Amish Husbands Meet Alone the Week After Their Wedding, I Learned What Was Decided Years Later.

Amish Husbands Meet Alone the Week After Their Wedding, I Learned What Was Decided Years Later.

image

The week after my wedding, my husband left before breakfast and did not say where he was going.

He was dressed in his good shirt, the one he had worn to the ceremony seven days before.

His hat was on before I had finished lighting the stove, and he was out the door without a word, and the horses were not taken, which meant he was walking, which meant wherever he was going was close enough to reach on foot through the November mud.

I stood at the window and watched him disappear down the lane between the bare trees.

I was 19 years old.

I had been a wife for exactly 7 days.

I did not ask where he was going.

That is the part I want you to hold on to.

Not that he left, that I did not ask because I had been taught every single day of my life before that morning that a wife does not question where her husband goes.

That asking was a form of hochmut, pride, that a good wife trusts and waits and tends to what is directly in front of her and does not reach past what has been given to her to manage.

So I turned back to the stove.

I made the oatmeal.

I sliced the bread.

I fed the chickens.

I moved through that gray November morning the way I had been trained to move through everything.

Quietly, usefully, without complaint, without question.

He came home 2 hours later.

He smelled of wood smoke and coffee and cold morning air.

His boots left mud tracks across the floor I had just swept.

He sat down and ate.

He did not explain where he had been.

He did not explain who he had been with.

He ate with the quiet efficiency of a man who had done what he went to do and had come home to the next thing on the list.

And I did not ask.

I did not ask that morning.

I did not ask the next week or the month after or the year after that.

I did not ask for 11 years because by the time one week had passed without my asking, the question had already been buried.

It had already become one of the things a woman like me simply did not say out loud.

And the not-saying had already become invisible to me.

The way all the most important silences become invisible when you have been practicing them long enough.

Stay with me because what I am going to tell you about what happens in Amish communities in the days after a wedding is going to make you understand something about power that most people never get to see clearly.

It is going to make you angry.

It is going to make you sad.

And if you grew up in a world anything like mine, it is going to make you recognize something you have been carrying without a name for a very long time.

My name is Martha.

I grew up Old Order Amish in Geauga County, Ohio.

I left some years ago, and this channel, Hannah the Amish Girl, is where I finally say the things my community would never have allowed me to say out loud.

Now, let me explain something it took me years and one ordinary Wednesday afternoon to understand.

In the community I grew up in, marriage was not only a covenant between two people.

It was an entry into a system.

And that system had rules that were never written down anywhere, never spoken aloud at the ceremony, never explained to a new bride before or after she stood before the bishop and said what she was asked to say.

The rules existed the way so many rules existed in my world, not through announcement, but through structure.

Through what happened and what did not happen, through who was in the room and who was not allowed to be.

Through what was considered worth discussing and what was considered already settled.

Let me explain how Amish marriage authority actually worked.

Not the version the theology offers, the real one.

The first thing to understand is that in Old Order communities, the bishop holds authority over every dimension of community life, not only the spiritual.

He settles disputes between families.

He determines whether a household’s behavior has violated the Ordnung.

He speaks into marriages when those marriages are brought before him.

His judgment in our district was treated as close to God’s will as any human decision could come.

The second thing to understand is that the men of the community operated inside a formal structure of accountability to other men, to the bishop, to the deacon, to the elder men of the church district.

A young husband was not simply left to lead his household however he chose.

He was expected to lead it correctly, and correctly was a word whose definition had been established long before he arrived by the men above him from whom all such definitions descended.

The third thing to understand is that a wife had no equivalent structure.

She was accountable to her husband.

Her husband was accountable to the bishop.

The bishop was accountable to God.

There was no one whose formal role was to receive what a wife experienced inside her own home, no channel, no office, no woman in a position of authority to hear what another woman might have said had she been given the belief that what she said would matter to anyone with the power to act on it.

Those are the structures as they were.

Now let me tell you what they produced in our community.

It was understood, not spoken openly, but understood the way all important things are understood in closed communities, through custom, through silence, through the absence of any alternative ever being offered or considered, that in the week following a wedding, the older men would gather with the new husband.

It was not announced as a meeting.

It was not put on a calendar.

It was not discussed in front of women.

But it happened.

The husband’s father, the bishop, sometimes the deacon, sometimes one or two elder men of the district who had known the family for decades and understood the particular shape of that family’s life.

They gathered in someone’s barn or kitchen in the early morning hours, and they talked, and what was said in that room became the architecture inside which the new marriage would operate, the scope of the husband’s authority, what would be expected of the wife, what he was permitted to require of her, the edges of things clearly drawn before he came home and sat down at the table and expected his breakfast.

I did not know this when Jonas left before breakfast on that gray November morning.

I did not know it for 11 years.

The woman who told me was named Ruth Shrock, 63 years old, married for 41 of them, to a man named Eli, who repaired farm equipment and spoke slowly and never once, in all the times I was in a room with him, said anything unnecessary.

We were at a quilting at Ruth’s home on a Wednesday afternoon in April, the spring of my 12th year of marriage.

Her youngest daughter had just announced her engagement to a young man from a neighboring district, and the women around the table were offering the particular combination of warmth and practical advice that Amish women offer at moments like that.

Ruth was cutting dark blue cloth into squares, steady and efficient, the way she did everything.

And she said it the way you say something you assume everyone already knows.

She said, “The men will meet with him after the wedding, of course, to set things in order.”

I looked up from my stitching.

She did not look up from hers.

I said, “What things?”

She said, “The household, how it will be run, what is expected of the wife, what the husband is permitted to require. The bishop will speak to him. The older men will speak to him. It has always been done this way.”

She said it the way you give directions to a road you have traveled a thousand times.

Turn here.

Always been this way.

Nothing more to say.

I set down my needle.

I thought about Jonas leaving before breakfast 7 days after we were married.

His good shirt, his hat, the November mud on foot so close by.

I thought about 11 years of mornings I had never asked about.

Ruth was not a cruel woman.

She was not trying to wound me with what she said.

She was a woman who had lived so long inside the structure that the structure had become invisible to her.

The way the walls of your own house become invisible when you have been inside them long enough.

She mentioned the meeting because her daughter was getting married and this was practical information, the kind that gets passed from woman to woman in the small sideways moments that are the only channel such information has ever moved through in communities like ours.

That afternoon I drove home with my hands very still on the reins and a cold feeling in my chest that I did not yet have a name for.

The feeling I drove home with that Wednesday was not surprise.

Surprise would have been cleaner.

What it was was recognition.

The kind that comes not like new information, but like the correct name for something you have been holding in your hands for years without knowing what you were holding.

Because here is what I had believed for 11 years of marriage.

I had believed that Jonas left before breakfast that November morning because he was a private man, reserved, self-contained.

That was simply his character, and his character was not mine to question or to judge.

I had arranged my entire understanding of my own marriage around a story that placed everything on his individual nature and removed the institution completely from the equation.

What Ruth told me on that April afternoon was this.

It was not his individual nature.

It was a procedure, a formal one, with participants and an order and a set of outcomes that had been determined before he ever came back through my door.

What was said in that room on that November morning, I do not know completely.

I was not there.

I was never going to be there.

That was precisely and entirely the point.

But I began to understand what the outcomes had looked like in practice, in my kitchen, in my bed, in every conversation that ended when Jonas decided it was ended.

In every decision that came home to me already made, fully formed, requiring only my compliance and not my participation.

In every moment I had reached toward a question or an opinion or a need I thought might be worth naming and felt the wall that had always been there.

Solid, invisible, perfectly constructed, mine to navigate around for as long as I lived inside it, but never permitted to be examined directly.

Never permitted to be named for what it was.

There is a word for walls you cannot name.

The word is furniture.

You learn to move around them.

You stop seeing them as barriers and start seeing them as simply the shape of the room.

You organize your life around them so naturally for so many years that you forget there was ever a time when the wall was not there and you cannot imagine what the room might have looked like without it.

The wall had a name now.

That was the only thing that had changed.

But the naming was everything.

My friend Miriam Bontrager had been married 3 years before me.

Her husband Aaron was a careful, quiet man who built furniture of a quality that people in the district talked about for years.

The joints were perfect.

The finish was even.

He was meticulous about everything he put his hands to, including his marriage.

She told me years after we had both left that she had noticed something in the first weeks of her marriage that she could never find the right words for.

Certainty in Aaron’s certainty.

Not arrogance.

Certainty.

He knew how things were to be done.

He knew what was permitted.

He knew the edges of things in a way that had surprised her, given that he was 22 years old and had never been a husband before.

She had attributed it to character, to the careful, measured way he moved through everything.

She had spent 15 years and a single conversation with her sister-in-law understanding where that certainty had actually come from.

It had been handed to him in a room by older men in the week after his wedding.

The same week she had spent washing their new household linens and arranging the kitchen the way she thought a kitchen ought to be arranged, full of small, private decisions she believed were hers to make.

She told me that when she understood this, she sat across the supper table from Aaron at a completely ordinary supper on an ordinary evening and could not find the man she had married inside the institution she was suddenly able to see clearly.

They had been the same thing to her for 15 years.

The man and the institution inseparable, making them two distinct things, held apart from each other, examined separately, was the loneliest work she had ever done.

Because once you see them separately, you cannot go back.

You can choose to stay.

You can find reasons to stay, but you cannot unsee what you have seen.

I understood that without needing her to explain it further.

Here is what I need to say about Jonas because this part matters.

Jonas was not a cruel man.

He had not designed this system.

He had not sat down and thought carefully about power.

He had been born into the architecture the same way I had been, and he had been handed a role and a room and a set of words about how to inhabit his own life, and he had done what you do with such things.

He had stepped into them.

He did not know that what he was handed in that room was something I had not been offered.

He did not know that the certainty he walked home with through the mud was a certainty I had never been given and would never be given.

He came home.

He sat down.

He ate his oatmeal.

And I turned back to the stove.

We were both in that kitchen on that November morning enacting something that had been decided before either of us understood what we were deciding.

That is the whole weight of what I need you to understand.

Not cruelty, normality, not one man’s choices.

A structure so old and so total that it required no enforcers because everyone inside it was already doing what they had been shaped to do and calling it faithfulness and meaning it with every quiet, obedient, carefully trained part of themselves.

After I left, I found a therapist two counties away, a woman with reading glasses on a cord around her neck who asked questions in a direct way I was not used to.

In our third session, she asked me to tell her about the first week of my marriage.

I told her about Jonas leaving before breakfast, his good shirt, the mud, the horses left in the barn.

Turning back to the stove.

She asked, “What did you feel standing at that window watching him go?”

I said, “Nothing. I did not believe I was allowed to feel anything about it.”

She was quiet for a moment.

Then she said, “That is the sentence I want you to sit with this week, not what you felt, what you believed you were permitted to feel.”

Those are two different questions.

One is about your emotions.

The other is about who you believed had authority over them.

I have thought about that distinction every day since.

Because what I came to understand slowly over the months that followed was that the meeting in that room had not only set terms for my marriage, it had set terms for my inner life, what I was permitted to want, what I was permitted to question, what I was permitted to feel in response to my own daily experience of my own existence.

The walls of a room I had never entered had extended outward invisibly into every room I ever lived in.

My therapist said something I have written down and read many times over.

She said, “A decision made about a woman in a room she was never permitted to enter does not become acceptable by being old. Age is not the same thing as rightness. Custom is not the same thing as consent.”

My daughters are grown now.

One of them was married two years ago, not Amish.

Her wedding was on a Saturday in May outdoors, and she had written her own vows, and her husband stood across from her and said things back to her that made him cry in front of everyone watching.

That evening, I sat in a folding chair with iced tea in my hands, and I thought, “No one is meeting about her tomorrow morning. No room, no conversation she was not part of, no certainty being handed to him tonight about what he is permitted to require of her life.”

I sat there and I thought about 19-year-old me at the window watching Jonas walk away down the bare November lane.

I thought about how certain I had been that not asking was faithfulness, that the shape of my life was simply the natural shape of a wife’s life, and not the direct outcome of a meeting I had not been told was taking place in a room I had not been told existed, producing outcomes I had not been permitted to know were outcomes, and not simply the nature of things.

I thought about the oatmeal, the bread, the chickens fed, the whole ordinary machinery of that morning I had moved through while men sat together in someone’s warm kitchen and drew the lines around my life.

Not because I was foolish, not because I was incapable of seeing clearly, because I had been given from the first morning I was old enough to understand anything at all exactly the beliefs I would need in order to never think to ask the question.

The system had not needed to lock a door.

It had only needed to ensure I never learned there was one.

If you grew up in a world where the terms of your own life were decided in rooms you were never invited to enter, I see you.

If you spent years mistaking a wall for your own character, I see you.

If you called your silence faithfulness because no one ever told you that your silence was the whole point of the design, I see you.

What was decided about you without your presence was not your failing.

It was never your failing.

It was a system and you were not a flaw in it.

You were exactly what it had been built to contain.

Disclaimer: This story is fictional and created for entertainment purposes only. Any names, characters, places, or events are fictitious or used fictitiously. No real person or organization is intended to be portrayed.

Related Articles