He Said He Was at Work When His Wife Was Found with an Axe in Her Head—37 Years Later, a Doctor Rewrote the Timeline and Sealed His Fate: The Case of Cathy Krauseneck |

He Said He Was at Work When His Wife Was Found with an Axe in Her Head—37 Years Later, a Doctor Rewrote the Timeline and Sealed His Fate: The Case of Cathy Krauseneck |

He Said He Was at Work When His Wife Was Found with an Axe in Her Head—37 Years Later, a Doctor Rewrote the Timeline and Sealed His Fate: The Case of Cathy Krauseneck.

There were no eyewitnesses. There were no ear witnesses. There was no direct evidence. That was the case 40 years ago, and it is the case now.

It was a little before 5:00 p.m. on Friday, February 19, 1982, in Brighton, New York. A woman opened her front door and found her neighbor standing there, clutching his 3-year-old daughter tightly to his chest. During the 911 call that followed, she told police he looked terrified.

“Police, there’s been, I think, a murder across the street.”

The dispatcher told her to calm down and asked what happened.

“I don’t know. Her husband’s here and he can’t even talk. She’s in her bed. Please, um, hurry.”

She was right. Inside the house on Del Rio Drive, 29-year-old Kathy Krauseneck lay dead in her bed with an ax in her head.

The man at the door was her husband, Jim. He told police he had left for work at 6:30 that morning and returned at 4:50 that afternoon, a gap of about 10 hours and 20 minutes. From the start, the entire case came down to one question: was Kathy already dead when Jim left for work? Nobody knew. Police zeroed in on Jim early, but suspecting a man and proving it are two different things, and for decades they could not prove it.

Then, almost 40 years later, a pathologist went back through the original 1982 file and arrived at a different time of death. There was also one detail in the first police report that would become a major point of contention. The only other living person in the house that afternoon was Jim and Kathy’s 3-year-old daughter, Sarah. The neighbor told police that as Jim held the girl, Sarah said, “I’m glad you came home early today, Daddy.”

Kathy Schloer grew up in Mount Clemens, Michigan, just outside Detroit, the second oldest of six children in a family of four girls and two boys. Her father drove a truck. Those who knew her remembered her energy, and a childhood friend described her as “everybody’s friend.”

She met Jim Krauseneck in high school. They came from the same small town, but their families were different: Jim’s owned a successful carpet business. The two dated through Western Michigan University and married in 1974 in what one relative described as a princess-style wedding. Kathy’s sister said education meant a great deal to her.

The couple moved as Jim’s career demanded, first to Colorado, where he studied economics, then to Virginia, where he taught. In 1978, they had a daughter, Sarah. In September 1981, Jim took a job as an economist at Eastman Kodak, and the family moved again, this time to Brighton, a suburb of Rochester.

They bought a colonial house on Del Rio Drive. Kathy, 29, planned to stay home with Sarah. Neighbors and friends said the couple seemed close, and one friend recalled how excited Kathy was about motherhood. They had lived in the house only about five months.

Jim’s account of that day is the yardstick against which everything else is measured. He told police it was an ordinary morning. He left for Kodak around 6:30, with Kathy still asleep and Sarah, then 3½, at home with her. Work was normal. At 4:50 p.m., he returned, intending to take Sarah to an appointment, and found Kathy dead in their bed. He grabbed his daughter and ran to the neighbor’s house.

Police arrived by about 5:00. One of the first officers up the stairs was a young patrolman who, 40 years later, would testify about what he saw. Kathy lay in bed with an ax in her head, he said, looking as if she were sleeping. Jim came up the stairs right behind him and, according to the officer, tried to climb onto his back. He swung between screaming and silence. When the officer asked when he had left the house, Jim answered calmly: 6:30 in the morning.

What do you make of that? Minutes earlier, the neighbor had thought Jim was going into shock.

Then there was Sarah. She was unharmed, but she had dressed herself that day. She wore several sweaters with the buttons lined up wrong and several pairs of socks. It is a small detail, but a hard one to shake.

Police now had a body, a house, a little girl and a husband who said he had been at work all day. What they lacked was a time. A body does not come with a clock. Doctors work backward from clues: how cold the body is, how stiff, what remains in the stomach. None of it yields an exact hour.

Around 9:00 that night, the county medical examiner took Kathy’s temperature. It was about 81 degrees. Using the standard rule of thumb for cooling, she estimated death occurred between 4:30 and 7:30 that morning, give or take two hours.

Another pathologist later reviewed the case and came up with 5:55 to 8:55. Both ranges begin before Jim’s stated 6:30 departure, and both extend past it. Kathy could have been killed while Jim was still home, or after he had left. The doctors could not say which. That gap would become the central problem of the case.

The next day, Jim left for Michigan with his parents, who had driven in to be with the family, and with Sarah. Police said he left without telling them and missed a follow-up interview. That can be read two ways: a man on the run, or a man who had just found his wife murdered and wanted his family around him.

Detectives followed him to Michigan. About a week after the murder, one of them questioned him. Jim answered their questions and gave investigators hair and blood samples. According to that detective, he even said, “Please don’t give up on my case.” Ten days after the murder, Jim hired a lawyer. By then, police were focused squarely on him.

But focus is not proof. Without a time of death, nobody could say Jim was home when it happened, and without that, there was no case. The file sat for 37 years.

Still, something about the house never sat right. When police first walked in, the first floor looked exactly like a burglary. A pane of glass in the door from the garage was broken, and a two-foot mallet was found nearby. In the dining room, a woman’s purse had been dumped out and a silver tea set lay on the floor. At first, police believed a burglar had broken in, Kathy had woken up, and he had killed her.

Then came the questions. What did the burglar take? Nothing. Upstairs, about $43 sat on a dresser, in plain view from the hallway, and nobody had gone through the rest of the room. Who breaks in, kills someone and leaves cash where he can see it?

The tea set bothered investigators too. One said a burglar would be in a hurry, yet the tea set was on the floor while pictures nearby still stood upright. It looked less like something knocked over in a rush and more like something someone had placed there. Next to it was a garbage bag with a faint shoe print inside, as if someone had stepped on the bag to hold it open.

At trial, an expert said the print was consistent with a boat shoe. Crime scene photos showed a pair of boat shoes by Kathy’s bed, the kind Jim was known to wear. And this was February in upstate New York. One detective later noted that you don’t normally see killers running around in winter wearing boat shoes.

Little by little, police changed their thinking. They stopped looking only for a burglar and began looking at the house itself, at things that might have been arranged to suggest a robbery. Decades later, that is exactly what prosecutors would argue: the burglary was staged, and Jim staged it.

The defense had its own points. Someone else could have smashed the window. Nobody saw Jim do any of it, and no physical evidence directly tied him to the scene. The boat shoes were never tested against the print, because the original investigators did not keep them. The expert could say the print was consistent with a boat shoe. He could not say it was Jim’s.

If the burglary was real, who was the burglar? That was the question the defense kept returning to, and it had a name: Ed Larabe. In 1982, he lived about half a mile from the Krauseneck home and was on parole for violent crimes against women. Not long after Kathy’s death, police got a tip about him. An investigator went to his door, and Larabe threw him out and made threats. That was it. Nobody went back.

Eventually, Larabe did confess. By then he was in prison, dying of ALS, and he told the FBI that Kathy had been one of his victims. At first, some of it seemed to fit. Authorities already believed at least one of his other confessions, involving the 1991 murder of a music teacher, was genuine. He mentioned details that sounded familiar: an ax in a garage, wiping things down with a dish towel.

Then investigators looked closer, and the details fell apart. He got the year wrong. He said the woman had short dark hair, but Kathy’s hair was long and blonde. He said he had sexually assaulted her, but nothing indicated that. The biggest problem was that Larabe said Kathy had been awake, on her knees when he struck her. The evidence showed she was asleep in bed.

Police and the district attorney’s office concluded Larabe had made it up. They also noted that he wanted pizza, sandwiches and a promise that he would be buried outside the prison grounds. The defense offered another explanation: Larabe was heavily medicated, and decades had passed, so the contradictions could have stemmed from his condition and the passage of time. The theory ended up as a confession with some details that fit and several important ones that did not. The authorities rejected it. The defense did not.

In 2015, police took another look at the case with the FBI’s cold case unit. They pulled the 1982 evidence and sent it back to the lab, hoping new DNA technology might show someone else had been inside the house. It did not.

Nothing suggested anyone besides the Krauseneck family had been there. It did not tie Jim to the murder either, and the two sides read that result differently. Prosecutors argued that when no one else can be found in the house, that tells you something.

For 37 years, investigators had been missing two things: a way to say nobody else was in the house, and a way to put Jim inside it when Kathy was killed. The first had finally come from the lab. The second was still sitting in the old 1982 file.

Years later, police brought in Dr. Michael Baden, a well-known forensic pathologist. He had no new evidence, only the same file, the same autopsy notes and the same photographs, but he read them differently. He focused on three things: how stiff Kathy’s body was, how far the food in her stomach had digested, and her body temperature. The first two were useful. The temperature could change everything.

Around 9 that night, the medical examiner had measured Kathy’s temperature at about 81 degrees. Normal is around 98.6, so she had lost roughly 17 degrees. The question was how fast. The defense’s medical examiner said the usual rate was about a degree and a half per hour.

The 1982 pathologist used about 1 to 1¼ degrees per hour. Baden used 1 degree per hour, reasoning in part that Kathy was fully clothed and lying under a comforter and an electric blanket. The differences sound small, but across 15 hours, a fraction of a degree can move the estimated time of death by hours.

Then there was the blanket. In 1982, a Brighton sergeant wrote that it had two controls and both were turned off. That mattered because a blanket that was on would have kept adding heat, keeping the body warmer longer and supporting an earlier time of death. A blanket that was off was simply more insulation.

When Baden testified before the grand jury, he said it was unclear whether the blanket had been on. The defense argued this left jurors with the impression that it might have been, and asked a judge to throw out the indictment. The judge refused, and because the sergeant had died in 2011, prosecutors agreed to put his old note before the jury. Both sides fought over the blanket, and it proves nothing on its own.

What matters is where Baden’s calculations led. He told jurors Kathy died between 1:30 and 5:30 a.m., with a best estimate of 3:30, hours before Jim said he left for work. Was Kathy already dead when Jim walked out the door? Baden’s answer was “very likely.” The defense disagreed, arguing that his entire opinion rested on body temperature. Remove the temperature calculation, they said, and nothing was left.

But the clock tells you only when, not why. For that, prosecutors had a theory. They did not have to prove a motive, but in a case with no eyewitness and no confession, a motive can carry weight. They told the jury that Jim had applied to Kodak claiming a Ph.D., and that in 1982 Kodak was trying to verify the degree and having trouble.

Jim had studied economics at Colorado State but never finished his dissertation. According to prosecutors and Kathy’s family, Kathy eventually found out, and that discovery led to the murder. Kathy’s sister told the jury that education had always mattered to Kathy, that Kathy confronted Jim after learning he never earned the degree, and that Jim had been calling himself Dr. Krauseneck. That was the family’s belief about what happened.

Investigators also found a marriage counselor’s pamphlet in the family car. Prosecutors saw a marriage in trouble. The defense saw it differently, saying the pamphlet proved nothing, and Jim denied his education had caused problems between them.

His lawyers told the jury that relatives and friends had known for years he hadn’t completed the degree, so there was no secret waiting to be exposed. They put the question to jurors directly: why would he do this?

The motive hinged on what Kathy knew, and the only person who could answer that was dead. There was one other person in the house, though: a 3-year-old. On the day her mother died, Sarah told police she had seen a bad man. She said he had long blonde hair and was sleeping in Mommy and Daddy’s bed with something in his head. Asked what color the man was, she said, “Many colors.”

It sounds like a witness. But the lieutenant who spoke with Sarah didn’t believe she had seen a man at all. Kathy also had long blonde hair, he reasoned. Nobody could prove what Sarah actually saw. She was 3, and it was the worst day of her life. Detectives wrote down every word anyway, and the motive was left hanging on what Kathy knew, with a toddler as the only possible witness.

The trial opened on September 6, 2022, and over the following weeks it became a battle between doctors. Prosecutors put Baden on the stand early. He said Kathy died before 6:30 that morning, probably in the middle of the night.

The prosecution’s account was simple: Jim went into the garage, grabbed the ax he used to chop wood, went upstairs and killed Kathy while she slept. Then, prosecutors said, he made the house look like a break-in and went to work.

The defense went straight after the clock, promising three medical examiners to challenge Baden. One, a deputy chief medical examiner from Erie County, testified that Kathy’s death could have come after 6:30, when Jim was already gone, as late as 1:30 that afternoon.

Jim’s lead lawyer then returned to the original medical examiner, the doctor who performed Kathy’s 1982 autopsy. She had estimated death between 4:30 and 7:30 a.m., give or take two hours. Extend that range and it runs from 2:30 a.m. to 9:30 a.m. By 2022, she had been dead for years, so nobody could ask what she meant.

That range has room for both stories. Baden’s 3:30 fits, but so does 8:00. Even Baden acknowledged on cross-examination that his calculations and interpretation differed from the original examiner’s. Nobody on the stand could tell the jury the exact minute Kathy died, not even Baden.

That was the jury’s problem. Qualified experts on both sides were looking at the same evidence, and the answer to whether Jim was still home when Kathy was killed depended on which interpretation they accepted. Jim’s lawyer put it bluntly: what is there to prove this happened before 6:30? You can’t just assume it.

The prosecution said the case didn’t rest on the clock alone. There was the staged scene, the shoe print, the Ph.D. issue and the absence of any trace of someone else in the house. That is how a circumstantial case works, they argued. One piece doesn’t have to tell the whole story. The question is whether the pieces together add up.

The jury got the case on a Friday, and a few hours into deliberations sent the judge a note asking for the legal definition of beyond a reasonable doubt. The judge explained there was no such thing as probably guilty or maybe guilty. It was guilty or not guilty.

On Monday, September 26, 2022, the jury returned a unanimous verdict: guilty of second-degree murder. Jim was taken into custody in the courtroom.

Six weeks later came sentencing. Kathy’s father had traveled from Michigan. After 40 years, he thanked the court. Then Jim spoke for the first time.

“To this day, it’s still very difficult for me to talk about the circumstances that surrounded her death.”

“All I see is Kathy with an ax in her head and Sarah standing in the hallway.”

“I did not murder Kathy. I love Kathy with all my heart and with all my soul.”

Sarah spoke too. She said her mother’s killer had gotten away with it, and that her father’s life had been taken by a failed justice system. The judge sentenced Jim to 25 years to life.

He served less than six months. In prison, he was diagnosed with esophageal cancer. In March, he was moved to the infirmary, and on May 5, 2023, he died at 71.

His lawyers had already filed an appeal, and here the case took another turn. Under New York law, when a defendant dies with an appeal pending, the conviction is wiped out, a doctrine called abatement. The conviction is vacated and the indictment dismissed, as though the case never reached a final conviction.

The district attorney’s office called it the normal legal process. Jim’s family wanted the appeal to continue so they could try to prove his innocence. His lawyer said he was confident an appeals court would have overturned the conviction, partly because of the 37 years between the murder and the indictment.

In July, the appeals court rejected the request and sent the case back to be dismissed. In October 2023, a judge made it official.

That left the case in an unusual place. A jury had heard weeks of evidence and found Jim guilty, but on paper there was no conviction. An appeal could neither confirm the jury’s decision nor establish Jim’s innocence. It did not mean a court found him innocent, only that the conviction could no longer stand as a matter of law. The appeal never ruled on whether the jury got it right.

So the case ends without the answer either side wanted. The jury gave its verdict. The appeals court never got to give one. Jim died still denying he killed Kathy.

Which brings you back to the first question: was Kathy already dead when Jim walked out the door? That still depends on whose clock you believe.

Disclaimer: This story is fictional and created for entertainment purposes only. Any names, characters, places, or events are fictitious or used fictitiously. No real person or organization is intended to be portrayed.

Related Articles