My Amish Husband Started Counting the Days After Each Birth, He Got Down to Nine

My Amish Husband Started Counting the Days After Each Birth, He Got Down to Nine

The ninth time he sat on the edge of the bed before I had even stopped bleeding, and he had the paper out already.

I could smell the birth still in the room — iron and tallow, and the sweat gone cold on my own neck — and I could hear our daughter breathing in the cradle Levi’s father had built.

And I watched my husband smooth a scrap of ledger paper against his knee with the flat of his hand the way he smoothed a receipt before he filed it.

He wrote a number.

He did not show it to me.

I asked him what he was counting, because I was young enough still to think a question would be answered honestly.

And he said, without lifting his eyes from the page, “The days.”

I did not understand what he meant by that until the fourth child.

By the ninth I understood it completely, and by then it was already too late for the understanding to change anything.

My name is Rachel.

I served my Old Order district as a midwife for twenty-eight years, from the winter I turned twenty-two until I was past fifty and could not do it anymore, in more ways than one.

In that time, I caught more than a thousand babies with these two hands, and I sat with more mothers than I can number through the hours where faith and medicine pulled two different directions, and only one of them was allowed to win.

This is where I tell you the stories from the bedside that the community never let me speak out loud.

The births that went wrong. The choices made in the name of God that I watched cost women everything. The children I could not save because someone decided before I ever walked in the door that saving them was not entirely up to me.

There is a brown bottle I kept through all of it. I still have it.

And I will tell you what a woman named Anna asked me for on my own front step before we are finished tonight.

Before I go further, let me tell you what no one inside that community was ever allowed to say out loud.

Not even to each other. Not even in the dark.

In that world, a wife’s body belongs first to her husband and then to God — in that order, though no one would ever have said it in that order out loud.

Children are called a blessing. And a blessing is not something a person is permitted to space out or slow down or, God forbid, refuse.

“The Lord opens the womb and the Lord closes it,” the bishop said more than once from the bench at the front of a barn on a Sunday.

And every woman in that room understood she was not the one holding the door.

There is a custom, unwritten, older than any of the men who enforced it, called the resting time — the days a husband is expected to wait after his wife has given birth before he comes to her again.

It is spoken of as tenderness. It is spoken of as the community’s care for a woman’s body.

The maidles and the older wives passing the number quietly to a new bride the week before her wedding. Twenty-eight days. Sometimes thirty. A mercy built into the fabric of the thing.

I believed that too once, the way I believed most of what I was told before I had any cause to test it.

I would learn later, from a woman who had spent her whole career watching numbers instead of believing them, that a resting time only means something if it is the same number every time.

Mine was not.

I did not know that yet.

I was in the room with the smell of iron and tallow still in the air, watching my husband fold a scrap of paper into his coat pocket and press the crease flat with his thumb like he was closing a book.

I want to stop here for a moment, because there is a part of this I have never managed to say to a camera.

I have tried three times to say it plainly and stopped each time before I finished the sentence.

So I wrote it down instead — over two winters at my kitchen table after my daughters were asleep, in the exact detail I spent twenty-eight years not saying to anyone but the page.

Ten chapters. Ten objects I still see clearly when I close my eyes.

The oilcloth I rolled a young mother’s tools in the first year I ever caught a baby.

The telephone, forty rods from a bed I was not permitted to reach in time.

The brown bottle behind the loose board in my own pantry that I have still never fully explained to another living soul until I wrote it down.

Our first child came in March, the year I was twenty-three. A girl, seven pounds, and quiet from the start — the kind of baby who seems already to have decided how loud she intends to be in the world.

Levi counted twenty-eight days that time, the number every bride is given, and he kept it without my having to ask.

He brought in wood without being told. He sat with the baby against his chest some evenings so I could sleep an hour longer than I would have otherwise.

I remember thinking I had married a careful man.

I remember being grateful for that carefulness in a way I did not examine too closely. The way you are grateful for weather without asking why it changed.

The second child came seventeen months later. Another girl.

And that time the number was twenty-four.

I noticed it because I was the kind of woman who noticed numbers — thirteen years as my aunt Salome’s helper before that, learning to read a labor by the clock and not by feeling, learning that four centimeters an hour meant one thing and four centimeters in six hours meant another entirely.

Twenty-four is not twenty-eight.

I told myself it was because he trusted my body more the second time. That a man learns his wife the way he learns a field and comes to know which parts of it recover fastest.

I did not ask him.

Asking him would have meant admitting I was counting too, and I did not want to be a woman who counted her own husband’s patience like it was a debt he owed her.

By the fourth child, the number was nineteen.

And I had a friend by then — a woman two farms over named Miriam, whose husband did not observe a resting time at all, who had six children in eight years, and a body that had stopped healing properly somewhere around the fourth, who bled for weeks after her fifth and told no one, because there was no one inside that world she was permitted to tell.

Miriam and I would sit shelling peas on her porch some afternoons, and she would go quiet in a particular way whenever her husband’s name came up.

A stillness in her hands that I came to recognize the way you recognize a symptom.

I did not understand yet that I was looking at what my own house might become if the number kept moving the direction it was moving.

I thought I was looking at someone else’s misfortune.

I was looking at a forecast.

Miriam’s husband never wrote a number on any paper. He did not need to.

His counting lived somewhere I could not see it, and it showed itself only in the shape of her days.

The way she stood up too fast from the porch step some afternoons and had to hold the rail. The way she stopped mentioning her own tiredness out loud somewhere around her fourth child, because mentioning it had never once changed anything.

I used to think Levi’s paper made him the more honest of the two men — that a written number was somehow more accountable than an unspoken one.

I understand now that a number written down in secret is not honesty.

It is only a man keeping his own books.

“Nine is what Sarah waited between Isaac and Jacob,” Levi said once, after our sixth, when I asked him carefully sideways, the way a woman learns to ask things in that world without it sounding like a question, why the number kept changing.

He said it like scripture settled the matter. The way the bishop said things from the bench — a fact laid down instead of a feeling explained.

I said nothing.

He was not looking at me when he said it.

I did not ask him again for three more children.

Each birth after that made the house a little smaller than the one before it.

Not the house itself. The rooms did not shrink.

But the space inside me that still belonged only to me — the hours in a day I could call my own without someone else’s arithmetic pressing against them — kept getting smaller.

By the seventh child, I had stopped sleeping through a full night, regardless of the resting time, because there was always an infant, always a toddler, always a body needing something from mine before the last body was done needing it.

By the eighth, I had started, without deciding to, keeping my own count in my head each night — unable to stop myself, the number ticking down whether I wanted it to or not. The way a person cannot stop counting stairs in the dark once they have started.

The eighth birth nearly killed me.

I will say that plainly, because a plain thing, said plainly, carries more weight than I could give it any other way.

I bled longer than I should have, and Diane — the English nurse who ran the little clinic at the edge of the county, sixty years old, her reading glasses always pushed up into her gray hair and forgotten there — was the one who came.

Because by then I had learned, from years of catching other women’s babies, exactly how much time a body has before longer becomes too long.

I sent for her myself, against what I had been taught.

And she came in her own car with her own bag, and she put her hand flat on my stomach, and she did not say a word for a long moment.

Then she looked at Levi, still standing in the doorway with his coat on, and she said, “She needs six weeks. Not less.”

He nodded at her the way he nodded at the bishop.

He wrote it down on the scrap of paper he kept folded in his coat pocket.

Six weeks became five and a half by the time the ninth child was three months old inside me.

The number already sliding the direction it always slid. Gravity finding its own level again once Diane’s car was gone from the lane.

The ninth time he sat on the edge of the bed before I had even stopped bleeding, and I have already told you what he wrote.

I asked him what he was counting.

He said, “The days.”

Without lifting his eyes from the page.

And something in the flatness of it — the way he said it like an answer that closed a subject rather than opened one — made me look at the paper itself for the first time instead of just at him.

It was not a fresh page.

It was the same scrap he had carried for years, folded and refolded until the creases had gone soft as cloth.

And down one side of it, in his own small, cramped hand, was a column of numbers, each one smaller than the one before it.

Twenty-eight. Twenty-four. Twenty-one. Nineteen. Seventeen. Fifteen. Thirteen. Eleven. Nine.

I did not understand in that first moment what I was looking at.

I understood a moment later, watching him fold it away into his coat pocket with the same care he used for a receipt he meant to keep, that I was looking at a countdown.

And that I had been inside it the entire time, without ever once being told what number it was counting toward, or why.

I asked him — plainly, for the first time in nine children — what the number was for, and why it kept getting smaller instead of staying the same the way every other woman I had ever midwifed had told me it stayed.

He did not answer me right away.

He looked at the cradle instead, at our ninth daughter sleeping in it.

And then he said the thing I have carried since. The thing I have never been able to say to a camera without stopping myself first.

He said, “Ten is a full quiver, Rachel. A man is not asked to wait on a full quiver the way he waits on an empty one.”

I lay still.

I said nothing.

I lay still.

He was not counting my body’s recovery at all.

He had never been counting that.

He was counting toward a number the bishop had put in his head before we were ever married — ten children being the mark of a household fully blessed.

And every year that number felt further away than he wanted it to be.

He had simply taken days off the waiting instead of taking anything off the wanting.

I did not say any of what I understood in that moment.

I have never been a woman who says the largest thing the instant she finds it.

I set it down somewhere inside myself instead, the way I had learned to set down a diagnosis at a bedside I could not yet act on.

And I kept moving through the evening as though nothing in the room had changed.

I nursed our ninth daughter. I made supper.

I lay beside my husband that night with his folded paper and arms length away in his coat pocket on the chair.

And I did not sleep.

And somewhere past midnight I understood the fuller shape of it.

That every kindness I had thanked him for over nine children — every extra hour of sleep, every evening he took a baby off my hands — had been purchased out of the same ledger as the number itself.

He was not a cruel man managing a cruel arithmetic.

He was, I think, an ordinary man who had been handed a number before he ever met me, and had simply never once stopped to ask whether it was his to chase at my expense.

There is a woman named Anna I met the same year.

Seven children of her own already at her skirts when she came to my step in the middle of the day, which was never the hour women came to me.

Because the night knock and the daytime knock meant two entirely different things in that world, and every woman understood the difference without being told.

Anna did not look at my face when she asked me what she asked me.

She looked at the basket by my door, the way you look at something safer than a person’s eyes.

I understood what she wanted before she finished the sentence, because I had understood the same thing myself, lying awake beside my own husband’s soft breathing, doing arithmetic I had been taught my whole life was not mine to do.

I gave her what she asked for.

I want to tell you exactly what that was and exactly what it cost me to decide it.

And I have never once managed to say the rest of that out loud. Not the whole of it. Not here.

So let me say this instead, plainly, the way I have learned to say the hardest things.

What I did in the end was not dramatic, and I will not make it sound that way now, because it was not that at the time, and pretending otherwise would be its own kind of lie.

After our ninth daughter turned four months old, and Levi’s count had already begun creeping toward whatever number came after nine, I went to Diane’s clinic on a Tuesday without telling him where I was going.

And I asked her a question I had never once been permitted to ask a soul in twenty-six years.

I asked her if there was a word in the English world for a man deciding how many children his wife would carry and when, without her body’s needs entering into the arithmetic at all.

She took her glasses down out of her hair and looked at me for a long moment before she answered.

She gave me the word slowly, over the better part of a year, one piece at a time. The way you hand a burn victim water instead of a full glass.

Reproductive coercion, she finally called it, sitting across from me with her glasses pushed up into her gray hair, forgotten there the way they always were.

Not a resting time. Not a mercy.

A man’s hand on the calendar the whole time, calling it patience.

I sat with that word for a long time before I could use it myself.

I think of my husband’s small, cramped column of numbers differently now.

Twenty-eight. Twenty-four. Twenty-one. All the way down to nine.

Not as a record of his consideration, but as a record of exactly how much of my body’s own timing he had decided, quietly, year after year, was his to set instead of mine.

The consequences arrived the way most consequences did in that world — quietly, in the order things are taken from a person rather than all at once.

My husband moved his bed to the daudy house within the month, without a word of argument from either of us. As though we had both been waiting years for permission to stop pretending the arrangement was working.

My own daughters, three of them old enough by then to understand what their mother had done, were instructed not to take food from my hand at the shared table.

A small thing. A plate passed around instead of across. That somehow undid me more completely than anything Levi himself ever said.

My oldest friend, a woman I had known since we were girls together at the same one-room schoolhouse, turned her buggy the other direction in the lane the next time she saw me coming.

And she was weeping while she did it, which I have never been able to decide made it better or very much worse.

I will say this plainly, too, because it is true, and because leaving it out would make the story smaller than it actually was.

There was real love in that house for years, alongside everything else I have told you.

Levi was not a monster.

He was a man doing arithmetic he had been handed before he ever met me, certain the whole time that he was keeping a promise instead of breaking one.

I sat in Diane’s office two years after I left, in a chair by a window with a maple tree in it and a few cars going by underneath.

And a young woman, not much older than my own daughters, asked me a question no one had asked me in twenty-eight years.

She did not ask what happened.

She asked what I had wanted in any of it for myself.

I wept in that chair the way I had not wept at any of the nine births themselves.

And the way I wept told me something about how deep the training had actually gone — deeper than I had let myself believe.

If you grew up in a place where love and control wore the same coat, and you were taught you could not tell the difference from the outside, I see you.

If you have ever done the arithmetic in your own head at night, counting down toward a number someone else set without ever telling you why, I see you.

If you have ever been handed a decision dressed up as a mercy, and spent years thanking someone for a kindness that was never actually a kindness at all, I see you.

And you are not the only one who has carried that particular confusion.

I do not hate the community that raised me, even now.

Even having told you all of this, it gave me my daughters, and it gave me twenty-eight years at hundreds of bedsides where I was, for all its faults, trusted with something sacred.

I carry that alongside everything else, because both are true at once, and I have stopped needing them not to be.

The ninth time he sat on the edge of the bed before I had even stopped bleeding, and he had the paper out already.

I can still see the column of numbers.

I can still see the way he folded it away.

And I can still see, when I close my eyes, the nine daughters who came out of that countdown, each one of them a whole world I would not trade, and each one of them a reason I finally learned to count something of my own.

Disclaimer: This story is fictional and created for entertainment purposes only. Any names, characters, places, or events are fictitious or used fictitiously. No real person or organization is intended to be portrayed.

Related Articles