The Chilling Case of Bessie Mundy — The Murder Scotland Yard Found in a Newspaper ||

The Chilling Case of Bessie Mundy — The Murder Scotland Yard Found in a Newspaper ||

“Bessie Mundy drowned in her bath in 1912. Ruled an accident. Case closed. But when two fathers in different towns read about a bride drowning the night after her wedding, they both cut out the article and mailed it to Scotland Yard—independently.

Three cases from the long 19th century of the English detective, and each began with a death that looked like something else. A bride found drowned in a rented bath was ruled an accident.

A banker was beaten in a moving railway carriage and thrown onto the tracks. A dismembered body was discovered by chance in a stable, over a stolen pair of trousers.

The first is the one that gives this article its name.

Herne Bay, Kent, 1912

Herne Bay was a small seaside resort on the North Kent coast, a town of a few thousand built around a long pier and a terrace of shops running back from the front.

It was the late Edwardian seaside, all boarding houses and furnished lodgings, with a population that swelled in summer and shrank in winter. Queen Victoria had been dead 11 years and George V was on the throne. It was the last stretch of settled peace before the Great War.

Into this town in the early summer of 1912 came a married couple who took a house at 80 High Street. The husband called himself Henry Williams. The wife was Bessie Mundy.

Beatrice Constance Annie Mundy, 32 years old, was the daughter of a bank manager who had died and left her about £2,500. The money was held in trust, overseen by an uncle, and paid to her as a modest allowance rather than a lump sum.

Her family thought her sheltered and naive about men. Little else of her survives in the record, which gives us her money, her lodgings and the man she married.

She had met him in 1910 in Weymouth, on the Dorset coast, where she was living in lodgings. He described himself as a picture restorer and art dealer. The name was false. He was George Joseph Smith, and he was already married.

They wed on August 26, 1910. Within weeks, “Williams” had taken whatever ready cash he could reach and vanished. He left a letter accusing her of giving him a venereal disease, a ploy meant to justify his desertion and keep her from chasing him. The trust itself stayed out of his reach.

Eighteen months later, in March 1912, the two met again by chance on the seafront at Weston-super-Mare. She forgave him and took him back. They moved to Herne Bay, and she was once more within reach of the money that had drawn him in the first place.

But the trust paid an allowance and not the capital, and a husband who wanted the whole sum needed a way to get it on her death. On July 8, 1912, the couple visited a solicitor and each made a will leaving everything to the other. Five days later, Bessie Mundy was dead.

Smith was born January 11, 1872, in Bethnal Green, in London’s East End. He was sent to a reformatory at Gravesend around age nine, and his youth was one of petty theft and confinement.

As an adult he piled up convictions for theft and swindling and became a practiced bigamist, seducing and marrying women of modest means, taking their savings and disappearing. His aliases included Henry Williams, John Lloyd, George Love and Oliver James.

He had married lawfully only once, under his own name, at Leicester in 1898. His wife, Caroline Beatrice Thornhill, was the woman he had induced to steal from her employers. She eventually turned him in, and she would later testify against him.

His method in the fatal cases never changed. He married a woman with some small property, secured her money or insured her life or got a will in his favor, and then presented her death as a fit or a faint in the bath.

Contemporaries spoke of a dominating effect he had on women, and his own defense counsel is said to have wondered privately whether hypnotism played a part.

That was speculation then and it remains speculation. The record establishes the pattern but not the mechanism of his hold.

The preparations at Herne Bay were reconstructed afterward in detail. Smith went to a local ironmonger and bought a zinc bath, portable and filled by hand, haggling the price down.

He also took Bessie to a young local doctor, Frank French, and told him his wife had suffered a fit. Bessie herself said only that she had a headache. A medical history of seizures was now on file for a woman who had reported none.

On the morning of Saturday, July 13, Smith sent Dr. French an urgent note saying, in effect, that he feared his wife was dead. The doctor hurried to 80 High Street and found Bessie in the zinc bath, her head under the water. The cause of death was drowning.

There was no witness to the death itself. There was a husband who had manufactured a history of fits, a doctor who had been told of them, and a body in a bath in a rented house.

The investigation that followed barely deserves the name. The doctor had been told the woman suffered fits and had examined her only days earlier, so he had no reason to suspect anything but a tragic accident. The death went to a coroner and an inquest, and the ordinary machinery for a sudden death found nothing to detain it.

Smith attended as the bereaved husband. Dr. French described a woman who had drowned in the course of a fit. There was no mark of violence on the body, because the method left none. The jury returned a verdict of misadventure, an accidental death with no one to blame, and no one was committed.

Smith inherited her money under the July 8 will. He returned the zinc bath to the ironmonger without paying for it and left town. The verdict stood as the official account of Bessie Mundy’s death for very nearly three years.

What reopened it was not a reconsideration of the Herne Bay inquest. It was a second death, and then a third. Alice Burnham, 25, died in a bath at Blackpool in December 1913. Margaret Elizabeth Lofty, 38, died in a bath at Highgate, North London, in December 1914.

In each case the man had married the woman, arranged for money to flow to him and presented her death as a sudden collapse in the bath. In each case a local inquest recorded an accident.

The police never connected them. Two private citizens did, each reading a newspaper in a different place.

The Lofty death was reported as the tale of a bride who drowned on the night after her wedding. Charles Burnham, Alice’s father, read the story in the News of the World.

In Blackpool, Joseph Crossley, whose wife had been the landlady where Alice died, read it too. Each recognized his own tragedy in the Highgate report. Each clipped it and sent it to the police, neither knowing of the other.

The clippings reached Scotland Yard and Detective Inspector Arthur Fowler Neil. He established that the men who had married and buried these women under various names were one man, and he put the suspect under watch.

On February 1, 1915, Smith was arrested outside a solicitor’s office, where he had gone to collect insurance money from Margaret Lofty’s death. Four and a half years and three deaths had passed undetected.

The women’s bodies were exhumed, and Sir Bernard Spilsbury conducted the post-mortems. He found no injuries consistent with a struggle and no natural disease capable of causing a fatal fit.

The women had been healthy, and that absence became the evidence. Three healthy women do not drown by accident in shallow baths within their own wedding seasons.

Neil then set out to show how such a drowning could be produced without a mark. He filled a bath and had a volunteer lie in it. Accounts differ on who she was, with some calling her a trained nurse and others an experienced swimmer in a bathing costume.

Neil showed that a sharp pull upward on the feet or knees slid the head under at once, before the person could resist or cry out. The volunteer lost consciousness and had to be revived with artificial respiration, and the experiment was not repeated.

Smith was tried for the murder of Bessie Mundy alone. The other two deaths entered the trial as evidence, not as charges. Proceedings opened at the Old Bailey on June 22, 1915, and ran until July 1.

Mr. Justice Scrutton presided. Archibald Bodkin led the prosecution, and Sir Edward Marshall Hall, the most celebrated defender of his generation, led the defense.

The prosecution built its case on the resemblance of the deaths. It laid out the aliases, the money, the zinc bath and the manufactured history of fits, and it set the Burnham and Lofty deaths beside Bessie’s as proof of a method repeated.

Marshall Hall argued the opposite. In his telling, these were three accidental drownings, the grim luck of a man unlucky in his wives, and the other deaths should never have reached the jury.

The ordinary rule is that a man tried for one offense should not have other alleged offenses put before the jury, lest he be convicted on his character and not the facts.

Scrutton ruled the evidence admissible, not to show bad character but to show system and design, that the Herne Bay death was one of a series too alike to be chance. That ruling on “similar fact” evidence remains a leading authority in English law.

The defense could not hold against the accumulated pattern. Smith was reported to be agitated and to have broken out more than once from the dock.

The jury deliberated about 20 minutes and returned a verdict of guilty. Scrutton passed sentence of death on July 1, 1915, in the first summer of the war, and the trial was followed in the press alongside news from France and Flanders.

An appeal was dismissed and the Home Secretary granted no reprieve. Smith was hanged at Maidstone Prison on Friday, August 13, 1915, by executioner John Ellis. He protested his innocence to the last.

The record of the trial appeared in the Notable British Trials series in 1922. Inspector Neil published his own account in 1932, and a full modern narrative followed in 2010.

The woman at the center of it, who had married in Weymouth a man she believed was a picture dealer, became one of the names by which the whole series is remembered.

The Hackney Railway Murder, London, 1864

The second case begins in London on the night of Saturday, July 9, 1864. London was then the largest city on earth, capital of a mid-Victorian empire at the height of the railway age.

Lines ran out from the termini to the suburbs, and the North London Railway carried passengers in first-class compartments that were enclosed and private.

Those compartments had no corridor and no connection to the ones beside them. Once the train was moving, a passenger had no way to summon help. This was the ordinary condition of first-class travel in 1864, and it was unremarkable until the night it produced this case.

Thomas Briggs was 69, chief clerk at the banking house of Robarts, Curtis and Company in Lombard Street. He lived at Clapton Square in Hackney, a settled, respectable man of regular habits. The record of his life is sparse, and the case is not the story of his life but of its last night.

That evening he dined with relatives in Peckham, south of the river, then crossed the city to begin the trip home. His train left Fenchurch Street at about ten minutes to ten, and he took a first-class compartment. He carried a gold watch on a gold chain and wore a tall silk hat. Those three objects would drive the whole case.

Between Bow and Hackney Wick, a journey of a few minutes, Briggs was attacked. He was beaten about the head and put out of the moving carriage onto the line.

At Hackney, two passengers opened the compartment door and found it empty and bloodied. On the seats and floor lay a walking stick, a bag and a black beaver hat. The hat was not Briggs’s. His own silk hat, his watch and his chain were gone, and the attacker had left his own hat in its place.

Briggs was found on the line, alive but insensible, and carried to a nearby public house. He never regained consciousness and died the following night, July 10.

It was the first murder of a passenger on a British train, and it set off a particular public dread of the enclosed compartment, a sealed box from which no one could call for help. A coroner’s jury returned a verdict of willful murder against a person unknown.

Inspector Richard Tanner of Scotland Yard took up the inquiry, and the hat and the missing watch gave him his lead. The first thread ran to a Cheapside jeweler named John Death, whose name rhymed with “teeth.”

A young man described as German had exchanged a gold chain at his shop for other jewelry, and the chain matched the one taken from Briggs. Death could describe the man, and the shop had handed over a box bearing its name.

The second thread ran from the hat. A cab driver named Jonathan Matthews came forward and said he recognized it. He had bought such a hat for an acquaintance, a young German named Franz Müller, and he could link Müller to the jeweler’s shop. He produced a photograph of him and gave his name.

Müller was already gone. Born October 31, 1840, in Germany, he was a 23-year-old journeyman of limited means who had planned to emigrate to America. He had booked passage to New York aboard a sailing ship, the Victoria.

A sailing ship crossed the Atlantic slowly, and that gave the police their chance. Tanner, Detective Sergeant George Clarke and the two witnesses, Death and Matthews, took a steamer, the City of Manchester.

It left after the Victoria and arrived ahead of it, and the police were waiting at New York when Müller’s ship came in. It was among the first chases of its kind, with steam used to overtake a suspect who had fled by sail.

Müller was arrested on August 24, 1864. He had Briggs’s gold watch and a tall silk hat that had been cut down and altered in shape. Extradition proceedings followed and he was brought back to London.

His trial opened at the Old Bailey in October 1864 and ended within days. He pleaded not guilty. No one had seen the attack, so the case rested entirely on circumstantial evidence.

The prosecution showed the watch and the altered hat found on Müller, the chain exchanged at Death’s shop, and Matthews’ identification of the hat left in the carriage. Together they traced the dead man’s property into the accused’s hands.

The defense pressed the circumstantial nature of it all and tried to establish an alibi for the night of July 9. It also attacked Matthews, whose account had put Müller’s name before the police and who stood, or hoped to stand, to gain from the reward money.

That point was contested at trial and writers have raised it ever since. The case also drew interest from the German community in London and from diplomatic quarters, and petitions were raised on Müller’s behalf.

The jury returned a verdict of guilty and the court passed sentence of death. Appeals for clemency, including appeals from German quarters, were refused.

The case had already sparked a national alarm about the enclosed compartment, and the conviction did not quiet it. The Times and the Illustrated London News covered it extensively from July to November.

Müller was hanged on November 14, 1864, in public outside Newgate Prison by William Calcraft, the hangman of the period. A crowd in the tens of thousands attended, and the size and disorder of the scene fed the growing argument against public executions.

A reported admission is attached to his final moments. The German pastor who attended him on the scaffold afterward said Müller confessed in German, just before he died, that he had done it. That rests solely on the pastor’s account.

It was not evidence given in court, and it is recorded as reported, not proven. Those who accept it see the doubts about Matthews answered, and those who doubt it note that Müller had denied the crime through his trial.

The railways changed. Companies introduced communication cords so a passenger could signal the guard, and cut small openings between compartments so passengers were no longer sealed off from each other.

Those openings were nicknamed “Müller’s lights.” Even the hat left its mark, and a shortened top hat in the style of the one found on Müller was called the “Müller cut-down.”

The trial was published in the Notable British Trials series in 1911, and a full modern study appeared in 2011 under a title drawn from the hat.

The spectacle of the hanging helped bring public executions in Britain to an end in 1868, four years after the crowd gathered at Newgate. The record remains, and so do the doubts.

Roehampton, Surrey, 1842

The third case is the hardest to hear. It begins in the spring of 1842 at Roehampton, on the southwestern edge of London. The district had not yet been swallowed by the city and lay on the semi-rural fringe, among the grounds of gentlemen’s villas in the parklands near Putney, where domestic service was a principal form of work.

It was the early part of Victoria’s reign, and a time of hardship across the country, remembered for economic distress and want among the laboring poor.

The Metropolitan Police had existed only since 1829, was still regarded with suspicion by much of the public, and was a uniformed force aimed at preventing crime.

It had no detectives, no plain-clothes officers at Scotland Yard charged with chasing a wanted man. That absence is part of this story, because this case would be the reason it was filled.

The record of Jane Jones herself is very nearly silent. She lived with Daniel Good as his wife, though whether they were lawfully married is uncertain. Some who knew them took them to be married, and the point cannot now be settled.

Earlier they had lodged near Manchester Square in London. Her age, origins and family are not reliably known, and the documents preserve almost nothing else. The case centers on the man who killed her and the failure of those who sought him.

Good was an Irish-born coachman of middle age, employed in the Roehampton and Putney district. He lived in quarters attached to the stables of Granard Lodge in Putney Park Lane, where he kept his master’s horses and carriage. The record gives the motive as an attachment to a younger woman he meant to marry, and a wish to be rid of Jane.

On April 6, 1842, Good went to a pawnbroker’s shop at Wandsworth and stole a pair of trousers. It was a small theft, but it was noticed, and it brought a constable into the matter. By the chance of a petty crime, the law came to the stables at Granard Lodge for a reason that had nothing to do with a death.

Constable William Gardner followed Good back to the stables to recover the trousers and searched the premises. In one of the stalls, under some hay, he found the body of a woman.

She had been killed and then dismembered, and part of the remains had been burned in the grate of the harness room. The body was Jane Jones.

Good reacted at once. He slammed the stable door, locking the constable inside with what he had found, and fled. A murder had been discovered by accident, in the course of recovering a stolen pair of trousers, and the man responsible escaped in the first minutes.

What followed was a failure, and the failure is why the case is remembered. Good was a named suspect from the moment he ran. His identity and workplace were known. Yet he was not caught.

The Metropolitan Police was divided into separate divisions that did not readily share a description across their boundaries. No central body coordinated a pursuit, and no detective force followed a fugitive from district to district.

Once Good left the neighborhood he passed beyond the reach of the men looking for him, and for about ten days he moved with a freedom a named murderer should not have had.

Meanwhile an inquest was convened, and the jury returned a verdict of willful murder against Daniel Good. The verdict named him but did not produce him. The want of a detective capability was openly blamed, and the newspapers pressed the point.

The Times followed the case through April and into May, and the failed hunt became a public scandal while it was still going on. Broadsides and ballad sheets, the cheap popular print of the day, circulated on it as they did on every notorious crime of the era.

When the capture came, it owed nothing to the machinery that had failed. On April 16, 1842, Good was recognized at Tonbridge, in Kent, by Thomas Rose, a former Metropolitan Police officer who had left the force for laboring work.

Rose knew him by sight, raised the alarm, and Good was taken. A named murder suspect had stayed free on the edges of the capital for ten days, and he was caught through the chance recognition of one man who had once been a policeman.

Good was tried at the Old Bailey in May 1842, charged with the murder of Jane Jones, and pleaded not guilty. The evidence was the body found in the stables of his own place of work, his flight, the locking of Constable Gardner in the stable, and the physical evidence in the stall and the harness-room grate. The jury returned a verdict of guilty.

The finer details of the proceedings, including the names of counsel and the length of deliberation, are not fixed in the popular record, and the surviving Old Bailey material is the place to look for a closer account. The court passed sentence of death.

Good was hanged on May 23, 1842, in public outside Newgate Prison by William Calcraft, before a large crowd, as was still the custom. He died for the murder of the woman who had lived as his wife and whose own record the case had barely preserved.

The failure of the hunt was laid before the commissioners of the Metropolitan Police. In August 1842, they set up a small detective branch at Scotland Yard, with two inspectors and six sergeants, the first detectives London ever had.

Jane Jones is the last of these three cases to enter the historical record, and what remains is the case file, the testimony and the inquest, and nothing more.

Disclaimer: This story is fictional and created for entertainment purposes only. Any names, characters, places, or events are fictitious or used fictitiously. No real person or organization is intended to be portrayed.

Related Articles