What Amish Mothers Hide Before Labor, I Spent 28 Years Pretending Not to Notice

The dish towel was knotted at the four corners, and it had been pushed so far behind the flower bin that only a white edge showed.
I knew what it was before I touched it.
In the spring of my twenty-fifth year as district midwife, I stood in the Glick kitchen with the cornmeal scoop in one hand and a cloth tape in my apron pocket, and I looked at that white edge, and I did the thing I had done 342 times before.
I looked at the wall.
Esther Glick stood at the sink with her back to me, and her hands went on washing a cup that was already clean.
She was thirty years old and thirty-two weeks along, and her ankles had disappeared into her stockings.
The clock on the shelf ticked. Somewhere in the yard, a child was singing the same four notes over and over.
I am going to tell you what a mother hides before her labor, and why I spent twenty-eight years pretending I could not see it.
My name is Rachel, and this is Rachel the Amish Midwife.
If you want to keep hearing the stories I was never allowed to tell, do me one kindness and subscribe and ring the bell so the next one finds you.
For twenty-eight years, I was the district midwife in an Old Order settlement in Pennsylvania, and I caught more than a thousand children.
I finished the eighth grade and not a day more.
And everything else I know, I learned at the bedside—from my aunt Saloma, and from the women in the beds.
This channel holds the stories from that bedside that the community never let me speak: the births that went wrong, the faith that was chosen over medicine, and the mothers who were not asked what they wanted.
Tonight is about the things a woman hides, and the woman who let her.
Before I go on, I want to be clear that I am not about to tell you a story about a cruel people.
I am going to tell you a story about a very kind one.
That is what makes it so hard to describe.
There is a pair of reading glasses pushed up into gray hair and forgotten that I still see whenever I close my eyes.
I still see them.
And before we are finished tonight, I will tell you the sentence Diane interrupted me with, and why I could not finish what I was saying.
In this world, a woman who is expecting is a woman who is watched.
She is watched by her husband, and by his mother, and by the women’s bench, and by the midwife, and by the church—which watches everything the way a hen watches a yard.
And a woman who is being watched learns one thing before she learns anything else.
She learns what to keep behind the flower bin.
She hides the small things first. A headache. A flicker of light at the edge of the eye. A swelling in the fingers that makes the wedding ring hard to turn.
She hides them not because she is ashamed of them, but because she has seen what happens to a woman whose body becomes the family’s business.
A body that has a problem is a body that must be decided about.
The husband will decide, or his father, or the minister.
And the deciding will cost money the family does not have, and take the woman away from a house that cannot spare her, and put her in a place she has never been among people who do not speak her language.
So she says it is nothing. She says it in the same voice she uses for rain.
She learns to sit down slowly so that nobody sees her sitting down slowly.
A spot of blood on a flannel is washed in cold water at night in the dark and hung where the wind will take it before morning.
And then she hides the large thing, which is a bundle.
A dish towel with the corners tied. A nightgown that is not her good one. A comb. Two diapers folded small. And a tin with whatever money she has been able to put by without anyone knowing.
She keeps it behind the flower bin, or under the mattress, or in the hayloft, and she never speaks of it, and it waits there through every month of her pregnancy for a day she hopes will never come.
I want to stop here for a moment, because there is a part of this I have never managed to say on camera.
I have tried three times. I began to tell it to this lens, and three times I found myself looking at the wall instead of at you.
So I wrote it instead—by hand, at a kitchen table, over three winters, in the exact detail I spent twenty-eight years not saying.
Ten chapters. Ten objects I still see when I close my eyes. The oilcloth, the record book, the brown bottle.
And the midwife, of course, notices.
That is the whole of her trade.
Saloma taught me on my first day, at fourteen, in a kitchen that smelled of vinegar and wet wool, with her two fingers pressed against my sternum so that I would remember.
She said, “A good midwife has eyes and no mouth.”
I did not understand what she meant. I thought it meant discretion.
I did not understand that it was a job description.
It was not cruelty. It was arrangement.
It was the absolute conviction that a woman’s hidden life and a midwife’s silent knowing were two halves of a single agreement, and that the agreement was what kept the peace.
Not because anyone was lying, not because anyone was afraid of the truth—because the thing said aloud in that world became a thing that had to be decided, and a thing that was merely noticed could be left alone.
The cost was two women in a kitchen, each of them knowing exactly what the other knew, and each pretending with all her strength that she did not.
In the spring of my third year as district midwife, I went to the Yoder farm to weigh out cornmeal for a mother of five, and when I reached behind the flower bin for the scoop, my hand found cloth.
It was a dish towel knotted at the corners.
I felt the weight of it before I understood.
Inside there was a nightgown, a comb, two diapers, and a tin of bag balm with $212 folded in it.
The mother, Ruth Yoder, was at the sink with her back to me. She did not turn around.
I put the tin back. I put the scoop down. I looked at the wall.
“The cornmeal is good,” I said.
“Yes,” she said.
That was the first time I did it.
What frightened me afterward was how easy it was.
It took no courage to do, and it took no courage to leave undone. I simply looked at a wall, and the wall looked back, and we all got through the afternoon.
I had my own bundle.
I should tell you that it had sat behind my own flower bin since the spring I was pregnant with my first daughter—a dish towel with a blue nightgown in it, and $18 in a lard pail that I had saved from selling eggs.
Saloma found it in the second month.
I watched her hand touch the towel. She stood very still for the length of a breath, and I saw her decide.
She said, “The lamp wants trimming.”
Then she trimmed the lamp.
It was the kindest thing she ever did for me, and it was the beginning of everything.
I carried that bundle behind my flower bin for nineteen years. I never took it down, and I never moved it, and I never told my husband that it was there.
Now I will take you back to the Glick kitchen.
It was the spring of my twenty-fifth year, and I had come to measure Esther’s belly with the cloth tape I had carried in my apron pocket since I was sixteen.
A yellow tape gone soft as flannel, with the numbers rubbed almost off the first ten inches by my thumb.
It was her seventh child.
She was a tall, quiet woman with an oval face and a habit of tucking a strand of hair behind her ear that always slipped out again.
I laid her on the settee and drew the tape from the top of her belly to the bone.
I said the number to myself. It was larger than it should have been.
I pressed my thumb into her shin. It went in and stayed—a dent like a thumbprint in dough—and did not fill.
Esther pulled her skirt down over her ankles.
“It is nothing,” she said.
“The baby is a good size,” I said.
We both looked at the wall.
I have thought since that it was the most intimate thing two people can do together—to look at the same wall so hard for the same reason, and not say why.
I saw the towel behind the flower bin that day, and the blue corner of a nightgown showing.
I saw it, and I did not see it.
Then I picked up my bag and went home.
At thirty-four weeks, I saw her sitting in the dark pantry in the middle of the afternoon with a cold cloth over her eyes.
“Good afternoon,” I said.
She lifted one corner of the cloth. “The summer light was too strong.”
It was April, and the day was gray.
“I understand,” I said.
I did not understand. I understood exactly.
I had seen the same thing once before, on a kitchen floor in another district in the fifth year of my work, and I had never in twenty years forgotten the sound the linoleum made under her heels.
I did not sleep that night.
I lay on my back in the dark with my husband breathing beside me and the tape lying on the dresser like a small yellow snake.
I noticed, and then I did not.
I said it over and over in my head, the way you say a prayer you no longer believe.
I noticed, and then I did not.
I went back on the Tuesday.
She was in the kitchen, and her face had gone as round as a plate, and there was a sheen on her skin like candle wax.
Her mother-in-law, Rosanna, was at the stove, and her husband, Mose, sat at the table with his hat beside his plate.
Nobody looked at me.
It was the quiet of a room that has agreed not to see.
The kitchen smelled of scalded milk and the yellow soap Rosanna used on the floor. A fly walked the rim of the sugar bowl.
I remember that I watched it for a long time before I could make my hand move.
I took the tape out of my pocket and laid it on the table, and I stood beside it, and I said:
“Esther, I have seen your ankles for four weeks.”
The clock ticked.
“I have seen you sit in the pantry with a cloth on your eyes.”
Nobody moved. Mose’s hand had stopped halfway to his hat.
“I have seen the towel behind the flower bin. I noticed. I did not say. I am saying.”
There was a long time in which the room was completely still.
Then Mose said, in a voice like a boy’s, “What towel?”
Esther put her face in her hands.
“The one you were never supposed to see,” she said through them.
And she began to laugh. And then she was not laughing.
Rosanna set down her spoon. She wiped her hands on her apron, one at a time, slowly, and she walked out of the kitchen and down the hall to her own room.
We heard a drawer.
She came back with a dish towel knotted at the corners, gone yellow and soft as old skin, and she put it in Esther’s lap.
“I have kept it for thirty-one years,” she said. “I never took it down.”
Nobody asked her for what day.
She looked at her son, and there was a great deal in it, and none of it was anger.
Later in the hall, while the driver’s lights swung across the yard, Rosanna told me about it in a low voice with her eyes on the floor.
She had packed her bundle in the spring of her second pregnancy, after a woman she knew had died at home with the child still inside her, and she had told herself it was for one year, until she felt safe.
Then the year passed, and she was still afraid, and the year kept passing.
“It was for the year I was afraid,” she said. “I am still afraid, Rachel.”
There was a driver in the next district who would come at first light for $40.
I sent Mose to the neighbors with the errand.
The baby came that same week, at thirty-six weeks and two days, by an operation—a boy, small and pink and furious.
Esther woke on the second day with a tube in her arm and asked for a glass of water.
She lived. He lived.
Mose stood in the hospital corridor for nine hours with his hat in his hands beside an English cleaner’s mop bucket and never sat down. I do not think he knew the chairs were for him.
The bill was $9,412, and I will come to that.
I did not stop looking at walls after that day. That is not how it works.
But I stopped doing it in front of a woman who was looking at me.
From that spring on, I noticed out loud.
It was a small change, and I made it in the smallest possible way.
At every visit, I laid the tape on the table where anyone could see it, and I said the number aloud, and I said what the number meant, and when I saw a thing that worried me, I said that it worried me.
I did not tell anyone what to do. I only stopped pretending that I did not know.
It cost what such things cost.
Two husbands began to meet me at the gate instead of the door. A mother-in-law told the women’s bench that I frightened people by counting.
The women stopped hiding things from me, which meant that they began to tell me everything, and I found that I was carrying more than I had ever carried.
When I looked at the wall, it turned out that the wall had been holding the weight.
I will not tell you that I was brave.
I had noticed for twenty-five years, and I had used it for nothing. I had read every sign on the road and refused every turn.
I told myself that noticing was the gift. It was only half of it, and the other half was a mouth.
If you want to keep hearing what the midwife was never allowed to say out loud, subscribe.
I will not tell you the district was only its silence.
Within two days of Esther’s operation, word had gone from farm to farm, and forty-one families put money into a hat at the Sunday meeting.
It came to $9,412 to the dollar.
Nobody spoke of it.
The bishop’s wife handed the envelope to Mose after the closing hymn, and Mose put it in his coat without looking at it.
It was the finest thing I ever saw that church do, and I have never in my life seen a more perfect kindness leave a more perfect silence behind.
I have counted the bundles since.
I have gone through them in my head, one at a time—behind flower bins and under mattresses, and in the hayloft over the cows—and there were 342 that I noticed.
I do not know how many were ever picked up.
I do not know how many of those women lay awake in the last week with a hand on a belly and a dish towel in the dark, listening to a midwife who could see them and would not say.
I told you at the start there was a pair of reading glasses pushed up into gray hair and forgotten.
The sentence Diane interrupted me with, and why I could not finish what I was saying, is chapter eight.
Diane the English nurse and I have never said it out loud to anyone.
It was the second spring after I left.
I had been going to Diane’s clinic for months by then, ostensibly for a cough that had long since cleared.
She kept a glass bowl of butterscotch candies on her desk and a pair of reading glasses pushed up into her gray hair, where she had forgotten them for years.
The first time I tried to tell her about the women, she interrupted me before I could finish, and I have never finished that sentence since.
This time she let me talk.
I told her about Esther, and the towel, and the 342. I told her about the wall.
When I stopped, she took off her glasses—which she found in her hair with a small, surprised noise—and folded them in her hand.
“There’s a name for what that does to a nurse,” she said. “It’s called moral injury. It’s what happens when you’re made to watch harm you could stop inside a system you belong to, and you go along with it. It’s not weakness. It’s a wound in the part of you that knows the difference.”
I had believed for most of my life that I was a coward.
She said I was wounded, and that it was not the same thing.
She said it in the same easy voice in which she said that the butterscotch was for anyone who wanted some.
Then she pushed her glasses back up into her hair, where they had been all along, and said that was enough for one spring.
I did not understand until much later that she was rationing me. She knew how much a person could carry out of a room at once.
I sat with her words in my lap in the warm, dusty light of that little office, with the radiator knocking and a car going by outside on the wet road.
I thought about a hand on a dish towel, and Saloma trimming a lamp, and a cornmeal scoop put down very carefully on a shelf.
I thought that I had spent twenty-eight years bleeding quietly from a place I did not know I had.
I had always thought a wound needed to show. Mine had been hidden the way the women hid theirs—behind a habit and a flower bin, in a place where a good midwife’s eyes could not reach because she had trained them to look elsewhere.
I have never said aloud that I was relieved when the women did not tell me.
It was so much easier not to know. That is the sentence I carried longest, and it is the true one.
Before that afternoon, when I saw a flower bin, I saw a place to look away from.
After it, I saw a woman’s whole hidden life folded up small in a dish towel, and I understood that what she had hidden was not the bundle. It was the fear behind it.
And I had been standing in front of that fear for a quarter of a century, holding a scoop.
If you have ever packed a bag and put it behind the flower bin for a day you hoped would never come, I want you to hear me now.
I see you.
I see you standing at the sink with your hands in the water, telling everyone it is nothing while your ankles disappear into your stockings.
I see you sitting in a dark pantry with a cold cloth on your eyes, saying that the light is too strong.
I see you who noticed something in someone you love and did not say it, because saying it would have meant deciding something.
You were not silent because you did not care. You were silent because someone had taught you that silence was the same as care.
If you are holding something you have noticed, say it aloud. It does not need to be brave. It only needs to be audible.
I have found that most of the time, the room has been waiting for someone to go first.
And if you are the one with a bundle behind your own flower bin right now, I have something to say to you as well.
It is not a betrayal. It is not disloyalty, and it is not a lack of faith.
It is a plan. You are allowed to have a plan for the worst day of your life.
And you are allowed to be the only one who knows it. And you are allowed, when you are ready, to take it down.
I do not hate the place that made me.
It gave me forty-one families with money in a hat.
It gave me Rosanna with her thirty-one years of yellow towel.
It gave me Saloma, whose two fingers I can still feel against my sternum, and who trimmed a lamp for me on the worst afternoon of my young life.
It gave me a woman in her sixties who walked down a hall in her own house and came back with thirty-one years in her hands, and who did not ask anyone’s leave.
I carry all of that. I carry the tape, too.
It is in a drawer in my kitchen, and the numbers are gone from the first ten inches.
When a young woman comes to my table, I do not measure her.
I only tell her aloud every number I know, and I watch her face while I do it, and I never once look at the wall.
Where are you watching from tonight? Tell me in the comments. I read every single one.
You were never wrong to be afraid, and you were never wrong to be seen.