What a Hutterite Gets When He Leaves the Colony.

What a Hutterite Gets When He Leaves the Colony.

image

Sometimes, when a man decides to leave a Hutterite colony, he comes to my office first.

He wants to know what he is owed.

I keep the books here.

I know what this colony is worth, down to the last hog and the last bushel in the bins.

And I have to tell him the answer the Supreme Court of Canada gave in 1970, nothing.

Twice that answer was tested in court.

The first time the men who tested it lost everything.

The second time, a man won at the Supreme Court, and it did not help him at all.

And that man had my job.

My name is Andreas Wirth.

I am a Hutterite, and I keep the books on a colony of 150 people in southern Alberta.

Two things: what a Hutterite actually owns, from the man who writes down everything this colony has, and the two court cases that tested it, the second of which started with a hog feeder and ended with one branch of our church split in half.

Stay with me.

Start with my books, because they are the shortest way to explain it.

In my office, there is a ledger with every acre this colony farms, every machine, every animal, every building, millions of dollars of it.

And there is not one line in that ledger with a man’s name next to it, not mine, not the ministers, nobody’s.

When a man joins this church, he is baptized as an adult by his own choice, and he agrees to the colony’s articles.

And those articles say, in plain words, that a member owns nothing.

Everything belongs to the community.

He gives his working life to it, and in return, the colony gives him everything he needs for the rest of his life.

In the video about taxes, I told you a court once described a Hutterite’s income as the value of what the colony provides for him to live on, or nothing at all.

This is the other side of that same coin.

If you leave, the providing stops, and there is no share to take with you, because there never was a share.

People find that hard to believe, so somebody had to test it, and somebody did.

In the 1960s, at a colony called Interlake in Manitoba, a group of members, all of them named Hofer, changed their faith.

They had joined a church most people knew from the radio, an American one, called at that time the Radio Church of God.

They stopped coming to our services.

They stopped keeping some of our feast days.

They moved their day of rest to Saturday, and they stopped eating pork.

On a Hutterite colony in Manitoba, a province where, by one count, Hutterites have raised about a third of all the pork.

They were expelled, and they went to court.

And they did not ask for very much, as they saw it.

They asked for their share.

They said the articles they had agreed to were against public policy, and that a rule that makes you give up everything if you change your religion is destructive of the freedom of religion.

If the colony was going to put them out, they wanted their part of what they had helped to build.

They lost at the trial.

They lost on appeal.

And in 1970, they lost at the Supreme Court of Canada.

I have read what the judges wrote, and there are two sentences I want you to hear.

The first was quoted from the trial judge.

To a Hutterian, he wrote, “The whole life is the church.”

He meant that you cannot pull a Hutterite’s work apart from his faith and his property, as if they were three different things.

They are one thing.

When you leave the church, you leave all of it.

The second sentence was from the Chief Justice of Canada himself.

“One of the liberties chiefly prized by a normal man,” he wrote, “is the liberty to bind himself.”

Read that again.

The court did not say these men were forced into anything.

It said the opposite.

It said they were free men who had freely made a promise, and that a free country should let a man make that promise and hold him to it.

I agree with that.

I made the same promise.

I remember the morning I was baptized.

I was a grown man, and nobody made me do it, and I knew exactly what I was giving up, because I had watched other men give it up before me.

But I want to be fair, because one of the judges did not agree.

He dissented and his argument as it is usually summed up was this.

If leaving costs a man everything he has ever worked for, is he really free to leave at all?

I think about that judge more than I would like to because I have watched a young man stand in front of my desk with one bag asking me a question I already knew the answer to and I have thought, that judge had a point.

So that was settled, 1970.

A Hutterite who leaves or who is put out has no claim to a share.

The highest court in the country had said so.

And for almost 20 years, that was the end of it.

Then came the hog feeder.

Lakeside Colony is a small colony just west of Winnipeg built mostly around one extended family.

Its secretary, the man who kept its books, was called Daniel Hofer.

The same family name as the first case, which tells you nothing because Hofer is one of the most common names among our people.

He had my job.

I want you to keep that in mind.

Daniel Hofer was an inventive man.

He worked out a mechanism for a hog feeder and then another Hutterite colony patented a feeder that was very much like it.

That other colony was called Crystal Spring.

And the man at the head of Crystal Spring was also the senior elder of the whole Schmiedeleut, one of the three branches of our church.

The bishop, in other words.

The most senior man Daniel Hofer had above him in the church.

And a hog feeder is not a small thing on a Manitoba colony.

By one account, in the middle of the 1980s, Crystal Spring was earning about $1.4 million a year from hogs, close to a third of everything it earned.

Daniel Hofer said Crystal Spring wanted his design to make back losses on its farming and there had been other losses, too.

In 1982, some colonies there were offered loans at six and a half or 7% at a time when the prime rate was around 18.

It went badly.

By the same account, about $2.5 million was lost, and Crystal Spring’s part of it was $1.25 million.

I will say only this, as a bookkeeper, when somebody offers you money at a third of what everybody else is paying for it, he is not offering you money.

Daniel Hofer said he had invented the mechanism first.

His own colony asked him to stop manufacturing his feeder.

He refused.

And here is where it stops being about a hog feeder.

Because on a colony, refusing is not a business disagreement.

It is disobedience.

The bishop and the other ministers moved to discipline Lakeside.

A committee was put over the colony.

Men were moved out of their positions.

Daniel Hofer, the secretary, was sent to work in the colony’s steel shop.

From my desk to the shop floor, I have thought about that more than once.

Then there was a meeting of the voting members.

He kept on speaking when he was told to stop.

He was asked to leave the room.

It was suggested he be shunned, kept apart at meals and in church.

He was asked to repent, and he would not.

And then he was told something I find very Hutterite and very strange at the same time.

He was told he was expelling himself.

There was no vote, nobody raised a hand.

It was done the way most things here are done, by everybody knowing what everybody thought.

I want you to notice that phrase, because I think it tells you how a colony sees these things.

We do not like to say the church throws a man out.

We say he has put himself out by what he has done, and the church only says so out loud.

That is my reading of it, not the court’s, but it is the way I was raised to hear it.

10 days later there was another meeting.

He was told about that one, and he did not go.

He asked for his case to be heard by a higher body of the church, and then letters came from the colony’s lawyers, telling him and two others they were expelled, and had to be off the colony’s land by a date that fell before that higher meeting.

He did not leave, and neither did his sons.

So, the colony went to court.

You have to understand how unusual that was.

Hutterites do not go to law.

Our teaching is against it.

A Christian magazine wrote at the time that a Hutterite church going to a secular court to enforce its discipline was unprecedented.

And at first, the colony won.

In 1989, a judge in Manitoba ordered Daniel Hofer and his supporters to leave.

The court also ordered them to stay away from several of the colony’s buildings.

One of those buildings was the dining hall.

Think about that.

A man who had eaten in that room every day of his life ordered by a court not to walk into it.

A few days before he had to be gone, he won the right to stay until his appeal was heard.

A professor of religion in Winnipeg said at the time that the Hutterites had started down a road they had never been down before.

He was right, and Daniel Hofer said something to the press that I have never forgotten.

He said he had no intention of leaving his church or his faith, whether he was asked to or forced to.

He did not want to share.

That was the difference from the first case.

He did not want to leave at all.

The Court of Appeal in Manitoba sided with the colony, too, with one judge disagreeing.

Then it went to Ottawa, to the Supreme Court of Canada, the same court that had shut the door on the Interlake men 22 years before.

In October of 1992, it gave its answer, and Daniel Hofer won.

Not on the hog feeder.

The Supreme Court never decided who invented anything.

Not on the faith, either.

The court was careful to say it is slow to step into the question of who belongs to a religious community.

He won on one word, notice.

The court said a man must be told in advance that his expulsion is going to be considered.

He must be told why, and he must be given a fair chance to answer in front of people who have not already made up their minds.

Daniel Hofer had not been given proper notice.

And three of the young people the colony was trying to put out had not been given any notice at all.

The court even said something kind about us along the way.

It said that a long-standing tradition gives a member a kind of notice of what rules his community will follow.

In other words, a Hutterite knows the rules.

But knowing the rules is not the same as being told that today they are about to be used on you.

There is one sentence from that judgment I keep on a piece of paper in my desk drawer.

“Natural justice,” the court wrote, “requires procedural fairness, no matter how obvious the decision to be made may be.”

No matter how obvious.

One judge disagreed, Beverly McLachlin, who later became Chief Justice of Canada.

Her view was that advanced notice is not needed when its purpose has already been served.

Put plainly, he knew exactly what was coming.

And I will admit something.

Part of me thinks she understood colonies better than the men who outvoted her.

On a place like this, nobody is ever surprised.

Everybody knows what is coming weeks before anybody says it.

But the majority was not talking about what a man knows.

It was talking about what he is told.

And the longer I sit at this desk, the more I think that difference matters.

So he won.

The Supreme Court of Canada.

And here is why I told you at the start that it did not help him.

The colony went home and did it again.

Properly this time.

With notice, with the chance to answer, and it expelled them again.

And in 1994, a Manitoba court upheld the second expulsion, and the rule from 1970 still stood.

Those men had lived their whole lives on that colony, and they had no claim to any share of it.

And there is one last turn in the story, and it is the one that tells you the most about our people.

After the second expulsion, the Hofers never went to court to claim a share of the colony.

The law professor who studied the case says it was because their faith, the same faith as the colonies, forbids that kind of lawsuit.

The colony had taken them to court for their share.

They would not take the colony to court in return.

But by then, it had stopped being about Lakeside.

The fight over that one small colony became a fight over the bishop and over who had authority over whom.

And it split the Schmiedeleut down the middle.

Two groups where there had been one.

People still call them group one and group two.

Colonies divided.

Families divided.

Cousins who had grown up in each other’s kitchens ended up on opposite sides.

And it did not stay polite.

At one point, one Hutterite colony was suing another over the patent.

The police were drawn in.

Several law offices in Winnipeg were kept busy for years.

A people whose teaching is against going to law had found its way into nearly every part of the law there is.

And at times, there was violence.

A law professor in Manitoba, the same one, spent years going through every court file and every church letter from those years.

His name is Alvin Esau, and he put it all in a book called “The Courts and the Colonies.”

His conclusion, as I understand it, was that when a court from outside is asked to rule on the law inside a church, it often makes things worse, even for the side that wins.

I want to be plain about where I stand because I am not a neutral man here.

I am Lehrerleut in Alberta.

None of this happened on our branch.

I never met Daniel Hofer.

I do not know who invented that feeder, and as far as I know, no court ever said.

The judge at the first trial threw out the claim of a conspiracy against him, but he also questioned whether it was proper for Crystal Spring to take money from a sister colony over the patent.

That is as close as anybody official came to an answer.

So, here is what I take from it, from this desk.

1970 told us what a Hutterite owns, nothing.

Because he chose to own nothing, and a free country lets a man make that choice.

1992 told us what a Hutterite is owed, not a share, notice, to be told to his face before anybody decides what he is accused of, and to be allowed to answer.

I used to think that was a small thing for the highest court in the country to give a man.

I do not think so anymore because when a young man stands in front of my desk with one bag and asks me what he is owed, I cannot give him a share.

There is no line in my ledger with his name on it, but I can do the one thing the Supreme Court said every one of us is owed.

I sit him down.

I do not hurry him.

I do not pretend there is a form he can fill in or a number I can look up for him, and I tell him the truth before he goes, all of it.

What he will leave with, which is nothing, and what he will leave behind, which is everything.

That is notice.

It is the only thing I have to give.

And has anybody ever told you something hard, plainly and in advance, when it would have been easier for them to say nothing?

There is a ledger on my desk with every acre and every animal this colony owns, and not one line in it has a man’s name.

Disclaimer: This story is fictional and created for entertainment purposes only. Any names, characters, places, or events are fictitious or used fictitiously. No real person or organization is intended to be portrayed.

Related Articles