She Was Murdered Hitchhiking in 1974—50 Years Later, a Knit Cap and a Birthday Revealed Her Killer’s Name: WISCONSIN 1974 Cold Case Solved |

She Was Murdered Hitchhiking in 1974—50 Years Later, a Knit Cap and a Birthday Revealed Her Killer’s Name: WISCONSIN 1974 Cold Case Solved |

In 1974, 25-year-old Mary Schlais hitchhiked to an art show and never made it. Her killer left behind an orange knit cap with his DNA—but no match for 50 years.

A hat left in the snow has finally given up its secret. The orange-and-black knit cap, found beside a young woman’s body in rural Wisconsin in 1974, carried hairs that sat unmatched for decades. Genetic genealogy has now tied them to an 84-year-old man.

On the afternoon of Feb. 15, 1974, the day after Valentine’s Day, 25-year-old Mary Schlais left her Uptown Minneapolis apartment holding a handwritten sign with a single word: “Madison.” She was a University of Minnesota graduate student, an artist, a horseback rider and a woman fluent in several languages. She was headed to Chicago for an art exhibition.

She never arrived. Around 1:30 p.m., at a remote crossroads in the town of Springbrook, Dunn County, Wisconsin, about 90 miles from Minneapolis, a neighbor named Denny Anderson drove past and saw a stranger burying a woman’s body in a snowbank. Their eyes met, and the man fled.

Schlais had been stabbed more than a dozen times and bore defensive wounds on her hands. The killer left behind no weapon, but he did leave the knit cap, with hairs inside that did not belong to her. A witness also described the tire tracks of his car.

In a later era, that trail might have led to him within months. In Wisconsin in 1974, it led nowhere. By 2009 the DNA from the cap still matched no one in the national database, and the case went cold.

It would take 50 years to solve. The break required a family that never stopped waiting and a team of college students in New Jersey working in a new branch of forensic science. It also took an arrest that came in the same week as what would have been Schlais’s 76th birthday. By then, the suspect was 84. When investigators knocked on his door, he opened it, looked at them and, by their account, knew exactly why they had come.

Mary Kathleen Schlais was born in November 1948 in Minneapolis, the daughter of Arnold Benjamin Schlais and Louise Catherine Larson Schlais. The family was Midwestern, German American and far from wealthy. They worked, saved and believed above all in education and independence.

She had an older brother, James, born in 1946, and a younger brother, Don. Don would spend most of his life waiting for an answer that never came.

Even as a child, Mary seemed to be looking toward the horizon. She grew to 5-foot-10, taller than most girls in her class. She drew constantly, read widely and picked up languages the way other kids picked up songs, eventually speaking French, German and enough others that a niece would later call her a scholar and “a traveler of the world.”

She attended the University of Minnesota as an honor student and stayed on for graduate school. She was also a serious artist and rider. In the late 1960s, she was even paid to ride horses for someone else.

In 1969 and 1970, she went to England to study art, living in the coastal town of Poole. A classmate from that time, speaking years after the case was solved, remembered a dedicated young woman who was more serious about her studies than most of her friends. She was always drawing and always taking notes.

The same friend said she had introduced Mary to hitchhiking, which was common in England then. But by the friend’s account, Mary rarely did it there and preferred the train. Photographs from the period survive, including one of Mary in Austria, hair pulled back, eyes bright, smiling like someone who already knew the world was far bigger than the Mississippi River.

She came home with a degree and with something else, a belief that a young woman alone with a sign could go wherever she wanted. In 1974, that belief was not unusual. It was widespread.

For anyone raised after cell phones and the internet, it takes some imagination to picture that America. In the early 1970s, hitchhiking was part of the culture. Students thumbed rides home on weekends, discharged soldiers crossed the country that way, and backpackers hopped from coast to coast with guidebooks and songs to keep them company.

That would change within a few years, and cases like Schlais’s were part of the reason. Half a century later, the Dunn County sheriff would put it plainly. In 1974, he said, hitchhiking from Minneapolis to Chicago was normal, but stories like this one are why we no longer let our children do it.

Schlais lived in Uptown, an artistic and lively Minneapolis neighborhood. She had friends in the art world and plans for the weeks ahead. In mid-February she had a specific one, an exhibition in Chicago, roughly 400 road miles away, mostly along Interstate 94.

On Friday, Feb. 15, she wrote her sign. Madison, about five hours from Minneapolis, was the first leg south. She didn’t need to reach Chicago in one ride, only Madison, and she could catch another ride from there.

The morning was bitterly cold, as Minnesota in mid-February tends to be. She wore a fur coat, carried her purse and headed toward the interstate. A young woman at the roadside with a sign was not a frightening sight then. It was, in the words of the original account, an image of freedom.

Investigators do not know exactly when the first car stopped for her. They don’t know whether she got in and out of several vehicles before the last one. What they know, from a confession given 50 years later, is that somewhere in Uptown a compact car pulled over. A white man of about 30 opened the door.

Mary looked in, decided, and got in. Within roughly three hours, she would be dead, her body lying in the snow 90 miles east. A man would try to bury her in a snowbank and drive home believing he had gotten away.

None of that had happened yet. That morning, she was simply a 25-year-old artist and graduate student on her way to an exhibition, and she stepped into a stranger’s car.

At about 1:30 that afternoon, Denny Anderson was driving home through Springbrook, a small community between Eau Claire and Menomonie, about 20 minutes from I-94. The countryside was a white canvas. Harvested cornfields lay under snow, bare oak and birch stood like posts, and the temperature was below zero.

The spot where 48th Avenue meets 990th Street is an unmarked crossroads with no light and no signs, just two country roads meeting in open emptiness. Anderson saw a compact car parked on the shoulder and a man beside it. As he slowed, he realized the man was dragging a woman’s body through the snow and trying to bury her.

For an instant, their eyes met. Anderson kept driving, calm, not stopping or shouting, and called police once he reached safety. Mary Dodge, who lived nearby with her husband, Jack, later told a WCCO reporter how Anderson described that moment. He said the man looked straight at him, and that he would never forget those eyes.

Dunn County deputies arrived in under an hour. They found the body of a tall, brown-haired young woman lying at the roadside under a thin layer of snow. She had no identification, no purse and no fur coat.

A few steps away, on the surface of the snow, lay something that didn’t belong there. It was a hand-knit orange-and-black cap, the kind of cheap 1970s style sold in any store. An investigator bagged it. Inside were a few hairs.

Nobody thought much of the cap that day. It was one more detail at a scene that already had too many. But it went into the evidence locker, and it was logged in the report. Fifty years later, it would be the thing that cracked the case.

The autopsy followed soon after. The victim was a white woman, 25, about 5-foot-10, killed by stabbing. She had suffered more than a dozen wounds, and some later accounts put the number at 15 or more, mostly to the back and chest. Cuts on her hands and forearms showed she had raised her arms to block the blade. She had fought back.

Police identified her within hours. By evening they had her name and had notified her brother Don. Five decades later, he would still recall that day as if it had happened the week before.

Anderson was brought to the station for a description, which became the portrait of the killer that would haunt Dunn County for decades. He described a white man about 6 feet tall, perhaps 30, with long red hair and a heavy mustache. The car was a compact, though Anderson wasn’t sure of the model. Some thought it was a Chevy Vega, and the original description gave its color as orange or yellow. Years later, investigators would say it might have been light blue.

That small discrepancy would never be settled. The following week, a car matching the description turned up at a local repair shop, brought in the day after the killing. Police examined it and interviewed the owner, who was cleared. The Eau Claire Leader-Telegram reported on Feb. 19, 1974, that a car that may have been used in the killing had been found. Nothing came of it.

The 1970s and ’80s passed. Detectives rotated through, and hundreds of tips were processed. None went anywhere.

In 1984, a friend of Mary’s named Nancy Marshki told a reporter something that would be quoted for years. No one doubted that something violent had happened to Mary, she said, but no one knew who did it.

In 1989, Detective Craig Koser took over the case and carried the file for more than a decade. In a 2011 interview, he walked WCCO’s Caroline Lowe to the crossroads. He stood in the snow, pointed to the spot where Mary had lain and said he still didn’t know who had done it.

Police had also found a black-and-white photograph of an unknown man in Mary’s apartment. Don Schlais looked at it and figured it was probably someone who had posed for her drawings. No one could confirm that, and the photo never led anywhere.

In 2009, with the family’s consent, police did something they rarely do and exhumed Mary’s body. The goal was to pull new DNA with techniques that hadn’t existed in 1974. In 2011, the results produced two DNA profiles from the scene that did not belong to her. They were run through CODIS, the federal criminal DNA database. Nothing matched.

In 2018, Dunn County publicly named a suspect, Randall Woodfield. A standout football player drafted by the Green Bay Packers in 1974, Woodfield was later convicted in a string of 1980s attacks along Interstate 5 and became known as the “I-5 Killer.” He is serving a lengthy sentence in Oregon.

In February 1974, Woodfield was known to have been traveling between Portland and Green Bay, a route that passes through this part of Wisconsin. His physical description fit, and so did the profile of the victims in his crimes, young women on the highway. For years, Dunn County believed it finally had its man.

Woodfield was never charged. When his DNA was compared with the two profiles from the scene, it did not match. A theory that had lasted a decade collapsed in a day, and the case went cold again.

The knit cap stayed in the evidence locker. The hairs inside still matched no one. Somewhere in Minnesota, an older man who had married, divorced, raised a child and lived decades outside prison had no idea his cap was still waiting for him.

A cold case isn’t necessarily one nobody is working. For four decades after Mary’s death, a file sat on someone’s desk in Menomonie. It passed through many investigators and many sheriffs, and through different drawers in the same building, but it was never sent to the archive.

Koser drove back to the crossroads more times than he could count. Each time a new lead flickered, he called Don Schlais. When Koser retired, the file moved on to someone else.

In November 2024, Sgt. Jason Stalker stood at a microphone and explained how deep that commitment ran. Anyone who had worked at the agency for any length of time, he said, knew Mary Schlais and her case. It wasn’t a flourish. It described the culture of the Dunn County Sheriff’s Office for 50 years.

But will alone can’t beat a cold case. Technology has to catch up, and it hadn’t, not until 2022.

That fall, on a hill in Mahwah, New Jersey, more than 1,000 miles from Dunn County, a small center opened at Ramapo College. The Investigative Genetic Genealogy Center, or IGG Center, officially launched that December. Its director was David Gurney, a Minnesota native. Karen Binder was associate director.

Neither is a police officer. They are genealogists, lawyers, scientists and teachers who train college students to do work few thought possible a few years earlier.

Investigative genetic genealogy works like this. Police may have a DNA sample from a crime scene that matches no one in criminal databases like CODIS. But the sample still holds genetic information. Compare it with civilian databases, where millions of Americans have voluntarily uploaded their DNA to find relatives, and you can begin building a family tree backward.

You don’t need the killer himself in the database, only a cousin. The Ramapo team was permitted to use two platforms, FamilyTreeDNA and GEDmatch Pro, where users opt in to let their data be used for criminal investigations. Once you find a first or second cousin, you identify shared grandparents, trace their descendants and narrow the field. It is manual work that can take weeks, months or years, and it requires patience and attention to every branch.

In fall 2022, Binder’s team came across the Schlais case online and called the Dunn County Sheriff’s Office. The offer was simple: send us your DNA profile, free of charge. Dunn County agreed. The profile was extracted from hairs that had lain inside the knit cap for 48 years.

In spring 2023, the team uploaded the profile. The closest relative they found was in the range of a first to second cousin, a good start but not enough. And the work was about to get much harder, because the unknown killer had a secret in his family tree. He had been adopted.

That meant the name on his birth certificate, the name his neighbors, his wife and his children knew, was not his genetic name. A paper family tree built from public records does not line up with the one built from DNA. Researchers have to find where the two trees intersect, working out who gave birth to whom and who adopted whom, generations back.

Binder later described it in modest terms. The genealogical research in the case was very complex, she said, and it took more than a year to produce results. That meant a year of manual work, tracing names, writing letters, making calls and comparing dates.

In January 2024, Dunn County investigators flew to Montana to meet a man whose family tree suggested a link to the killer. They obtained a new DNA sample. It didn’t match fully, but it matched partially, confirming the tree was heading the right way. The man was a cousin, and the killer was somewhere on the same branch.

A few months later, a second lead took investigators to Michigan, to another man who turned out to be another cousin. Each time, the tree narrowed, and Binder’s team crossed off branches that didn’t fit.

On Oct. 19, 2024, Binder called Dunn County investigator Dan Westland. They had a name for him to contact. On Nov. 4, Westland and his team located a woman in the Midwest who appears in legal documents only by the initials “TE.” She confirmed that her biological father was named John Keith Miller.

The same day, they spoke with another woman, identified as “RD,” who confirmed she had been married to Miller from 1973 to 1977. Investigators ran the DNA. It matched. John Keith Miller, 84, living in a nursing home apartment in Owatonna, Minnesota, was the man who dropped the orange-and-black cap beside Mary Schlais on Feb. 15, 1974.

The timing carried its own weight. The day Westland had the name in hand fell in the same week as what would have been Mary’s 76th birthday. Had she lived, she might have been blowing out candles in Minneapolis, surrounded by her brothers and her nieces and nephews. Instead, she had lain in the snow 50 years earlier, and on a birthday she never had, the killer’s cap finally spoke his name.

Miller was born in 1940, making him 33 at the time of the killing. He had been married to RD for less than a year, and he already had a criminal record that had escalated over three decades.

In 1959 and 1960, he was convicted of forgery in Minnesota and sent to the state reformatory in St. Cloud. In 1965, he was convicted of robbery in Arizona. In 1967, he was convicted of petty theft in California. In 1969, also in California, he was convicted of armed robbery after threatening a convenience store clerk with a loaded gun, and he went to San Quentin.

He was released on May 5, 1972, 21 months before Mary was killed. The sequence is clear: forgery, robbery, armed robbery. The account of the case lays it out as an escalation, and says that on the day Mary stepped into the compact car, she was getting in with a man who had already climbed every other rung.

Around 5 p.m. on Nov. 7, 2024, Westland and Stalker drove across the Minnesota border and stopped at the Owatonna nursing home, about an hour from Minneapolis. Miller had lived there for a few months. Before that, he had spent more than a decade in an apartment in Austin, Minnesota, about 40 miles away.

He was 84, moved slowly, no longer drove and lived alone. The investigators, in plain clothes, knocked. Miller opened the door and looked at the two strangers in the hallway.

At a press conference days later, Westland described the moment in a single sentence. The instant Miller opened the door, he said, he knew why they were there.

For 50 years, Miller had lived with a secret. He had driven Minnesota roads, paid rent and watched his daughter grow up. He had read the paper every day and occasionally wondered whether anyone was still looking.

Then two men knocked on his door, and he knew.

The investigators stepped inside and sat down with him. At first, according to legal records, Miller denied everything. He said he knew nothing about the name Mary Schlais, nothing about Dunn County and nothing about Feb. 15, 1974.

Westland and Stalker let him talk. Then they laid out the DNA evidence. They didn’t shout or pound the table. They set the facts in front of him, and by the account in the case records, something in him broke. He began to talk.

According to the criminal complaint, Miller said that in February 1974 he had been driving toward Uptown Minneapolis when he saw a young woman hitchhiking with a sign. He stopped, and she got in. They talked briefly. Then, he said, he asked her for sexual contact.

Mary said no. When she leaned forward, Miller told investigators, he reached to the passenger-side sun visor, where he had already hidden a knife. He took it out and stabbed her from behind.

The placement of that knife is the detail that stands out. It wasn’t in a glove compartment, a coat pocket or on the floor. It was above the head of whoever sat in the passenger seat, within a second’s reach and out of the passenger’s sight.

Fifty years later, Miller did not tell investigators it was something he carried for protection or for work. By their account, he said only that the knife had been hidden there ahead of time.

Mary fought back. The defensive wounds on her hands showed she had raised her arms to block the blade. But she was in a moving car with a man who had prepared, and she had no real chance.

Miller told investigators he stabbed her more than a dozen times and kept driving. He left I-94 at the next exit, found a secluded country road and dragged her body from the car. He tried to bury her in the roadside snowbank.

Then another car drove by, and as readers already know, its driver was Denny Anderson. Miller told investigators he panicked, abandoned the effort, ran back to his car and drove off. In his panic, he dropped the orange-and-black cap.

When investigators showed him a photograph of the cap from the Dunn County evidence locker, he acknowledged it was his. He said he must have dropped it that day. He did not remember what he had done with Mary’s purse, her fur coat or the knife. Those items vanished 50 years ago and have never been found.

Westland and Stalker stood and handcuffed him. They walked him to their car and drove him back across the state line, where he was booked into the Steele County Jail to await extradition to Wisconsin.

The next morning, Nov. 8, Sheriff Kevin Bigler announced the arrest at a press conference. He spoke about Mary and about the Ramapo IGG Center. His line about hitchhiking, that it was normal in 1974 but that stories like this are why we no longer let our children do it, spread across the headlines.

Three days later, on Nov. 11, Dunn County held a joint press conference with the IGG Center. Gurney and Binder flew in from New Jersey, and Mary’s family sat in the room. They didn’t speak, but when it ended, they hugged the Ramapo team.

Stalker repeated that anyone who had worked at the agency for any length of time knew Mary Schlais and her case. Westland added what became a motto, that even though the case was very old, it had “never gathered dust” at the agency.

The Schlais case was the first in the Ramapo IGG Center’s history to lead to an arrest. The center had been operating for less than two years, and its first success was one of the oldest cold cases in the country ever solved with the killer still alive.

In the Menomonie jail, Miller became a media subject. KARE 11 reporter Lou Raguse requested an interview, and Miller agreed. The tapes aired on Feb. 13, 2025. Viewers in Minnesota and Wisconsin saw an 84-year-old man in a jail jumpsuit discussing the killing of a young woman 50 years earlier with what many described as chilling indifference.

Asked how often he thought about Mary, Miller answered, “Rarely.” Asked whether he felt anything, he paused, then said, “Maybe I’m cold.” He added that he thought he was cold-blooded.

Asked whether he planned to go to trial, he said, “Why bother?” He said he would plead guilty so her family wouldn’t have to endure one. Describing the moment after he dumped the body, he said a car went by and he thought he had been caught. But the next day, he said, the newspaper described a car that wasn’t his, and he thought he had gotten away.

In that interview, Miller said he had been driving a blue 1972 Gremlin. That conflicts with Anderson’s 1974 description of an orange or yellow car, possibly a Vega. After 50 years, either man, or both, could be misremembering a detail. It can’t be known for certain, and the discrepancy remains unresolved.

Miller also insisted he had never done anything like it before or after. Investigators don’t believe him. The two accounts stand in direct conflict, and the question remains part of an ongoing inquiry.

In February 2025, a Midwest investigative podcast, “The Vault” from Forum Communications, hosted by journalist Trisha Torinskas, was running a series on another cold case, the 1972 murder of 16-year-old Minneapolis girl Jolie Trulesen. Miller was asked about that case too. He denied involvement, but the investigation was not finished.

On March 27, 2025, John Keith Miller walked into the Dunn County Circuit Court for what was described as the last time.

For the Schlais family, 50 years of waiting had ended, and the knit cap that sat in an evidence locker through five decades of dead ends had finally pointed to a name.

Disclaimer: This story is fictional and created for entertainment purposes only. Any names, characters, places, or events are fictitious or used fictitiously. No real person or organization is intended to be portrayed.

Related Articles