She Bailed Out the Man Who Abused Her Daughter—Then the Court Gave Her Child Back, and He Killed Her While the 9-Year-Old Called 911||
Chantel Rhoden bailed out the man who abused her 9-year-old daughter—despite being warned. Three weeks later, he beat her to death while her daughter locked herself in a bedroom and called 911.

On the night of June 15, at 9:10 p.m., a 9-year-old girl in Milwaukee locked herself in her bedroom and dialed 911. She gave the address correctly, twice, zip code included, which is more than many adults manage under stress. She spelled her own name for the dispatcher, then spelled her mother’s.
The dispatcher asked who else was in the house. She named her stepfather. She named a 10-year-old boy in the next room, and her little sister, who was 2 and asleep. Then the dispatcher asked whether she could get out.
“No,” she said. “He’s by the door.”
Downstairs, Chantel Rhoden was already dying on the floor of her own front room. She had about four minutes left, and her daughter stayed on the phone for every one of them. Twenty-three days earlier, a judge had sent that little girl home to this house.
Everyone involved had known what was inside it. A doctor had photographed the child’s injuries. A detective held her recorded statement. The state had removed her from her mother for her own protection, then returned her after her mother stood in a courtroom and swore the man was gone.
He had never left.
To understand how the case reached that night, you have to start years earlier, with a different death. Terrell Latimer and Chantel met at 22. Their daughter, Jouri, arrived when they were 26. They never married, but they were together about six years and lived in a duplex on Milwaukee’s north side, together “on and off, mostly on,” as people who knew them put it.
By nearly every account they were not a great couple. They were, by the same accounts, decent parents.
Terrell worked at a plant on the edge of Menomonee Falls that made hydraulic fittings, and he had been there since he was 19. He died on a Tuesday in March at age 31. A ruptured aneurysm struck him in a break room, with two coworkers present. Paramedics reached the building in nine minutes, but there was no sequence of events that would have saved him. Jouri was 4. She has almost no memory of him.
His older sister, Deanna Latimer, was the one who took the call from the plant. Deanna was 41 at the time of the events that followed. She had worked nine years at a medical supply distributor in Mount Pleasant and waited tables four evenings a week on top of it. She had a 19-year-old daughter at technical college, had divorced at 31, and had not remarried or particularly wanted to.
What happened to Chantel after the funeral is, by the family’s own telling, the thing that has to be understood first, because everything else grew out of it. The 18 months that followed are unusually well documented, because the state later pulled her entire financial history for the child welfare case.
Two evictions appear in it. So does a nine-day stretch in December of that first year when the gas was shut off, a fact recorded in a utility file that Deanna did not learn until she read it in a court filing years later.
There is a payday loan from February of the second year, for $400, that cost her $900 by the time it closed. There is also one line in a nursing home’s payroll records that Deanna has never gotten past. In the week that would have been Terrell’s birthday, Chantel worked six shifts.
She fell apart, and nobody helped her. There was a funeral, then a casserole period of about four weeks, and then everyone went back to their lives. Terrell’s mother, Bernardine, and his sister did what they could. But the relationship between Chantel and that family had never been warm, and a dead man is not much of a bridge.
Chantel had no parents. Her mother died when she was 19, and she never knew her father. She had a 4-year-old, a duplex she couldn’t afford alone, and no life insurance, because Terrell was 31 and had never thought about it. She lost her call center job in November over absences.
She moved twice in 18 months. She worked a gas station, then laundry at a nursing home, then landed a job at a fulfillment center off Good Hope Road. The shift ran 10 p.m. to 6 a.m., and she held it for the next four years. By every account, she was extremely lonely the whole time.
Deanna saw it. She lived 35 miles away, worked two jobs, and had a daughter finishing high school. She took Jouri when she could and sent money twice, and she did not do more. If she had it to do again, she says, she would have done more. She has no idea what “more” would have looked like.
There is also something about those years that people who tell this story tend to leave out, and it is the only part of Chantel that anyone defends. She kept that child fed and in school through two evictions, a car that died, a winter without gas, and a job that paid $12 an hour. Jouri did not miss school. She had a coat every winter. Her birthday cake was homemade, because a bakery cake cost $19.
Her second-grade teacher later gave the state a statement running four paragraphs, in which she went out of her way to say that the mother had shown up. She came to conferences and reading nights, every one. That is the same woman who would later stand on a porch in Racine.
Almost nobody in this story has managed to hold both of those facts at once. Both are true.
Chantel met Wayne Stalworth at a cookout in Sherman Park the summer after Jouri turned 7. He was 36. He had a son, Bryce, who was 8 and lived with him full-time. Bryce’s mother had left when the boy was 2 and had been in Georgia ever since.
That last fact did more work for Wayne than anything else about him. A single father raising a boy alone is what people saw, and it is what Chantel saw. It is also what made every warning she received afterward sound like people being hard on a man who was doing his best.
And some of what people saw was accurate. Bryce was clean, fed, and polite. Whatever Wayne was, he had kept a child alive for six years on almost no money, moving from a rented room to a friend’s basement to an apartment in West Allis. That is visible from a folding chair at a park cookout. It is also the kind of fact a defense attorney puts in front of a jury as evidence that a man is not a monster.
The record, however, tells a harder story, and it existed before Chantel ever met him. Wayne had not held a job longer than 14 months since he was 25. He had worked a warehouse, a scrapyard, and a delivery outfit that let him go after six months. When they met, he was picking up occasional cash shifts with a residential demolition contractor.
He had an operating-while-intoxicated conviction from age 28 and a second from age 33. He had a disorderly conduct charge from an incident outside a bar in Wauwatosa. He had also been the subject of a restraining order, taken out by a woman in West Allis three years earlier. It expired without incident and sat in Milwaukee County’s public records, where nobody looked, because nobody thinks to.
What he had in place of a job was a story about a job. A cousin was going to bring him onto a crew. A license was coming. A man in Franklin was going to sell him a truck cheap so he could subcontract. He told it at every cookout for two years, and people stopped asking after about eight months, which he took as the matter being settled.
Deanna asked him once, at the wedding, because she wanted to hear him say something specific with a date attached. He said things were moving.
He also drank every day. Not to the point of falling down, and not in a way that stopped him functioning, but steadily, from about 4 p.m. onward. Everybody in that park knew. That isn’t hindsight. A friend of a friend, someone Chantel barely knew, told her within three weeks of meeting Wayne that he had known him for years and she should be careful.
“Careful of what?” she asked.
“Just careful,” he said, and would not go further, which is what men tend to do about other men.
Chantel described that conversation to her supervisor at work a few nights later as somebody being nasty about a man who had turned his life around.
About a year into the marriage, Wayne began selling out of the house. It was not a business. It was mostly pills and some weed, at a scale that covered what he drank and little else. In two years he never paid a month’s rent from it.
What it did to the household is what matters. People came to the door. These were men Chantel had never met, arriving at hours she was at work, because those were the hours he did it. Jouri later described two occasions to a forensic interviewer. A man came twice, months apart, and the second time he shouted on the porch. Her stepfather argued with him for about ten minutes while she took her little sister upstairs and shut a bedroom door.
She was 9. Her sister was 2.
Chantel knew about the dealing. It surfaced in an argument that Bryce overheard and later repeated. She raised it, and Wayne told her she didn’t know what she was talking about. That was the end of it.
She knew about the drinking within about two months, and told people it was under control. She told Deanna the same thing on the phone once, unprompted, which is what people tend to do when they have been thinking about something.
The first six months looked fine from the outside, and that is why nobody could get purchase on it. Three separate people said Wayne was good with Jouri at the start, and Deanna has never disputed it. He fixed her bike. He picked her up from school twice when Chantel couldn’t, and was on time both times. He learned she didn’t like being surprised, and for a while he was careful about it. Bryce and Jouri, 8 and 7, got on the way children do, completely and without reference to anything the adults were doing.
Chantel was visibly better for about five months. She laughed on the phone and started cooking again. In the fourth month, she told her supervisor she had forgotten what it was like to have someone ask how your night was. Deanna saw it at a birthday party in the fifth month, thought “All right,” and left relieved. She did not think about him again for about four months.
They moved in together after seven months, and the marriage followed. A daughter, Noel, was born 14 months after the wedding. By the time any of this began, she was 2, walking, and in that house every hour of every day.
By the accounts of everyone who was in that home, Wayne was fine with the toddler. That is a sentence that sits badly, and it is true. People describe a man who behaved differently with the 2-year-old than with the 9-year-old, and the difference was not subtle. Jouri noticed it. She said so in an interview in about six words that a room full of adults had to sit through.
Nearly everyone who cared about Chantel told her not to go through with it. Her supervisor at the fulfillment center, who had worked beside her for two years, said she was moving too fast and that a 36-year-old man without a job was not going to start now. A friend from the old duplex said she had watched him at a cookout and did not like how he talked to his own son.
Bernardine Latimer, Terrell’s mother and Jouri’s grandmother, called and said one thing and did not say it twice. She told Chantel to take her time, because there was a little girl in the house.
Deanna said nothing, on purpose, and has never forgiven herself. She was the sister of the man Chantel had been with for six years, and she had never been close to her. Anything she said about a new man would land as jealousy on behalf of a dead brother. She weighed the cost of being that woman against the cost of silence and chose silence. She kept it for two years.
The couple married at the courthouse nine months after the cookout, with four people present. The house on 47th Street was Chantel’s, a three-bedroom two-story rental she had moved into two years before meeting him. It was the best place she had lived since Terrell died. Wayne arrived with Bryce and a truck bed of belongings.
He paid no rent the first month and none in the 24th. That surfaced later in Chantel’s own bank records, which the state pulled for a different purpose. From the day he moved in until the day she died, the rent, the utilities, the car insurance on the vehicle he drove, and the groceries for four people all came out of an account that held only her wages. He worked, on average, about nine days a month.
What he contributed, in his own telling, was that he was there. Chantel worked nights, and he was in the house with the children. He said so often.
“Somebody had to be there.”
That was true, and it made the arrangement look sensible from outside. It also meant a 9-year-old girl spent eight hours a night, five nights a week, in a house where the only adult was a man who had been drinking since 4 p.m.
The verbal abuse came first, and it was not hidden. He called her stupid, routinely enough that Bryce repeated it later without being asked, as something that was simply said in that house. He called her slow. When she got something wrong at the table, he would keep at it in front of everyone until she stopped talking, then tell her she was being sensitive. He compared her to his son constantly, and always in the same direction.
When he had been drinking, he went after her about her father. He told a 9-year-old girl that her daddy was dead and wasn’t coming, that nobody was coming for her, that this was her house now and he was what she had. He said it in different forms and often enough that she later repeated three separate versions to a forensic interviewer, unprompted.
Chantel was at work for most of it. For some of it, she was not. Bryce described a dinner table with four people at it, and that detail did the most damage in court later. A good deal of this happened at 6 p.m., with her mother in the room.
Her response on those occasions was to tell him to leave it alone, to ask him to stop, and then to let it go when he didn’t. Afterward she would tell Jouri that Wayne hadn’t meant it and had had a hard day.
In the first year, somebody nearly got there. Jouri’s third-grade teacher put a note in the file in February about her grades, a routine academic concern, after a slide from B’s to D’s in a single semester. The school sent a letter home. The adult who checked the mail was Wayne, and it never reached Chantel. A conference was offered for a Thursday afternoon, and nobody attended.
The teacher followed up once by phone in March, reached voicemail on a number belonging to a woman who slept during the day, and closed the note. Nobody has ever called that negligence. It was a teacher with 29 children and a letter that did what letters do.
The physical abuse began in the second year, and nobody outside the house knew until March. This account will not describe it scene by scene. What exists is what a pediatrician documented on March 22 and what a 9-year-old told a trained interviewer on the 24th. That is all anyone knows.
She had been grabbed by the arm and by the back of the neck. She had been pushed into furniture twice and into a door frame once. She was made to stand in a corner of the kitchen for stretches the interviewer’s notes put at up to an hour, forbidden to sit or lean. Food was used as punishment. She was sent to bed without dinner often enough that she had worked out which nights it was likely and started keeping things in her room. On one occasion in January, she was shut in an upstairs closet.
That is the record, and it covers about 14 months.
Bryce got a version of it too, and that version is why he later talked. His father did not hit him. Bryce said so flatly, more than once. What Wayne did was use him. Bryce was held up at that table every night as the example, with better grades, better behavior, quicker answers, out loud and in front of a girl who had to sit there. He was 10 and understood exactly what was being done with him.
At some point in the second year, he began getting answers wrong on purpose. He said it himself in a forensic interview. He started missing questions at the table so his dad would stop.
Jouri told no one. Not a teacher, not her grandmother, not her aunt. Not the school nurse, who saw her twice that year for stomachaches no one could explain. She got very good at the house instead. She learned its schedule. Four in the afternoon was when it started, and 10 was when it got bad, so she learned to be upstairs before 9. She stopped asking for things. She stopped bringing friends over, which a child can do without ever being told.
Her grades went from good to average to bad over those 14 months. Her teacher flagged it, and another letter went home to a parent who worked nights. The nurse’s log has the two visits, dated. The first was in October, and she was sent back to class after 20 minutes. The second was in February. The nurse kept her most of an afternoon, called home, and reached Wayne, who came to collect her. The nurse wrote that the child had been reluctant to leave.
That log went into evidence four months after Chantel died. It is two lines long.
She also became extremely good at reading a room, which her therapist flagged in the first month as the most telling behavior in the whole file. At 9, she could tell how much he had had to drink from across a room. She didn’t count drinks. She listened for a change in his voice, which she described to a county therapist as him “getting slower.”
She had built her entire evening around that sound for over a year. If she was upstairs before 9, it was usually fine. If her mother was working, it was worse. If her mother was home, it was different, but not better. And she knew not to be the first to speak at the table, which is part of why her grades fell. A child who has learned not to speak in her own house does not raise her hand in a classroom.
She also got smaller. She had been at the top of the growth chart at 7 and was near the bottom at 9. The only person likely to have noticed was a doctor, and she hadn’t seen one in two years.
Deanna had met Wayne four times. She disliked him from the first meeting and said nothing for two years, because she was the dead husband’s sister and anything she said would have sounded like jealousy. She decided that being “that woman” was worse than being quiet. She has since concluded she was wrong.
Her closest approach came at the wedding. It was a Tuesday morning at the courthouse downtown, with four people present: Chantel, Wayne, Bryce, and Jouri, who was 8 and had been put in a dress. Deanna was not invited. She learned of it from her mother, who had learned from Chantel by text three days earlier. She drove up anyway and waited in the corridor, and Chantel came out to see her.
They talked for about 90 seconds. Chantel asked if she was going to make a face. Deanna said no, said congratulations, and hugged her. Then she stood in that corridor while it happened and drove back to Racine.
On the drive she made a decision, properly and with reasons, to keep her mouth shut and stay in the child’s life. The alternative was a fight that would leave her unwelcome and a 9-year-old with no one from her father’s side. She has replayed that drive more than anything else in her life.
By the time she picked Jouri up on a Friday in March, she had not had her for six months. The gap wasn’t deliberate. A Christmas had gone to Wayne’s cousins. A February weekend was cancelled twice, and Deanna let it go both times because she was working two jobs and pushing felt like overstepping. Six months is a long time in a 9-year-old.
That Friday night, small things began to add up, though Deanna did not register them until much later. Jouri asked at about 9:30 what time she had to go to bed. Deanna said whenever she liked, since it was Friday. The child sat on the couch and watched two hours of television with her aunt, getting up three separate times to ask whether it was all right that she was still up.
On Saturday morning, Deanna came in from the yard and pulled the kitchen door shut hard behind her, the way it always sticks and bangs. Jouri was at the table. She came up off her chair about four inches and put both arms over her head. She laughed a second later. Deanna laughed too, made a joke about the door, and then stood at the counter with her hands flat on it.
That afternoon, at a store on Durand Avenue, Jouri picked up a pack of hair ties, about $2. Deanna told her to get whatever she wanted. Jouri put them back. Deanna said she meant it, and put them in the cart.
“What if he says I can’t?”
Not “she.” “He.”
Deanna asked what she meant. Jouri said nothing and wouldn’t look at her. After about nine seconds, she said she had a stomachache and asked if they could go.
That night, Deanna called her mother. Bernardine was 67 and had buried a son. She listened to her daughter describe three things that were each, individually, nothing, and said one sentence.
“You need to look at that child.”
“What do you mean, look at her?”
“You know what I mean.”
Deanna didn’t sleep. She sat in her front room from about midnight to 3 a.m. doing what people in her position do, building a case against herself. Six months. Two cancelled visits she hadn’t pushed back on. She scrolled through nine photographs of Jouri from the past year. In the last, a Christmas picture sent by Chantel and taken in that house, the child stood slightly behind everyone else with her arms at her sides. Deanna had looked at that photo in December and thought it was a nice picture.
On Sunday morning she did what she did, and she did it badly, as she herself has never denied. She ran Jouri a bath, which she hadn’t done since the girl was about 5 and which a 9-year-old does not need. She stayed in the room and talked about nothing.
What she saw, she saw in about four seconds. There were bruises on both upper arms in a pattern a grown woman recognizes as the shape of a hand. There was bruising on the back of the right shoulder, running toward the shoulder blade. There were two older, yellowed marks on the left forearm. There was a healing split on the inside of the lower lip that Jouri had been holding her mouth oddly about for two days, which Deanna had assumed was a mouth ulcer.
She said nothing in the bathroom. She got the girl dressed, made breakfast, sat down across from her, and asked straight out who had done it.
Jouri said she fell. Asked again, she said she fell down the stairs, then off her bike. Then she began to cry and said the sentence that ended the conversation and started everything else.
“Please don’t tell my mom I told you.”
Deanna sat in her own kitchen with a 9-year-old crying at her table and understood two things at once. This had been going on for a long time. And the child had just told her, in seven words, that her mother already knew.
She did not call Chantel. Many people have since second-guessed that, and Deanna has never wavered. She had a child who had just asked her not to tell, and 35 miles between that child and the house she was due back in on Monday. She considered calling Chantel for about 40 minutes and played it to the end.
Either Chantel wouldn’t believe her, and the child would go home to a house where a man now knew she had talked. Or Chantel would believe her, and a woman with night shifts, no money, and no family would confront a man at 4 p.m. on a Sunday with two children in the house. In no version of that call was a 9-year-old safer.
Instead, she called the Racine Police Department’s non-emergency line that Sunday afternoon at about 2:20. Two officers came. They spoke to Deanna in the kitchen and did not interview Jouri, which is not what a patrol officer does with a 9-year-old disclosing abuse. They took a report and made a referral, and because the child lived in Milwaukee, the referral went there.
On Tuesday, March 22, Jouri was examined by a pediatrician at Children’s Wisconsin. That examination became the spine of everything that followed. The physician documented seven separate injuries in three stages of healing, photographed all of them, and recorded that their pattern and location were not consistent with the accidental explanations the child had offered. She was in the fourth percentile for weight.
On Thursday, she was interviewed on video at a child advocacy center by a forensic interviewer, with no family member in the room, as the protocol requires. It ran 51 minutes and became the document on which the whole criminal case rested. The remarkable thing was how little the interviewer had to do. It was not an interrogation. The technique is the opposite, with open questions, no suggestions, nothing leading, and a great deal of silence.
What came out, over 51 minutes, was a structured account of 14 months from a 9-year-old. She described the schedule, 4 in the afternoon and 10 at night. She described where in the house things happened and which room she went to. She gave three versions of what her stepfather had said about her dead father, in the order they occurred, months apart, without being asked to sequence them. She described the January closet and how long she was in it and how she got out.
Near the end, the interviewer asked, in the neutral way they are trained to, whether she had ever told a grown-up.
She said no. Asked why not, she said her mom knew.
Wayne Stalworth was arrested at the house on 47th Street on Friday, March 25, around 7:20 p.m. He was charged with physical abuse of a child, intentionally causing bodily harm, under Wisconsin statute 948.03, with a second count of the same and a count of child neglect. When officers searched the house that night, they found what he had been selling. It wasn’t much, but it was enough for a possession-with-intent charge, added the following week.
It also changed the child protection case in a way the abuse alone might not have. A house with that in it, and a 2-year-old in the house, is a different kind of file. Wayne said little at the scene and nothing afterward, and had a public defender by Monday.
Then came the part almost nobody outside the system knows, and which drove the rest of the story. Milwaukee’s child protective services division filed a petition, and both of Chantel’s daughters were taken into state custody. Not from Wayne, who was in a cell. From her.
Under Wisconsin law, a child can be found in need of protection or services where a parent failed to prevent abuse the parent knew or should have known about. The state’s position, laid out in the petition and later in court, was that Chantel had been in that house for 14 months, had been at the table for some of it, and had told her daughter the man hadn’t meant it.
Jouri was placed with Deanna in Racine on a temporary order. Noel was not. Deanna asked for her, by phone on the first day and again in writing, and received the same answer both times, which was not unreasonable. She had no biological or legal relationship to the child and had met her perhaps six times. Relative placement means relative. A 2-year-old with a father facing charges and a mother under investigation goes into licensed foster care while it is sorted out.
There was also a practical side no one said aloud, which Deanna worked out on the drive home. She had given up a second job to take one child. She couldn’t have taken two.
Noel went to a licensed foster placement in Milwaukee County on March 26, to strangers. Her 9-year-old sister, who had been the one taking her upstairs when men came to the door, learned of it two days later in a kitchen in Racine.
One point about removals explains why the next nine weeks unfolded as they did. The state was not saying Chantel had hurt her daughter. Nobody has ever said that, and no document in the case file does. The state’s position was that a child had been physically abused in her home over 14 months, that some of it happened in front of her mother, that the child had told her so, and that the mother’s response had been to tell the child the man hadn’t meant it.
In Wisconsin, as in every state, that is enough. It is enough for a reason, because the alternative is a system that returns children to homes where the abuser lives with someone who will not act. None of that makes it feel like anything but the state taking your child.
Chantel learned her daughters had been removed by phone at work on a Friday night. She left the fulfillment center at 10:09 p.m., drove to Racine, and reached Deanna’s porch around 10:40. Two neighbors heard what followed.
Chantel accused her sister-in-law of taking her child. She said Deanna had always wanted her. She said Terrell’s family had never thought she was good enough and had been waiting eight years for this. She said whatever Jouri had told them, she’d said it because Deanna had gotten into her head over four days.
Deanna said one thing.
“Come and look at her arms.”
Chantel said no. She did not go inside. She stood on a porch in Racine at that hour and declined to look at her daughter’s arms, because looking meant it was true. Then she got in her car and drove home.
Everything else in this story is downstream of that moment.
Deanna called the next day and got no answer, and again the day after. On the third day Chantel picked up, said nine words, and hung up.
“Don’t call my phone. You’ve done enough to me.”
Bernardine called that week and got further. The conversation lasted about 20 minutes, most of it Chantel crying. Near the end, Bernardine asked, as gently as she has ever asked anyone anything, whether she had known.
Chantel said she hadn’t known it was like that.
Not that she hadn’t known. That she hadn’t known it was like that. Bernardine repeated that sentence on a witness stand seven months later. It is the only thing anyone in the family ever got from her about what she understood.
Chantel’s defenders read it as a woman who sensed trouble and truly did not grasp its scale. The state read the same sentence as an admission that she knew enough. The record can’t settle which, and Chantel is not here to say.
The following Tuesday, she bailed Wayne out. Cash bail had been set at $3,000 at his initial appearance, and she did not have it. She took an advance against her paycheck at a lender on Capitol Drive, borrowed the rest from a coworker, and paid a bondsman. He walked out of the Milwaukee County jail on March 29.
His release carried a no-contact condition. He was not to contact the child or be in a residence where the child was present. The child was 35 miles away in Racine, so on paper nothing was being violated. Chantel took him home to 47th Street, and within a week he was living there again.
Why she did it is what everyone asks, and she answered it herself, to three different people, and the answer never changed. Her caseworker told her by phone that posting his bail would be documented and raised at the hearing, and asked if she understood what she was doing. Chantel said he was her husband. Bernardine asked the same question that week, in a longer conversation, and got the same sentence back.
“He is my husband. I’m not leaving him in there.”
Her supervisor asked on a break and was told to mind her own business.
There was no strategy in it. Nobody has ever found one, and Chantel never offered one. She did not say she was doing it to get Jouri back. She did not say she thought the report was wrong. She said she loved him and wouldn’t leave him in a cell. Then she went to a payday lender on Capitol Drive and borrowed $3,000 at a rate that would have cost her nine by year’s end.
Four days earlier she had stood on a porch and been asked to come inside and look at her daughter’s arms, and had said no. It is worse than a plan would have been.
At a routine review on April 4, nine days after the arrest, somebody said aloud what everyone in the building knew. The assistant district attorney noted on the record that the defendant’s bail had been posted by the mother of the complaining witness and that he was living at the address the child had been removed from. The court noted it. Nothing else happened, because nothing else could. The no-contact order covered the child, who was in Racine, and a woman is entitled to have her husband live in her own house.
Deanna was in the room and heard it. She went home and searched for anything she could do about a mother bailing out the man who had hurt her child. Two websites and a legal aid line told her there was nothing.
Jouri lived in Racine for nine weeks. She enrolled at a school there on a temporary basis and saw a county therapist twice a week, the first time she had ever talked to anyone about anything. She gained six pounds. Her grandmother came every Sunday. Deanna’s 19-year-old daughter, home most weekends, slept in the same room with her, and somewhere around the fifth week Jouri stopped needing the hall light on.
The nine weeks cost Deanna her second job and about $14,000. She worked days in Mount Pleasant and had been waiting tables four evenings a week, and she quit the restaurant in the second week, because a 9-year-old in a temporary placement can’t be left from 5 to 11. That was $600 a month gone. The county paid a foster maintenance rate for relative placements, real money but not enough, and it didn’t begin for five weeks because of paperwork.
She drove to Milwaukee twice a week for court dates and meetings, about 70 miles a day, and took nine unpaid days off. Nobody asked her to do any of it, and she has never called it a sacrifice, because at the end of the nine weeks the child went back anyway.
Chantel had supervised visits, one hour a week at a county facility in Milwaukee with a worker in the room. She made seven of the nine. The visits are documented in the case file, and it is painful reading in both directions. Chantel was not cruel in them. She brought things. She asked about school. She told her daughter she loved her, and meant it.
In four of the seven visits, she also asked Jouri what she had said to the lady with the camera, whether she remembered it right, and whether Auntie Deanna had helped her remember. The worker documented it every time and warned her twice. The second time, she was told another instance would end the visit.
The sixth visit was different. The worker’s notes record that Chantel did not ask about the interview. She brought a bag of the child’s own clothes from the house, folded. She spent most of the hour doing a word search with her daughter. At the end, when the worker called time, she put her hand flat on the back of her daughter’s neck and left it there a few seconds.
It is a note written by a county employee in a room with a camera, and it is the last decent thing anyone recorded about that woman. Nine days later, she filed for divorce and told her caseworker Wayne had moved out. She did not mean a word of it.
The hearing was May 24. The state had to decide whether the conditions that caused the removal had been addressed, and by the checklist, Chantel had done everything. She completed a 12-week parenting course. She attended a domestic violence education program, all six sessions. She had a letter from her employer and a clean home study.
And about three weeks before the hearing, she filed for divorce and told her caseworker Wayne had moved out. The divorce filing was real and is in the Milwaukee County record, dated May 3. The move-out was not. He was living in the house on May 24 and was still living there in June.
Nobody caught it. A caseworker carrying 19 families did an announced home visit on May 16. There were no men’s belongings in the house, because they had been put in a truck for the afternoon.
Deanna told the court she didn’t believe he was gone. She was permitted to say so. It was noted, and it was not evidence.
The court returned both girls to their mother on May 24, under a supervision order with conditions and monthly caseworker contact for six months. Noel had been in foster care for nine weeks. She was 2 and had spent a tenth of her life with strangers. When she was handed back, she did not want to go to Chantel and cried for about 20 minutes in a county office in front of four adults.
The state’s defenders would say that is not a failure of one person. It is what the system does, and it does it for a reason. The standard is reunification. The mother had completed everything asked of her, and no evidence in the courtroom showed the man was still in the house.
Deanna’s legal aid attorney, who had four other child protection files that month, told her plainly where she stood. She was a relative placement, not a party with standing to oppose reunification. She could be heard, and she was, and the court had to consider what she said but did not have to act on it.
Deanna asked what would happen if she refused to hand Jouri over. The attorney said she would lose the placement. The child would go to a non-relative foster home in Milwaukee County that afternoon, and the mother would still get her back within a month.
On Friday, Deanna drove her niece back to 47th Street herself, because Chantel would not let anyone else bring her and because Deanna wanted to see the door. Jouri didn’t want to go. She said so in the car, not loudly, and asked whether she could stay. Deanna told her the judge had decided, that it would be all right, and that she would see her in two weeks.
Deanna has never been able to say that last part aloud without stopping.
The state had one more chance, and it passed in an afternoon. The supervision order called for an unannounced visit within 30 days of the return. The caseworker had 22 families. She had done the announced visit on May 16, before the return, and did not reach an unannounced one until June 15. That was 22 days.
The caseworker was not failing. It was a caseload, and every child protection worker in the country carries something like it. A review afterward said as much and changed nothing, because without money there is nothing to change.
Wayne was back in the house the following week. He had never really left it.
Deanna called the house nine times in those 23 days and reached her niece twice. The first call came the Sunday after the return and lasted about four minutes, with Chantel in the room. Jouri answered questions about school in three and four words. The second was June 9. Chantel was at work and Jouri picked up the house phone herself, and the call ran 19 minutes.
Deanna asked if she was all right, and she said yes. Deanna asked whether Wayne was there. He was downstairs. Was he talking to her? No. Then she said it was better.
What happened in those 23 days is known from Jouri, from Bryce, and from two neighbors, and it is short. Wayne did not touch her. That is established, and it matters because it is the only reason anyone was surprised by what came next.
What he did was stop speaking to her entirely. For three weeks, in a house with four people in it, he did not say a word to a 9-year-old girl, look at her, or acknowledge her in a room. He told Bryce to do the same. Bryce spoke to her anyway and was shouted at for it twice.
Wayne also talked about her, in front of her, to Chantel, about what she had cost him. He cited $14,000 in legal fees that Chantel was paying and a charge that hadn’t gone away because a criminal case doesn’t close when a family court goes your way. A trial date loomed in the autumn. He was facing a felony, he was out on bail because of the woman he lived with, and he spent three weeks making sure the whole house knew what he had lost.
Two neighbors noticed things, and neither did anything, and neither should be blamed. The woman two doors down heard raised voices on a Saturday night and thought it was a marriage. The man across the street saw Wayne loading a truck one Monday afternoon and assumed he was moving out. That was May 16, the day of the announced home visit. He mentioned it to his wife, who said, “Good.”
Chantel spent those three weeks trying to hold it together. On June 15, she stopped.
The caseworker arrived that Wednesday for the unannounced visit the order required, the first since the return. She did not find Wayne. She found a razor and a men’s deodorant in the upstairs bathroom and a pair of work boots by the back door, in a size nobody in the household wore. She asked Chantel directly whether Mr. Stalworth was living at the address. Chantel said no.
The caseworker wrote down what she saw and told Chantel it would be documented. At the door, she said a sentence that was repeated at trial four months later.
“If he is in this house, she does not stay in this house.”
Chantel sat in her front room for about two hours afterward. Then she called her supervisor and took the night off, something she had not done in four years. That evening, she told Wayne to go.
What she did in those two hours, between the caseworker leaving and the call to her employer, has never been established, and there is no one left to ask. She did not call a lawyer or the police. She did not call Deanna, Bernardine, her supervisor, or anyone else, according to her phone records. She called the fulfillment center and took the night off.
It was a Wednesday, and he had been drinking since about 4 in the afternoon.
The children were upstairs by design. At about 7, Chantel sent them up and told Jouri to put a film on in her room, something she had never done on a school night. Bryce, 10, was in the other bedroom with the door shut.
What was said downstairs lasted somewhere between 40 minutes and an hour and was loud enough that the woman two doors down heard it and thought nothing of it, because that house had been loud before. Neither child heard the words. Both heard the shape of it.
At some point after 9, it stopped being an argument. Chantel Rhoden was killed in the front room of the house on 47th Street. The medical examiner’s findings are public record, and this account will not walk through them. What matters is that it was not fast, that she had defensive injuries on both forearms and both hands, and that she fought.
Jouri came out onto the landing. She did not go down. She got to the top of the stairs and could see part of the front room, then went back into her bedroom and shut the door. It is the last thing in this story anyone has asked her about.
She called 911 at 9:10 p.m. from a phone her mother had bought her in January. The call lasts three minutes and 41 seconds. It has been played in a courtroom and never released publicly, and it should not be.
The transcript shows a 9-year-old girl giving her address twice, correctly, with the zip code. It shows her giving her own name and her mother’s and spelling both. When the dispatcher asked who else was in the house, she said her stepfather and a boy named Bryce.
She was asked to stay on the line and did, with the bedroom door shut, for the whole call. At two minutes and 11 seconds, she asked whether her mom was going to be okay. The dispatcher told her people were coming, and she said okay.
One more moment is the part people who have heard the call do not get over. At about the two-and-a-half-minute mark, the dispatcher, who had worked the job six years, asked whether she could get out of the house.
“No.”
“Why not?”
“Because he’s by the door.”
Milwaukee police were on the street within four minutes. Wayne was still in the house. He had not left and had not tried. He was in the kitchen, and he was arrested there without resisting. An officer went upstairs and found a bedroom door with a chair wedged under the handle, and behind it two children. Bryce had come out of his room at some point and gone into hers, and the two had braced the chair together.
It is the only thing in this story anyone did right, and it was done by a 10-year-old and a 9-year-old.
A Milwaukee police detective called Deanna at about 12:40 a.m. She was listed in the child welfare file as a relative placement, her number was in it, and the child had given her name. She drove 35 miles in the middle of the night and reached the District 5 station shortly after 2. Jouri had been in a room there for three hours, with a victim advocate and a blanket. The first thing she said to her aunt was that she was sorry.
Wayne was charged with first-degree intentional homicide. That night at the district, before he had a lawyer, he gave a statement that ran about 40 minutes. He said they had argued about money. He said she came at him. He said he didn’t remember most of it.
He never used the word “accident,” and his attorneys never argued one. At trial four months later they argued adequate provocation, which in Wisconsin can reduce first-degree intentional homicide to second-degree. The theory was that he was provoked by the collapse of his marriage, the loss of his home, the pending charge, and how much he’d drunk. Intoxication is not a defense in Wisconsin and has not been since 2014.
He was offered no plea and asked for none. There was nothing to negotiate. First-degree intentional homicide carries a mandatory life sentence, and the only open question was the year a judge might set for release eligibility. From the first week, the state said it would seek “never.”
The state’s case took six days. Prosecutors called the medical examiner, who testified about the defensive injuries, along with the neighbors and the responding officers. They called the caseworker, who described a razor, a men’s deodorant, a pair of work boots, and a woman at a door saying no. They called Bryce, by video, who was asked what his father had said to Jouri in the three weeks before. He said his dad hadn’t said anything to her, not once, the whole time.
They did not call Jouri. The state decided that early, and Deanna was asked and agreed. The 911 call went in instead and did more than testimony could have.
Wayne testified. His attorneys put him on because they had to. Adequate provocation requires the jury to hear what was in the defendant’s head, and no one else could tell them. He was on the stand most of a day. He said Chantel had been the one who called the police on him, which was not true, and which the state corrected in nine seconds on cross.
He said the girl had lied about all of it, put up to it by an aunt who wanted her. He said he had lost his home, his marriage, and $14,000 of somebody else’s money, and a man can only take so much.
The state’s cross-examination ran about 40 minutes and was mostly about one subject. The prosecutor took him through the 23 days. She established he had not spoken to Jouri once in three weeks and had told his own son not to either. She asked whether he thought that was a reasonable way to treat a 9-year-old in his household.
He said the girl had put him in a cell.
The prosecutor asked how old he was. Forty, he said. She asked how old Jouri was. Nine, he said.
She sat down.
The jury deliberated four hours and 20 minutes and convicted him of first-degree intentional homicide, which carries a mandatory life term in Wisconsin. The judge spoke for about nine minutes before sentencing, and most of it wasn’t about June 15. She said she had presided over homicide cases for 16 years, and what set this one apart was how long the warning had been running and how many people had heard it.
She listed them. A teacher who sent a letter. A school nurse with two lines in a log. A supervisor at a fulfillment center who said something at work. A grandmother who said one sentence on the phone and didn’t repeat it. A woman two doors down who heard raised voices and thought it was a marriage. And an aunt who saw it in four days, reported it, got a child out of that house, and then had to hand her back because a court was required to return her.
She said the system had done what it was built to do and a woman was dead anyway.
The judge set his eligibility for extended supervision at “never,” life without the possibility of release. He was 40. He will die in a Wisconsin institution. The following spring, in a separate two-day trial, he was convicted on the original child abuse counts and given a consecutive term that is legally meaningless. The state pursued it anyway, wanting the conviction on the record for what he did to the child before what he did to her mother.
Deanna read a statement at sentencing that ran about three minutes. She did not talk about Wayne, though she had been told she could. She talked about a woman on a porch in Racine at 10:40 at night who had been asked to come inside and look at her daughter’s arms, had said no, and had gotten back in her car.
She said she had spent every day since June 15 deciding whether to hate that woman. She had not landed anywhere, she said, did not expect to, and the person who would eventually have to answer the question was a 9-year-old girl, not her.
Then she sat down.
Jouri Latimer lives in Racine. Deanna was granted guardianship in September and adopted her the following year, a process that took 14 months and cost more than she had. Bernardine paid for most of it from what was left of her late husband’s pension.
Jouri is 13 now. She doesn’t talk about June 15 and hasn’t since the week it happened. She has seen the same therapist for four years, who has never pushed her on it.
She does talk about her mother, which Deanna was not prepared for and has had to learn to handle, because the Chantel her daughter carries is not the one in the court file. She remembers a woman who worked nights and slept in the day. She remembers being brought things at the county facility for an hour a week. She remembers a hand on her back at a bus stop. She does not remember a porch in Racine, because she wasn’t on it.
Deanna has never told her about the porch. She has decided not to and has told Bernardine she won’t. Bernardine disagrees, and the two have not resolved it.
Chantel is buried at a cemetery on the north side, about four miles from the house on 47th Street. About 60 people attended the funeral. Deanna went, and paid for part of it because nobody else was going to.
Deanna testified at the sentencing hearing and four months earlier at Wayne’s trial, and both times the defense went after the same thing. They put it to her that she wanted that child, that she had a room already made up, that she was the one who took her to a doctor, called the police, and kept her for nine weeks, and that she had made no secret of her opinion of the marriage.
She agreed with all of it.
Then the defense attorney asked whether she had ever wished for something to happen that would let her keep the girl. She said no. He asked if she was sure.
She said she had spent two years keeping her mouth shut so she wouldn’t lose access to that child, and that if she were the kind of person who wished for something to happen, she would have opened her mouth at the wedding.
Noel Stalworth was 2. Her mother was dead and her father was serving life without release, and she had been in that house on June 15, asleep three rooms from it. She went back into foster care that night, to a different placement than the one she’d had for nine weeks, because the first had taken in another child in the meantime.
Deanna asked for her again, properly this time, with a lawyer, in September. She was told what she’d been told in March, that she had no relationship to the child that a court recognizes. Noel was adopted 18 months later by a family in Waukesha County. Deanna has never met them, doesn’t know their names, and has never been given a photograph.
Noel is 8 now. Jouri is 13. They live 40 minutes apart and have not seen each other since March 26, when a 2-year-old went to strangers and a 9-year-old learned of it in a kitchen in Racine.
Bryce Stalworth was 10. He had lived with his father since he was 2, and his mother had been in Georgia for eight years and hadn’t seen him in six. He had no legal relationship to Chantel, who was not his adoptive mother.
He had none to Jouri either, who was not his stepsister in any sense a court recognizes, because the marriage ended the night it ended. He had no relationship at all to Deanna, who had no standing to seek custody of him and couldn’t have afforded it if she had.
He entered state custody on the night of June 15. Nobody in this story ever asked what Bryce had seen. He was interviewed twice, once as a witness to what happened to Jouri and once as a witness to what happened to Chantel. Both interviews were about someone else.
He was in that house for all of it. He sat at that table every night for two years, held up as the better child. He was in a bedroom on June 15 with the door shut. And at some point he got up, crossed the landing, and went into a 9-year-old girl’s room, and the two of them put a chair under the handle.
He had no therapist. No county order provided one, because he was not a victim in either case, and nobody applied. His mother was located in Georgia in August and declined to take him. He passed through three foster placements in the first two years. Deanna wrote to him twice through the county in the first year, got no reply, and has never learned whether the letters reached him. She doesn’t know where he is now.
The last time Jouri saw Bryce was at the top of a staircase on June 15, when the two of them put a chair under the handle of a bedroom door together.