The Hutterite Punishment Where Nobody Speaks to You.

The Hutterite Punishment Where Nobody Speaks to You.

image

On a Hutterite colony, there is no police, no fine, and no jail.

Nobody is paid, so nobody can be docked a day’s wages.

There is only one thing the colony can take away from a man, his peace.

When the church takes a man’s peace, he eats alone.

He does not sit with the others in church.

Nobody shakes his hand.

He goes on working, but he works alone.

It can last a week.

It can last much longer.

And when it ends well, it ends only one way, with the man standing up in front of the whole congregation.

In 1992, the Supreme Court of Canada had to decide whether a Hutterite colony had done this properly to one of its own members.

Six judges to one, they said it had not.

My name is Andreas Wirth.

I am a Hutterite and I keep the books on a colony of 150 people in southern Alberta.

Two things, how a colony punishes its own people, step by step, from a quiet word with the minister to the thing we call Unfrieden, and how a man is taken back.

And then the case that took our way of punishing all the way to the highest court in the country, what the judges said, and the part of this that I think we have sometimes got badly wrong.

Stay with me.

Start with the word, because the word explains everything.

In our dialect, it is Unfrieden.

In German, Unfrieden.

A Hutterite who writes a blog about our life translated it the simplest way, unpeace.

A historian in Manitoba, writing in 1960, put it the way the old people say it.

In serious cases, he wrote, the congregation takes his peace.

I want you to think about what that means in a place like mine.

I do not own my house.

I do not own the truck I drive or the desk I sit at.

I am not paid.

A Hutterite has given up almost everything a man outside would use to measure his life.

What he has left is that he is at peace with every person he eats with, three times a day, for the rest of his life.

So that is what the church takes.

Now, the ladder, because it is a ladder, and almost nobody gets near the top of it.

The anthropologist John Hostetler, who spent much of his life studying us, described it as a progression of sanctions.

It starts with a reproach in private.

Then, if that does not work, a hearing before the council.

Then exclusion.

And at the end, if all goes the way it is meant to, reinstatement.

The historian in Manitoba gave more steps.

First, he wrote, “Generally, a visit from the minister persuades the person to conform.”

Most things end there.

A man has done something he should not have.

The minister comes to see him.

They talk, and that is the end of it.

Often, nobody else ever knows.

If it is more serious, the congregation takes his peace.

He is shunned.

The word for that is Meidung, avoidance.

He is isolated, the historian wrote, whether at work or at the table.

He may even be given living quarters apart from his family.

If he will not make his peace, he can be put under the ban.

And at the very end, there is exclusion from the colony itself.

The historian added that there are only a few instances of that in our whole history.

When the Supreme Court of Canada described it, the judge who wrote for the majority put it in plain words.

“Forms of punishment in the Hutterite community,” he wrote, “are all based on the exclusion of the offending person. The offending person may not be allowed to sit with the others in church or at meals. And at its most severe, the exclusion may be almost complete.”

Exclusion.

Not pain.

Not money.

Just being left out of the room where everybody else is.

What does it look like?

The best description I have found was written by an American researcher who stayed on a colony in Minnesota in the late ’90s.

A young man there was put under this kind of discipline.

For about a week, his meals and his lodging were provided apart from the colony dining hall.

Then he made confession of his wrongdoing before the congregation, the researcher wrote, and was at once fully reintegrated into colony life.

At once.

That is the part outsiders never believe.

And the same researcher noted something else.

In that colony’s 20 years, shunning had been used only once.

One more thing the judge wrote, which I think is the key to all of it.

The punishment, he said, is offered to the person, and the person is expected to accept it.

He is supposed to take it and to answer it with repentance and in the end, reconciliation.

If he refuses, he is said to excommunicate himself.

Read that again.

In our understanding, the church does not throw a man out.

A man who will not accept being set aside for a while has thrown himself out.

So, who decides?

On a colony, the baptized men vote.

The minister is the one who disciplines, and he is held to the church like everybody else.

Our own church’s website says a minister must be responsible for teaching, disciplining, the ban, and other duties.

Most decisions are made by talking until there is agreement.

The Supreme Court noticed that, too.

Hutterite meetings, it wrote, tend to work by reaching consensus, rather than always taking formal votes.

Remember that sentence, because it is what lost a colony the case.

And what gets a man into trouble?

The historian in Manitoba, in 1960, listed the small things.

Young men buying a radio or a musical instrument against the colony rules.

A cigarette.

Those were for the minister’s visit, not for the ban.

The serious things are disobeying the leaders of the colony, refusing to stop doing something the church has told you to stop, and leaving.

Leaving is the heaviest.

John Hostetler wrote that two offenses cannot be forgiven in our tradition.

Shedding the blood of another and deserting the colony.

I am going to come back to that, because not every Hutterite agrees with how it is put.

And children, none of this is for them.

Our own church’s website says the ban is for baptized members who fall into sin again and again.

A child has not promised anything yet, so the church has no piece of his to take.

Children are handled the old way.

An encyclopedia of family life says that young Hutterite children are thought of as willful and that strict punishment, including the strap, is used and that it stops in the teenage years.

And a historian noticed that we allow young men a certain amount of misbehaving before they are baptized.

He called it going up fool’s hill.

I went a little way up it myself and my father pretended not to see.

It is not new, any of this.

Our own chronicle, written in Moravia in the 1500s, describes the early communities.

The brotherhood banned and punished, it says, each according to his sin.

And the next line, when they showed true repentance, they were reaccepted into the church.

And it is in the promises we make when we are baptized.

One of them says that a member must submit to and follow brotherly warning, admonition, and discipline so that nobody becomes co-guilty in the sins of another.

That is the idea underneath all of it.

If I see my brother doing wrong and say nothing, I share it with him.

Discipline, the way we were taught it, is not one man punishing another.

It is a whole people refusing to let one of their own go quietly bad.

Now, how a man comes back.

A historian who has written several books about us, described it this way.

Members who do something wrong in a Hutterite colony admit it.

They stand up in front of the church, show repentance and humility, and the ritual is over.

The sin forgiven and forgotten.

The process, he wrote, is highly programmed.

Everyone knows exactly what is going to happen.

Our catechism says the ministers remit the sins of the repentant sinner and accept them again into the communion of saints.

I have seen it done once, properly, on the colony where I grew up.

I was a young man, just baptized.

A man I will not name had done something that was not very much, but he had done it in front of everybody, and he would not say he was wrong.

So, for some days his plate went to his house, and his place on the bench in the dining hall was empty, and nobody filled it.

Nobody spoke about it, either.

That was the strangest part.

30 men at the table and one gap, and not one word.

Then, on a Sunday, he stood up in church.

He did not say much.

The minister did not say much.

And at dinner that day, he walked into the dining hall and sat down in his old place, and the man beside him passed him the bread without looking up, as if he had passed it to him the day before.

That was it.

Nobody ever mentioned it again.

I have thought about that bread for 30 years.

Now, the case.

In the late 1980s, at a colony called Lakeside, west of Winnipeg in Manitoba, there was a man named Daniel Hofer.

He was the colony secretary, which is not so different from what I do.

He had worked out a mechanism for a livestock feeder, and he said he had invented it.

Another colony held a patent on something similar.

Hofer accused people at that colony of taking his design.

His own colony told him to stop making it.

He refused.

At a meeting of the colony, he was asked to leave, and it was suggested that he be shunned at meals and at worship.

When he would not repent, he was told that he was expelling himself.

No vote was taken.

It was done the way most things on a colony are done, by everybody agreeing.

Hofer asked for a higher court, a hearing before the ministers of the wider church.

Then the colony’s lawyers sent him letters telling him he was expelled and had to leave by a date that came before that hearing was due.

He did not leave, and the colony, a Hutterite colony, went to the courts of the world to have him removed.

Think about that.

In the old days, a historian wrote, a man who was asked to leave and would not was shunned and left alone.

Now a colony was asking the state to carry him out.

The colony won at the trial in 1989 and again at the court of appeal.

And then the Supreme Court of Canada heard it, and on the 29th of October 1992, the colony lost.

The judges did not say the colony was wrong to want him gone.

They said it was not their business to decide that.

What they asked was whether the colony had followed its own rules.

And the colony’s own rules said a member could be expelled at a meeting by a majority vote.

There had been no vote, and Hofer had never been properly told what he was accused of or given a fair chance to answer it.

Justice Gonthier wrote one sentence I have read many times since.

“Natural justice requires procedural fairness, no matter how obvious the decision to be made may be.”

One judge disagreed.

Justice McLachlin, who later became the Chief Justice of Canada, saw it the way most of my people would have.

The man had expelled himself.

No notice was needed.

It did not end there.

The colony held its meetings again, properly this time, and expelled the group again.

And in 1994, a court in Manitoba allowed the colony to evict them.

So, the colony lost in Ottawa and won in the end.

But it lost something else.

The quarrel at Lakeside was tangled up with a much bigger one over the leadership of that whole branch of our church, the Schmiedeleut.

In 1992, the same year as the judgment, the Schmiedeleut split in two.

Our own church’s website calls it a tragic division made worse because shunning was used between the two sides.

Colonies whose families had married into each other for generations stopped worshipping together.

A scholar who wrote a whole book about our court cases counted about a dozen lawsuits in Canada and the United States.

And there was an older case.

In 1970, members of a colony in Manitoba who had joined another church were expelled and sued for their share of the colony.

The Supreme Court said they had no share.

One of the liberties chiefly prized by a normal man, the Chief Justice wrote, is the liberty to bind himself.

So, the courts have told us two things.

If you promise to give everything to the church, the promise holds.

But, if the church wants to put you out, it has to do it fairly.

Now, the part we have got wrong.

Unfrieden only works if the man accepts it.

A Hutterite writing about it online said exactly that.

At its best, he wrote, it is a way for a believer to be restored to full membership.

At its worst, it can be a soul-crushing device that an ungodly or unwise leader can use to manipulate the people.

And he said the shunning he had seen was shaped by personality clashes and family feuds.

Somebody answering him put it shorter.

It must be used towards willing participants or it loses its value.

A Hutterite woman named Carol Mandel wrote on our own church’s website that in some colonies, the leaders do take advantage of the power they have been given.

In 2003, a newspaper went to a colony in Alberta called Ponderosa, where a family had fallen out with the leadership.

Members had been told to shun one man and have no communication with him whatsoever.

Another said he was under house arrest.

A woman said her own sister did not talk to her.

A judge ordered one of them reinstated because he had been expelled without a proper hearing.

And the judge added that his ruling might not solve the family’s problems and might even make them worse.

At least 30 people had left that colony in a little over a year.

That is not what I saw at that dining table when I was young.

That is what it becomes when the people doing it have forgotten what it is for.

And about leaving being unforgivable, Carol Mandel wrote that, too.

“I have never been taught,” she said, “that if I leave the colony, I will go to hell.”

Neither have I, not in those words, but I know men who believe it, and I know the weight it puts on a young man who is thinking of going.

So, here is what I think.

A punishment made of silence is the gentlest punishment in the world when it is used rarely by people who love you for a few days with the door open.

It is one of the cruelest when it is used for a quarrel about who is in charge.

The difference is not in the rule.

It is in the men using it.

And the Supreme Court, I think, understood that better than we did in 1992.

They did not tell us how to judge our own people.

They only told us to do it fairly.

Has anybody ever stopped speaking to you as a punishment in a family, a workplace, a church?

Did it bring you back or push you further away?

And if you had been one of those judges in 1992, would you have sided with the colony or with the man?

Until then, on our colony, when a man is taken back, nobody says, “Welcome back.”

Somebody passes him the bread.

Disclaimer: This story is fictional and created for entertainment purposes only. Any names, characters, places, or events are fictitious or used fictitiously. No real person or organization is intended to be portrayed.

Related Articles