 30s, working in an emptying town, had very few ways left to make a living. She was also still taking laudanum with drink.

One researcher’s account of her last years describes about four years of heavy laudanum and alcohol use before the end, on top of the habit she carried out of Tombstone.

Across those same six years, Wyatt’s road ran parallel to hers and never touched it. After Colorado, San Francisco and the Dodge City War, he and Josephine joined the gold rush to Eagle City in Idaho’s Coeur d’Alene country. Then came San Diego. It was saloons, mining claims and boom towns, with a famous name opening doors in every one.

Mattie’s road ran the other way, from Colton to Globe to a mill town that was losing its mill.

There is one more absence in her story that almost nobody mentions, and it is not Wyatt’s. Celia Ann Blaylock had a family in Iowa the whole time. Her father, Henry, died in 1877 while she was in Dodge City.

Her mother, Elizabeth, lived until 1899, 11 years after Mattie died. Her sister Sarah, who ran away with her and went home, lived until 1906.

Whether any of them ever learned what became of the daughter who changed her name, the record does not say. As far as anyone has found, nobody came from Iowa to Pinal City.

Pinal sat below a mountain named for Picket Post, the army post General George Stoneman set up nearby to protect miners from Apache raids.

By the summer of 1888, the mine that built the town was nearly played out. It was July in the Arizona desert, in a place with little left to offer anyone.

On July 3, 1888, Mattie took laudanum and alcohol together in a dose large enough to kill her. Opium at that level slows the breathing until it stops. She was 38.

The death record was signed by a physician, Dr. Thomas H. Kennard. It names her as Mattie Earp, not Celia Blaylock, six years after Wyatt left her and with no marriage behind it. His name was still the one she died under.

The doctor put her age at 40, which suggests nobody in Pinal knew her very well. For the cause, he wrote the word that opened this story: “supposed.”

That word is honest. Nobody found a note. Nobody saw her measure the dose. A woman who had mixed laudanum and alcohol for years could misjudge it on any given night, and some who have studied her death think it may have been an accident.

But a death inquisition filed on July 21 came down on suicide. The official answer was suicide, while the doctor’s own wording left the door open.

Where was Wyatt Earp that summer? He was in San Diego with Josephine. In 1887 the two had gone there to ride the real estate boom, and between 1887 and about 1896, Wyatt owned four saloons and gambling halls in the city: one on Fifth Street, one on Fourth, and two near Sixth and E.

While the man with the famous name ran gambling halls in San Diego, the woman who had carried his name for about a decade was buried in a cemetery outside a dying town.

Did Wyatt even know? There is no letter, telegram or remark from him that answers that. If he heard, he never said anything anybody wrote down.

One more line in this story is the hardest, and it needs care. When researchers went looking for Mattie in the 1950s, among them Earp researcher John Gilchriese and writer Frank Waters, they turned up a coroner’s report for a Mattie Earp in Pinal.

With it came an account of something she supposedly said before she died: that Wyatt Earp had ruined her life.

That line has been repeated so often it is treated like a court record. It is not one. It comes down secondhand and surfaced more than 60 years after her death, and Waters is the same writer whose handling of Allie’s memories historians now question.

It may be exactly what she said. It cannot be proved. But you do not need the quote, because the documents speak for her.

They also explain why it took until the 1950s to find her at all. Wyatt lived until January 13, 1929. In his last years he worked with writer Stuart Lake on the biography that appeared in October 1931, two years after his death. Wyatt Earp, Frontier Marshal does not mention Mattie anywhere.

That was no accident. Josephine worked to keep Mattie’s name, and her own, out of the book. She wanted the Johnny Behan years gone too, and she even traveled to Boston to try to persuade the publisher to stop it. Afterward she called the finished book full of outright lies. Lake himself later admitted he had invented quotes and dialogue.

So the book that made Wyatt a national hero was partly made up, and it left out the one true thing about his household: that a woman listed as his wife in the 1880 census existed at all.

That book became the source for the movies, including two versions of Frontier Marshal in the 1930s, My Darling Clementine in 1946, and the television series The Life and Legend of Wyatt Earp from 1955 to 1961. A whole generation learned Wyatt from a story with Mattie cut out.

Josephine kept at it for the rest of her life. She threatened legal action against Waters over his Earp manuscript, and she worked with Wyatt’s cousins on her own account, the one historians call the Kason manuscript, to fix his story the way she wanted it remembered.

She also claimed she and Wyatt married in 1892 at sea, by the captain of Lucky Baldwin’s yacht. No public record of that marriage has ever been found either.

Consider the symmetry. Wyatt’s last two wives both lived as Mrs. Earp with no paper to prove it. One spent the rest of her life shaping how he would be remembered. The other died in Pinal.

And look at who finally put Mattie back into print. When her story resurfaced in the 1950s and ’60s, it came largely through Waters, whose book on Allie historians now treat with real caution. Then came Boyer’s 1976 book, the one that later fell apart.

The woman Wyatt’s official biography erased had her story told first by the two sources historians trust least. That is why the facts here lean on the census, the mortgage, the court case and the death record, and why anything else deserves a label.

When Josephine died in 1944, she was buried with Wyatt’s ashes in Colma, California, in a grave with his name on it. Mattie’s grave, in the old cemetery about a mile from what is left of Pinal City, had no marker at all until 2009, when the Tonto National Forest and local groups finally placed one.

By then the town had been gone for more than a century. Its post office closed on November 28, 1891, three years after Mattie died there, and the people went with it.

When Hollywood finally brought her back, it brought back the bottle. In Tombstone in 1993, Dana Wheeler-Nicholson played her as the sickly wife on laudanum.

A year later, in Wyatt Earp, Mare Winningham played her too. Both films let her drift off screen, which is close enough to the truth to be cruel.

Tombstone even sends Wyatt off after Josephine to start a new life, the ending Josephine would have loved. Its closing narration says Mattie died of an overdose soon after she left Tombstone.

Soon after? It was six years, and a lawsuit over her house and the record of her death both fall inside them. It works fine as a movie, but it is the Stuart Lake edit all over again, with better music.

What neither film puts in front of you is the paper. In February 1882, a notary had to take Mattie aside and ask whether she was signing away her home freely, and Wyatt named her as his wife on a loan he left unpaid.

In July 1888, a doctor in a dying silver town wrote her down as Mattie Earp, got her age wrong and called her death “supposed.” In between, there is no license, no letter and no telegram.

The only time Wyatt Earp himself put Mattie on paper as his wife was when she was useful for a loan.

Even Doc Holliday and Big Nose Kate, who had their own arrangement with no license anyone has found, ended theirs with Kate swearing out an affidavit against him. Mattie never got even that.

Disclaimer: This story is fictional and created for entertainment purposes only. Any names, characters, places, or events are fictitious or used fictitiously. No real person or organization is intended to be portrayed.

Related Articles